Can anyone fill me in who was in this list? However much people hate lists, it's always interesting to see who is at the top - like that stupid Observer Music Monthly British album one. Yeah, of course Stone Roses is the best British album ever.
that list is a fucking joke. pete cool? the others cool? thats where i am gonig wrong - i gotta start smoking crack!!!
arrgghhhh !!!! makes me so angry!
It's shit. I love NME's response to the claims of glamourising drugs...'the list is based on musical ability' when they clearly state that it's all about the image and attitude!
I was talking about the list with one of my mates, it made me laugh when he said it was a joke kele was in it. "He looks like hes posing for a university broshure in that picture". Ive just realised how uncool we are, get down army and navy get your fleece now kids!!!!!!!!!!
Not that I've ever paid that much attention to who the NME says is "cool", but I think this year's list is the worst of the two of three previous ones there have been; it just seems to be full of people from no-mark guitar bands who are only cool by virtue of the fact the play the Barfly twice a week, or some similarly twisted logic. Before, at least they had a couple of people who've done something more interesting than take heroin...club owners (that Erol Alkan blokey), producers, etc.
full list {according to some bloke on a message board} is:
50 Graham Coxon
49 Alan Donohoe, The Rakes
48 The Game
47 Sam Forrest Nine Black Alps
46 Mike H, The Bravery
45 Thom Yorke, Radiohead
44 Eddie Argos, Art Brut
43 Joanna Newsom
42 Nic Offer, !!!
41 Si
40 Bob Smith, the Cure
39 Charlotte Hatherly
38 Paul Epworth
37 Greg Oliver Fierce Girl
36 Victoria Bergsman, The Concretes
35 Ricky Wilson Kaiser Chiefs
34 Sam Herlihy, Hope of the States
33 Willy Mason
32 Jamelia
31 Karen O Yeah yeah yeahs
30 John Linger Neils Children
29 Murry Lightburn The dears
28 Abi Harding The Zutons
27 Albert Hammond Jr The Strokes
26 Jack White
25 Dizzee Rascal
24 Matt Bellamy
23 Liela Moss The duke spirit
22 Billie Joe Armstong
21 Ross Millard The Futureheads
20 Serge Pizzorno Kasabian
19 Gwen Stefani
18 Devenda Banhart
17 Meg White
16 Carlos D Interpol
15 Kyp Malone TV on the Radio
14Kim Deal
13 Andre 3000
12 The Maggot GLC
11 Dom Masters The Others
10 Ana Matronic Scissor Sisters
9 Martin Tomlinson Selfish Cunt
8 Brandon Flowers TheKillers
7 Kele Okereke Bloc Party
6 Morrisey
5 Nick McCarthy Franz Ferdinand
4 Jonny Borrell Razorlight
3 Eminem
2 Mike Skinner
1 Pete n Carl
Couple of questions here.
1, Who is 'Si'?
2, Seriously, GLC, cool?
3, A member of Kasabian? Really? Homophobic, 80's throwbacks from the uncoolest city on the planet.
4, Selfish Cunt? How on earth are they/he cool?
5, What, or who, is 'The Game'?
6, Who's Paul Epworth?
7, Neils Children? The Rakes? The Others? What on earth is remotely cool about these people?!
I'm obviously out of touch with the cool reality. Maybe I suck. But that list can do one.
Yeah but although his work with Bloc Party is good, his work with the Futureheads isn't quite up to scratch. Andy Gill was working on the Futureheads album before him and he's much more talented
I think Paul Epworth's production of the Futurehead's album is great.
Have you got the Futureheads' Andy Gill-produced EP's on fantastic plastic? Copare them to the Epworth-produced tracks on the album and you will see that Epworth wins hands down.
Gill may be a very talented guitarist and songwriter in Gang of Fourm but talented producer - not so sure...
The list is a fucking joke BUT not as bad a one as last year. May I remind you Justin Timberlake was no 1 last year. And Matt Bellamy in the cool list? Muse are my favorite band because they dont need lists like this.
Hmm I just remembered, NME's choice of the Rev JT at the top last year was because he did no wrong. Explain the two wankers from the Shittertines (couldn't think of anything offensive) then.
its a load of shite, but it allways gets people talking, so thats why they do it. but the talk always tends to revolve around "what a fucking pile of rotten shite, who the fuck do they think they are", but still, it gets strong reactions.
does anyone not know who or what 'the game' is then? i take it isnt the wrestler.
