Drowned in Sound

Search



elliott smith new moon 150
1 vote
?
by Sean Adams
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 07/05/2007
  • Label: Domino Records
  • Info: Double-disc posthumous collection

For those not familiar with the work of Steven Paul Smith (aka Elliott Smith), he was a legend. He is a legend.

His legacy contains a mixture of lo-fi masterpieces and widescreen grace, a perfect muddle of grainy poetic art-house pavement pain and uplifting grand soul tickling. He was, of course, a complex and dark soul whose life was riddled with drink and drugs to dull and snuff-out the depression of dealing with life’s big questions versus small world, small talk, pointlessness – not to mention murmurs of a much bleaker childhood which he blotched out by escaping into his land of sound. He shared a love of Beatles song craft, The Beach Boys’ wall of sound, Simon & Garfunkel’s melodies and the energy, ideology and atmosphere of punk and grunge. The latter is often why he's become a conduit, and the first step on the folk-rock bridge, for backpack-carrying emos. Oh, and if you didn’t know, he was a poster-boy for the doomed, hero of the bookish, and received an Oscar nomination for his contribution to Good Will Hunting. Introduction over…

New Moon is a posthumous double-disc collection of outtakes and things which didn’t quite make the cut for Elliott, the ever-obsessive perfectionist, or for those dang major label goons of Steven Spielberg’s Dreamworks label. This is less an introduction and more like something to delight those already carrying a (roman) candle for indie’s most delicate soul. This compilation of tracks previously lurking on fan sites and P2P leans toward the understated 4am tearjerker side of Elliott, closer production-wise to the self-titled-era as many of these are rough recordings, especially the version of his Oscar-nominated track ‘Miss Misery’. A few tracks were recorded for his final, grungier album From a Basement On the Hill, which was rumoured to be a two-part album, whilst several others are alternate versions of classics like ’Pretty Mary K’.

Throughout these recordings Elliott’s voice is as light as a safety flame, barely audible unless you’re concentrating, and the effect is as disarmingly downbeat as many of his finest moments. The likes of ‘Riot Coming’ and ‘Whatever (Folk Song in C)’ could easily sit on a best of… beside ‘Between the Bars’, ‘Sweet Adeline’, ‘The Biggest Lie’, etc, etc, etc… I could possibly list absolutely everything; his career had little filler.

Those worrying about Tupac-like pillaging of the legacy, fear not: there is little left by our reckoning after this. As fan-boy pleasing as this is, and as great as some of the songs are, it still feels a little like sneaking a peek at a director’s first draft, or rummaging through a scribbly, discarded diary. However, for the completist this is a must-have; for everyone else, start with the overblown post-Disney Figure 8 and work your way back until your heart is completely restructured, and cherish him like those of us who inject him into our soul via our earphones, on a regular basis.

Rest in peace, my friend.

  • Elliott Smith 8 / 10
Words: Sean Adams

what a stupid comment

It's actually coming out via Kill Rock Stars and Domino.
Two of the best independent labels in the world who invested in Elliott when no-one gave a crap and have created a great package that's worth buying.
I'm pretty sure Dreamworks as a label doesn't exist any more.


also

a portion of the proceeds are going to a Portland-based charity, i think?


it is noticeably "fuller" sounding...

...than the downloaded versions, which is nice. it is definitely worth buying.

'basement ii' will probably never get released due to some of the songs already being on this, and i would imagine a lot of the lyrics are incredibly close to home and very hard for his family and friends to listen to, let alone release.


Spot on review

It is hard as a fan wanting the cache of Elliott left untouched from the pillaging of his unreleased (it was his decision to be unreleased) archives until dry a la Jeff Buckley, and having a bit more of his genius to listen to. Luckily, these songs are pretty complete, and are a must for any fan. Lets hope those controlling his estate continue to tread this fine line so well in the future.

Re the 1st comment here, I believe a substantial (ish) amount of the sales will be donated to the Elliott Smith Memorial Fund. This was carefully considered by those close to Elliott. I would rather have these final cuts out there with money going to the charity rather than have everyone just taking these demos free of charge (of course, I did do this, but will not hesitate to get the official copy niw it is out!)


.

arent you a saint


Is it cynical to think

that none of the money would be going to charity if the demos hadn't already been readily available for free?


I'm just glad

'Going Nowhere' has made it onto the album. Probably my favourite Smith track, and all but unknown. I've had most of the tracks on New Moon for months, if not years. But it'll be good to have them grouped up on an actual release. I want to feel that thrill of buying an Elliott Smith album on release day again. The last time was marred by my inability to bring myself to listen to the album for 6 months after I bought it. Perhaps the only time I've let sadness eclipse music.


I have most of this stuff

But I'm gonna buy it anyway.


It's awesome

I bought it from domino and they sent me an Elliott Smith poster, so it was well worth it, though having listened to the un official versions so long it's hard to here certian songs with out the click tracks or the hey hey hey's at the start.


nearly

"a posthumous double-disc collection of outtakes and things which didn't quite make the cut for Elliott, the ever-obsessive perfectionist, or for those dang major label goons of Steven Spielberg's Dreamworks label"

These songs all pre-date his time with Dreamworks, he was with Kill Rock Stars at this point.
Am I right in thinking New Moon is released on KRS in America? If so that makes Figure8's comment a little silly.
Not everyone will scour the internet my friend, I have and I know most of these songs but even if I had downloaded everything I still would have bought this record. The Elliott Smith Fund makes money from this, you can put a cynical negative spin on it if you want or you can just be pleased we have (more or less)completed versions of these songs when we didn't before.


All these songs are pre 1998

I'm sure Dreamworks (or whoever now holds the rights to the songs) will put out their own rarities collection at some point.

One more would be ok, if the songs are as good as this.

But please no Tupac/Buckley/Cobain exploitation.


its decent-ish stuff..

...but i still felt wierd listening to it in that certain songs particularly on the first cd are obviously outtakes some songs that didn't quite work - the odd dodgy lyric or forgettable melody. i'm not altogether 100% comfortable with music being released after someone has died that for good reason they wanted keeping to themselves


Yep I'm thinking...

...a possible Basement II release later?


Oh and...

I know the demos are on the internet so I was meaning an official release.


a full release of the 'basement ii' stuff...

...is incredibly unlikely. i would hazard a guess most of it comes very close to home and is very, very hard for his family and friends to listen to, let alone release.

it is all gold, and i would love to see a lot of his dreamworks-era unreleased stuff see the light of day. a lot of the more bare takes or alternate versions he did of songs are practically superior to the originals, but obviously that is the opinion of one man who isn't the artist.


I downloaded the album with bittorrent....

and then donated $25 to the charity. I would rather my money go to the charity than a record company. The album is moving and brilliant - as per usual with Elliot.


aren't legends

mostly invention, which inflates the reputation and whatnot of the subject?

bit hard on Mr. Smith...