The first time I heard Ys, I cried. They weren’t just any kind of tears; they felt like conjoining dew drips, the kind you cry when someone touches you so slowly and softly you barely notice ‘til their hand begins to warm your inner thigh. It’s that gradual, half-fearful, tenderly touch of a cinema first date, where a moment’s innocence washes you back to a simpler time. There’s something in these silent bawls that meets with that sensation of being rescued, feeling joyous whilst these light tears, the ones that are as warm and soft as blood, tumble and fall.
As lame as it is to reiterate this, with Ys Joanna Newsom really and truly has, more so than with The Milk-Eyed Mender, crafted an utterly compelling otherworldly jewel of an album. Her new five-track offering stretches and meanders along longer ancient autobahns, like lullabies placed upon hand-woven widescreen canvasses. They're often like her exhaling in tongues, leaving condensation on a three-way magic mirror, through which she then reveals intricate etchings of poetic pictures that tell tales which seem to be pouring into your head at random, but which water the thoughts you've condensed and buried in the back garden of your mind. It’s not that she is a magician or an elfish witch (or maybe she is), but she has the power to make these subconscious feelings grow, your emotions buckle or falter and hairs raise all over you like an apparition’s appeared.
I'm rocking back and forth as if overdosed on methadone to every string, stood in the El Rey Theatre in LA some time after Newsom’s latest came out - a considerable while in this digital age – and this is where my virginal unravelling of Ys takes place. However, I could be anywhere; I'm completely lost, as every word featherishly whirls from her breath to mine, diving like dolphins or gravity-defying penguins up my nostrils and wrapping themselves around my brain veins, sensed only momentarily before dissipating. Whether her words go in like osmosis or whether they just evaporate, I’m not sure. Her lyrics feel like a junk shop muddle but each one adds up to touch on those senses of 'something bigger' that we all feel. She doesn't have the answer, just a few mossy cobbles from an Aztec or Victorian purple brick road. But maybe those roads once lead us somewhere.
To prove just how enamoured the room is, she receives the politest heckle ever following album opener 'Emily':
"That was the best thing I ever heard!"
Joanna replies, "Ahaha. Thank you."
Then she plays another 15-minute string-gasm.
There are obviously not just her words; there's music, but it sounds like fairytale pond scenes. Between spinning leaves slapping on a lake, small bugs skitter across strings and bounce on thumbed bass lines. The whole set is more autumnal than mulled-wine scented mittens, yet with violins that sound so transitional that one moment it's like the brightest spring morning; the next minute it’s like migrating geese are eclipsing the moonlight in some Hitchcockian Thomas Hardy remake.
Joanna has made an entire folk world and art-rock genre and taken the styles through a periscope and to another level. Not only that: tonight she has dragged us all with her. At times she plays so fast and far away from the folk that it’s not unlike the McGarrigle Sisters playing rave covers – sure to turn any early folksters in their lily buried graves. It’s for this reason my Richard Thompson-loving nan is getting Ys for Christmas.
And the bugs keep skittering as she plays her way through the entire new album in an elongated daydream way. It's almost as if you've not heard the album before, which I hadn't, but even listening back to it in the days and weeks that follow, the whole wonder of the record feels divorced from the past plays and experiences, with more and more revealing itself as you try to keep up and understand her and all the emotions the incredibly simple music is prickling.
She says "meedoooriite" (meteorite) like the media is wrong and all assumed knowledge is muddled like wool knotted in a kid’s first attempt at knitting. She makes you wish tabloids were in flames, and she is probably only really talking about falling stars which she thinks you can put in jars. She might be a fucking lunatic and stink of piss, but that doesn't matter a jot. She's unique and fascinating, and probably every guy in here wants to sit in a forest eating jam sandwiches with her.
For anyone who has been living in a soundproof room, it’s all about her quivering voice that gusts over her harp, sounding not unlike the pre-vocals before Björk erupts or the moments when little-known goth-ers Queen Adreena and Cyclefly would slow right down to a near stop.
I could be anywhere: Joanna Newsom crowds are probably this shushed and in varying degrees of cute with an awed slant to their jaws the world over. There's a kid with a No More War tee who stares like a cliché waiting to be photo’d. An art-school beauty with big blonde hair and a floral dress steals every guy’s 'n' girl’s hearts as she half-skips making trips back and forth to the bar. A bunch of older guys, who'd bore anyone for hours about Neil Young, sit on chairs, or slouch, propped up against the walls. It’s just like any other Joanna Newsom gig, anywhere in the world: everyone is knowingly touched and leaves wanting to live on a commune or own a pet dragonfly.
I get home and play the record for the first time and the feeling is exactly the same and the same trickling channels appear on my cheekbones. Live, Joanna pretty much sat prettily and played the harp, recreated the record, some other people joined in, she played 'Peach, Plum, Pear' and the 'Book of Right On', and it was all special...
What else did you wanna know?
pseud
although i do now want to go to one of her gigs.
How was
Bill Callahan?
spew
Honestly Sean, that opening paragraph made me feel queasy, have you considered writing soft porn books?
If rabbits could talk...
...they would all sound like Joanna Newsom.
What I don't understand is
if you are gushing over JN & Ys like this, how come the record didn't make your top 20 list of 2006?
They can
and they don't.
That photo
is so calling out for a speech bubble.
"She says "meedoooriite" (meteorite) like the media is wrong"
I'm confused, does she pronounce meteorite like "the media is wrong"?
well
media is plural, so surely 'are' instead.
An OK review, but that first paragraph was indeed horrific.
first para
explains all emo jibes thrown in your direction ever
yeah i was thinking that
I was a little bit sick after reading it.
Its true though...
oh joanna
you can do no wrong! If you masturbated on stage and plucked the harp with your pussy, I'd love it!
...
ps. the first time I heard Ys I CRIED TOO
SO EMOTIONAL
There goes my breakfast
...all over the keyboard. Seriously, these kinds of reviews really have to come with a barf warning.
cried?
Did you really cry though, really?
I am jealous, I really like what I have heard of this album and as younger snapper of whips I would have rushed out bought it and listened with rapt attention dozens of times by now. Not sure I would have cried mind you.
Now as an old bastard I find it hard to be so moved by anything even if its dead good and clever and lovely and everything, its a thing that happens, the deepest love of music still gets wishy washy once you start wearing comfortable pants.
Wil buy this album now though.
You should
Even the most jaded cynic will melt.
string-gasm
ouch
Jesus
How can you get into this state over someone who CAN'T FUCKING SING?
She plays the harp beautifully, granted.
this is the worst review i've ever read..
I'm assuming you wanted an opinion on it, seeing as it's treated as work of art.
Dear oh dear.
Yep
terrible review, you can do better...the gig was, no doubt, at least worthy of the 9 you gave it...not that ive seen her live...
it's a good review
i'm very happy Joanna Newsom exists and makes music.
yeh, me too
but the mushy sentiment in this review is very sick-making.
STOP WRITING
please!
what an awful, cheesy, wanky review
Why didn't you give it a 10?
I agree with lots of the sentiment. It's truly wonderful.
this review
is puke worthy. and worse than that it makes her sound shit.
Beautiful
Joanna does things to the soul that only some can understand.