Cos they were idiots. Not all bands know what's best for them. Look at Jonny 'Twat' Borell of Razorlight producing his own album and ruining it (their b-sides are amazing, the album sadly isn't). I think Gill's production gave em a rawer sound. The quality of the First Day single (which he produced) is excellent. Epworth defibitely works for the Bloc, but not for the Heads imho.
Although I agree with you about Borell being a twat, sadly you are a misguided fool. You are one of few people who actually rate Gill's production work. When I first heard the 123Nul ep i couldnt believe it was the same band i had seen live. Absolute cowboy job.
Soulless,calculated,banal and his approach nearly destroyed the band. I bet you rate the libertine's production too.
Many moons I ago, I used to respect NME for their unswerving dedication to slate every single piece of music Biffy Clyro ever released. But then they gave the new album 8/10. And now this? Simon from BC on the "cool list"? Fuck that.
I imagine the hologram cover is a result of all the money they've made selling Pete Doherty smack so they can then write weekly stories about Pete Doherty's smack addiction. Shit...CONSPIRACY!
I think it was sponsored by some mobile phone company, 'cos the phone advert on the back was hologramified...and there was a picture on the front of a phone, with an arrow pointing you round the back. My friend said "Pete has reached new lows...now he's appearing in mobile ads to pay for his drug habit." :-)
I understand you were just pipped at the post by Jamelia, oceanRain. It was close though. If only you were a black, attractive, young, British, slightly overrated but still acer than a lot of British tosh, sould singer. Close.
I saw the NME last night, and contemplated buying it for the first time in a couple of months. Then I flicked through it and realised it had nothing that could keep me entertained. Seriously, how downhill can one magazine go. It's a shame.
But I still stand by the fact that I am a damn site cooler than at least half of the people on that list, and I'm not joking.
oh how the sound of impotent misdirected anger and furrowed brows burdens my soul.......
It is supposed to be entertainment kids
The hacks at NME are a decent bunch with (mostly) good taste. The editor however is not.
Cool is uncool. Uncool is cool.
It really doesn't matter.
ps: if you want to use all your resentment for a good cause, then write to Mr. B-liar and ask him why the leaves on the trees are still green in the first week of december. I'm sure his pals at Shell and Esso have a few answers.
There are more important things to worry about than global warming, we've got to decide once and for all whether Boris Becker is cooler than Sandi Tokhsvig.
Didn't want to be the one pissing in the wind but there is not a leaf left on the trees outside my window. Surely Esso don't employ someone to stick false green leaves on trees in the winter, do they?
NME says Crack is cool. C'mon kids, it's ok, it's good for you, it makes you look and act cool. All everyone ever wants to be is cool. Stealing from your friends, that's cool too. Do it. Don't get a job. Don't aspire to anything more than your next fix. You too can cancel gigs your fans have paid to come to. You too can scam money off the government and live in an East End scumhole, get up at 3 in the afternoon, and see yourselve plastered all over the papers. Your dream of being cool has been fulfilled by some hasbeens. And never weres.
It really makes you wonder how much NME understand, let alone define cool. Surely by being in this very list you instantly become uncool? Shouldn't this kinda thing be left to people in the fashion world and the steerers of cool themselves?
Editorial meeting:
"Right, we can't put Pete at Number One, Carl will get really upset."
"Well, why don't we put Carl at Number One?"
"Cos Pete will get upset."
"Wait a minute, i've got a great idea...."
So I take it from the "cool" list that the hive have started muttering about Devendra. Quick Mr Banhart, get back into your hot air balloon. THEY'VE FOUND YOU GODDAMMIT!
I was going to make a joke about me not being on the list or some of the flavor of the month rock stars NME has on this list. But no. This time they've gone too far. Now, I'll preface this by saying I happen to like the Libertines. I like them a lot. But putting Pete (and Carl) as the coolest music star isn't a good idea. Very bad psychology. Praise his work with the Libs. Report ad nauseum his drug spree antics. But validating Pete's drug addled persona in this way is plain wrong, and very likely dangerous.
