Drowned in Sound

Search



no votes
?
by Rob Webb
In Portuguese, the title of this Illinois quartet's second album means 'of new' but there's nothing here that fits that description. From Dylan to The 'Stones and Bowie to The Beatles, The Redwalls have pilfered unashamedly. No wonder Oasis picked them as tour support for their recent nationwide jaunt.

But where the Gallagher brothers inject a bit of bluster into their take on the 60s, The Redwalls' sound fails to hold the attention. Opener 'Robinson Crusoe' borrows a riff from Bowie's 'Heroes',teams it with a nasal whine and falls flat on its face because the end result sounds more like Jet than Ziggy.

Unfortunately, that sets the tone for the rest of the LP. The slower numbers ('Hung Up On The Way I'm Feeling' and 'How The Story Goes') will grate with anybody who possesses a pulse and a pair of ears and its only when The Redwalls play with a sense of abandon on songs like 'On My Way' and 'It's Alright' that things start to pick up (probably because it's harder to hear Logan Baren's vocals).

With couplets like "the world keeps turning around / it's bringing me down" and "it's all up and down with the weather / we was glad to hear you're feeling so much better", you see can why they might feel the need to crank up the volume.

But even those two songs fail to hide The Redwalls' basic limitations. They may have a more-than-half-decent set of influences but they seemingly lack the imagination to make the music their own.

  • The Redwalls 5 / 10
Words: Rob Webb

The Redwalls - De Nova

hahhaha its crap

The Redwalls - De Nova

It didn't even deserve this, BLATES!

this record is one of the most shocking I have ever had the misfortune to hear.

If the Redwalls were the Beatles, and they're most definitely not, they would all be Paul McCartney.

It's that dire.

The Redwalls - De Nova

it sure is a more accurate review I feel:
http://www.giittv.hypnotisingsilence.net/reviews/redwalls.htm

Re: The Redwalls - De Nova

given that it's on your site, you would wouldn't you...




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - DiS meets Panda Bear: "I feel like the music I like the best is exclusively pop stuff"