Drowned in Sound

Search



pmfs up in them guts
no votes
?
by Mat Hocking
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 26/07/2004
  • Label: No Idea
Something which many people link with Denver-based Planesmistakenforstars is both outright passion and fervent energy, both live and on record. Anyone who caught them live with pop-rockers The Ataris last year surely can not dispute this for they are definitely one of the most feverishly intense punk outfits to have graced our stages for some time (– returning with October File in January and a few months later with Converge).

But listening to their latest album ‘Up in Them Guts’, one wonders whether such tiresome expressionism is really needed, vocally at least. For as head-splittingly intense as it is with tumbledown riffage clattering about from each track to the next it’s the vocals that you’re constantly at odds with as you make your way through. It’s a huskier, fuzzier and more furious Planes than that which released the ‘Fuck With Fire’ LP two years ago, vocalist/guitarist Gared O’Donnell admitting to a progression which has since seen them “get better at being heavy”. Yet by the end of tracks like ‘Glassing’ and ‘Say Not A Word’ you feel aurally dishevelled, trying your hardest to unscramble a message ravaged by unnecessary vocal layering and miasmic reverb.

It’s there, the passion and energy, but it just doesn’t appear to flow with the music, O’ Donnell sounding out of breath as he musters lethargic screams into the mic, whilst secretly praying the song finishes before he collapses in a wheezy heap on the floor.

Not that I’m saying they don’t succeed at what they do. Indeed, this is their trademark sound, one that has spearheaded the No Idea style of punk and which is captured perfectly by the extraordinary talents of A.J. Mogis (Cursive, Get Up Kids…). But to these ears all that’s assimilated is a squalling wreck, caused mainly by Gared’s vocals that blur and grate against admittedly fairly decent punk rock. They're characteristic of this style, of course, but when it chokes the album of it's punch, it's heat, I'm afraid that's when things start to get unlistenable.

Still, nice artwork though.

  • Planes Mistaken For Stars 4 / 10
Words: Mat Hocking

Planes Mistaken For Stars - Up In Them Guts

Is Fuck With Fire not an album?

Re: Planes Mistaken For Stars - Up In Them Guts

Indeed. My mistake. I own the EP released on Ignition, but yes it is an album too.

Re: Planes Mistaken For Stars - Up In Them Guts

D'oh!
That's 'Fucking Fight'.
Two-track old EP re-released last year.
'Fuck With Fire' is their bad-fucking-ass album on No Idea.

Planes Mistaken For Stars - Up In Them Guts

Everyone who I talked to said they were terrible supporting The Ataris - and these were people there for Planes, not The sodding Ataris.

Definitely go see them with Converge in March (or whenever it is) though...oooooh yes.

Re: Planes Mistaken For Stars - Up In Them Guts

They were okay when I saw them, but the Astoria's hardly their stage, is it.

Planes Mistaken For Stars - Up In Them Guts

pah, the vocals are essential to planes' greatness, they feel so lived in and careworn that they give emotional heft to a lot of the tracks. They also allow the lyrical pull of the music to coalesce around just a few phrases, with the rest becoming clear over subsequent listens - which is great.

and live - i've seen them in the derby vic twice, and both times they've slayed. It's their kind of venue, intimate, dirty, raw, punk...




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Primavera Sound 2008: DiS diary, day two