I can't say why I, personally, got started with dope, and it'd be impossible to pin it on a single reason or two. But I can tell you it has been a motherfucker, with a capital M. It's a jack-in-the-box: it'll let you crank the knob for a while with a pretty carnival tune till all of a sudden jack pops out and by then it's too late... yer just fucked! If yer lucky you'll survive, and I can pretty much guarantee you you're not gonna be on the cover of any magazines! "Children, hear me when I say this: the NME has lied to you. Don't fall for it!"
People are reading too much into this silly nonsense. When since was the NME the be all and end all of anything? i.e decent magazines even? I don't care if Pete and Carl are at plus ten! It peturbed me to read Carl actually wanted to be in it. Pete's rambling cracked me up as ever but winner of seeing it for the mindless nonsense that it is was Eddie Argos of Art Brut and his guinea pig theory. At least he could see that the NME were clearly taking the piss and revelling in their usual frivolity. Yet still people get indignant and het up about nothing. Mooseman - Quote of the thread!
Generally a magazine has to make a cool list to announce which bands are cool because those bands have a total lack of charisma and therefore need their supposed 'cool' to be broadcasted to an expectant nation. 'C'mon you fuckers, we're cool, love us!'
Just leave NME alone. It's for wee lil' kids and young people and is clearly there to be taken as seriously as Tony Dortie was on Top of the Pops. It's inconsequential, websites like this one and Pitchfork do more to promote good new music than NME has done all year.
I saw the ad for this yesterday on the website and felt the need to add my comments. I couldn't believe they wrote that the list had nothing to do with musical ability...excuse me, are you not meant to be a MUSIC MAGAZINE?? Jeez, they've really taken it too far now in the stakes of being shallow.
It was nice to be able to vent to them directly for a change and also tell them to get out the arse of Mr Doherty who's merely an attention seeking twat. I really don't mind the Libertines as a band but I don't think they're amazing and the way the NME goes ON AND ON AND ON makes me almost resentful.
The website's good for breaking tour news etc but other than that they've really lost all credibility in the last couple of years.
I'm tempted to make my life's work a plight to out do the NME with a music magazine that is what it says on the cover.
RIP Melody Maker, XRay and (the old format) Select.
Re: NME Cool list
2. Pete
suprise surprise.
Others were Brandon Flowers, Kele from Bloc Party, annoying one from the Others, Sam HOTS, Ricky Kaiser Chiefs e.t.c....
I do have the NME in my bag but I can't be arsed to get it out and look at the list. Plus I have to pretend I'm working.
Re: NME Cool list
Thanks.
Re: NME Cool list
arrgghhhh !!!! makes me so angry!
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
50 Graham Coxon
49 Alan Donohoe, The Rakes
48 The Game
47 Sam Forrest Nine Black Alps
46 Mike H, The Bravery
45 Thom Yorke, Radiohead
44 Eddie Argos, Art Brut
43 Joanna Newsom
42 Nic Offer, !!!
41 Si
40 Bob Smith, the Cure
39 Charlotte Hatherly
38 Paul Epworth
37 Greg Oliver Fierce Girl
36 Victoria Bergsman, The Concretes
35 Ricky Wilson Kaiser Chiefs
34 Sam Herlihy, Hope of the States
33 Willy Mason
32 Jamelia
31 Karen O Yeah yeah yeahs
30 John Linger Neils Children
29 Murry Lightburn The dears
28 Abi Harding The Zutons
27 Albert Hammond Jr The Strokes
26 Jack White
25 Dizzee Rascal
24 Matt Bellamy
23 Liela Moss The duke spirit
22 Billie Joe Armstong
21 Ross Millard The Futureheads
20 Serge Pizzorno Kasabian
19 Gwen Stefani
18 Devenda Banhart
17 Meg White
16 Carlos D Interpol
15 Kyp Malone TV on the Radio
14Kim Deal
13 Andre 3000
12 The Maggot GLC
11 Dom Masters The Others
10 Ana Matronic Scissor Sisters
9 Martin Tomlinson Selfish Cunt
8 Brandon Flowers TheKillers
7 Kele Okereke Bloc Party
6 Morrisey
5 Nick McCarthy Franz Ferdinand
4 Jonny Borrell Razorlight
3 Eminem
2 Mike Skinner
1 Pete n Carl
Re: NME Cool list
I hate it when people go on about how cool Jamelia and co are - 'great pop artists'. Shut up.
