Drowned in Sound

Search


Home > Reviews > Live


Roddy Woomble Idlewild Live
no votes
?
by Lianne Steinberg
On the surface, this would seem an immensely pretentious concept. From the lanterns to the cockeyed lamp shades, and the piano holding the glasses of red wine, the overwhelming feel of tonight is that of a louche Manhattan lounge.

It’s a world away from the last time Idlewild stepped on to the stage in Manchester, supporting Coldplay at the Evening News Arena. Back then, post-traumatic stress was kicking in after the departure of bassist Bob Fairfoull and it was clear that the Nissan Almera-owning audience weren’t there to be swayed by the shy, skinny frame of Roddy Woomble when Chris Martin and co were waiting in the wings.

However, bolstered by the addition of two new members – the jovial Gavin Fox on bass and guitarist Allan Stewart, Woomble has taken on a new confidence. Striding across the stage with his jeans tucked into his boots (“I was told last night in Glasgow that I looked like a camp builder”), he has finally developed into a poised frontman, no longer turning his back on the audience, but bantering with us and making his case for this, Idlewild’s experimental acoustic tour.

Purists may bemoan the fact that Woomble refuses to hark back to the days when they were a rollickingly fast fireball of chaos, but it’s been several years now since the calm set in and the REM comparisons started. On the strength of these acoustic re-workings, it’s baffling that the band didn’t become household names years ago. Re-discovered after a period of respite, ‘When I Argue I See Shapes’ opens their set and even without guitarist Rod Jones yelping "shapes" behind Woomble’s deeply rich voice, the song still maintains plaintive resonance.

Woomble’s interesting sense of style, his flowing locks and his new-found swagger, may be attributed to the fact that he’s recently taken up residence in New York. However, new tune ‘Welcome Home’ hints that Woomble has never really felt comfortable in his bluey-tinged Scottish skin. Similarly with ‘Disconnected’; rather than falling around a simple lyrical hook, the implication with forthcoming album, Warnings/Promises is that he’s become a crafty wordsmith.

With Jenny Reeve on violin and drummer Colin Newton stripped of the kit, the emphasis is on the bare bones of the songs. Newton occasionally uncomfortably fumbles with his tambourine, or shakers, but his skills on the piano and accordian shouldn’t be underestimated. The likes of ‘Little Discourage’ and ‘Live In A Hiding Place’ justify Woomble’s summation of the band’s back catalogue as “a collection of mournful ballads”. If anything, this isn’t so much a preview of new material but a show of strength and consequence from a band that have deservedly been voted third in a poll of the best Scottish bands of all time.

Post a new comment on this review

Idlewild

sounds like a great night , cant wait to see them and hear the new album

but admit it, you thought his hair looked a little bit silly too when you first saw it

Idlewild

Going to see them in London tomorrow, hope that will be just as good, still not sure how to react to a sit down Idlewild gig, When I Argue I See Shapes acoustic to begin with will set the tone though.

Idlewild

My word! London was enchanting. Majestic. Roddy as drunk on life as ever. They even played Self Healer.... El Capitan is going to be an absolutely massive single.

Some utterly rude people critising Roddy's hair of all things. Musta felt quite exposed for him to not have his usual duvet of noise. Am so sick of the idlewild purists.

Re: Idlewild

I liked it too, but one of the guys I went with was an utter twat. Then he had the AUDACITY to buy me chicken nuggets!

I ♥ you really Sean

Re: Idlewild

El Capitan sounded great, my favourite of the new ones. The Bronze Medal was beautiful and Safe And Sound worked surprisingly well the way that they did it

Re: Idlewild

El Capitan is wonderful and came across extremely well last night.

Couldn't agree more.

Re: Idlewild

See the track that I told you was my favourite on the album last night, that'll be El Capitan. I have the excellent habit of liking the most miserable track on the album before I realise how depressing the words are. Must be my manics fan knack.

To be fair though, he needs a haircut, bless im.

x

Re: Idlewild

Goth.
(Absolutely beautiful gig last night, all sparkly and warm and.. just lovely.)

Idlewild

this was such a beautiful gig, so different to usual. whilst i missed the heavier numbers (particularly of 100 broken windows which i love, roseability, idea track etc.), the new songs sounded great, especially 'el capitan'. and just how good was 'when i argue...'
dog

Idlewild

el capitan was stunning wasnt it? I've just heard the version on the album and it's just as good, especially when it gets all placid at the end - 'looking at pictures in the distance...'




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - DiScover: David Karsten Daniels