Re: NME Cool list
1, Who is 'Si'?
2, Seriously, GLC, cool?
3, A member of Kasabian? Really? Homophobic, 80's throwbacks from the uncoolest city on the planet.
4, Selfish Cunt? How on earth are they/he cool?
5, What, or who, is 'The Game'?
6, Who's Paul Epworth?
7, Neils Children? The Rakes? The Others? What on earth is remotely cool about these people?!
I'm obviously out of touch with the cool reality. Maybe I suck. But that list can do one.
Re: NME Cool list
Although this list is worthless, I think Paul Epworth is a talented man.
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Have you got the Futureheads' Andy Gill-produced EP's on fantastic plastic? Copare them to the Epworth-produced tracks on the album and you will see that Epworth wins hands down.
Gill may be a very talented guitarist and songwriter in Gang of Fourm but talented producer - not so sure...
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Hmm I just remembered, NME's choice of the Rev JT at the top last year was because he did no wrong. Explain the two wankers from the Shittertines (couldn't think of anything offensive) then.
Re: NME Cool list
and then seth from the o.c at number two.
and the rest don't matter.
x
Re: NME Cool list
does anyone not know who or what 'the game' is then? i take it isnt the wrestler.
Re: NME Cool list
From LA
With Dr DRE.
We have now reached the extent of my knowledge on this subject.
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Soulless,calculated,banal and his approach nearly destroyed the band. I bet you rate the libertine's production too.
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
the NME obviously thinks that it has stepped up in the world. hologram covers....jesus...
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
and that's the reason i never read NME.
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
I saw the NME last night, and contemplated buying it for the first time in a couple of months. Then I flicked through it and realised it had nothing that could keep me entertained. Seriously, how downhill can one magazine go. It's a shame.
But I still stand by the fact that I am a damn site cooler than at least half of the people on that list, and I'm not joking.
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
It is supposed to be entertainment kids
The hacks at NME are a decent bunch with (mostly) good taste. The editor however is not.
Cool is uncool. Uncool is cool.
It really doesn't matter.
ps: if you want to use all your resentment for a good cause, then write to Mr. B-liar and ask him why the leaves on the trees are still green in the first week of december. I'm sure his pals at Shell and Esso have a few answers.
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Those pesky Esso kids.
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
It really makes you wonder how much NME understand, let alone define cool. Surely by being in this very list you instantly become uncool? Shouldn't this kinda thing be left to people in the fashion world and the steerers of cool themselves?
Re: NME Cool list
I wasn't on it.
And the cowardice.
Editorial meeting:
"Right, we can't put Pete at Number One, Carl will get really upset."
"Well, why don't we put Carl at Number One?"
"Cos Pete will get upset."
"Wait a minute, i've got a great idea...."
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
I can't say why I, personally, got started with dope, and it'd be impossible to pin it on a single reason or two. But I can tell you it has been a motherfucker, with a capital M. It's a jack-in-the-box: it'll let you crank the knob for a while with a pretty carnival tune till all of a sudden jack pops out and by then it's too late... yer just fucked! If yer lucky you'll survive, and I can pretty much guarantee you you're not gonna be on the cover of any magazines! "Children, hear me when I say this: the NME has lied to you. Don't fall for it!"
Re: NME Cool list
Re: NME Cool list
Just leave NME alone. It's for wee lil' kids and young people and is clearly there to be taken as seriously as Tony Dortie was on Top of the Pops. It's inconsequential, websites like this one and Pitchfork do more to promote good new music than NME has done all year.
Re: NME Cool list
It was nice to be able to vent to them directly for a change and also tell them to get out the arse of Mr Doherty who's merely an attention seeking twat. I really don't mind the Libertines as a band but I don't think they're amazing and the way the NME goes ON AND ON AND ON makes me almost resentful.
The website's good for breaking tour news etc but other than that they've really lost all credibility in the last couple of years.
I'm tempted to make my life's work a plight to out do the NME with a music magazine that is what it says on the cover.
RIP Melody Maker, XRay and (the old format) Select.