Sign In: or Sign Up! (forgotten password?)
Home / Community / Music forum / 

Vote Now...

...Vinyl or CD?

I vote Vinyl. That's 1-0, vinyl takes an early lead, but can it be sustained.

(running commentary optional)
Miserabli | 08 Mar '05, 14:43 | Send note | Report this | Reply


  • Re: Vote Now...

    cd

    an equaliser 1-1
    pigeon | 8 Mar '05, 14:46 | Reply

    • Re: Vote Now...

      What a comeback as CD scores from outside the area.

      2-1
      tom_from_sparks | 8 Mar '05, 14:48 | Reply

      • Re: Vote Now...

        But the midfield general for Team Vinyl strokes a 30 yard volley into Team CD's goal.

        2-2, and extra time beckons
        grinner | 8 Mar '05, 14:50 | Reply

      • Re: Vote Now...

        Vinyl shoots from the half way line.

        2-1 whammy!
        atom_jack | 8 Mar '05, 14:50 | Reply

        • Re: Vote Now...

          whoops, perhaps it is 3-2 now
          atom_jack | 8 Mar '05, 14:51 | Reply

      • Re: Vote Now...

        Streakyknees creaks across the pitch starkers, singing "C30 C60 C90 go" , rediscovering an activity he used to do in the 80's.
        creakyknees | 8 Mar '05, 14:52 | Reply

        • Re: Vote Now...

          CD hits a six, 127-2.
          JohnM | 8 Mar '05, 14:56 | Reply

          • Re: Vote Now...

            CD.
            dsrBaker | 8 Mar '05, 14:58 | Reply

            • Re: Vote Now...

              Monster Steve invades the pitch eating everything in his path! asdfhgadfhjankfd!

              CD & Vinyl - 8ish, Monster Steve - KABILLION!
              ma0sm | 8 Mar '05, 15:00 | Reply

          • Re: Vote Now...

            I have to say Vinyl but not in a smuggo collector for collectors sake way - its just looks cooler and youre more likely to go a bit wonky when you find something on vinyl you want than on CD - well I do anyway - but CDs are stil better than tapes
            prole-art-threat | 8 Mar '05, 14:59 | Reply

            • Re: Vote Now...

              Equal
              stubryce | 8 Mar '05, 15:00 | Reply

            • Re: Vote Now...

              i'll have to go for cds. i dont own any vinyl :(

              have lost count now!
              pretty_vacant | 8 Mar '05, 15:03 | Reply

  • Re: Vote Now...

    Niether thanks grandad.
    MP3!
    John_Brainlove | 8 Mar '05, 15:04 | Reply

    • Re: Vote Now...

      Pah, you can keep your horribly compressed, bass and treble flattened abominations.
      JohnM | 8 Mar '05, 15:06 | Reply

      • Re: Vote Now...

        of course Ive only got an i-pod - its a design classic
        prole-art-threat | 8 Mar '05, 15:12 | Reply

    • Re: Vote Now...

      Sorry Nathan....
      Miserabli | 8 Mar '05, 15:15 | Reply

      • Re: Vote Now...

        you should know by now I was being ironic - I still use a personal CD player and on the tube I get looked at like I've just discovered Bill Haley and His Comets or something
        prole-art-threat | 8 Mar '05, 15:47 | Reply

      • Re: Vote Now...

        you should know by now I was being ironic - I still use a personal CD player and on the tube I get looked at like I've just discovered Bill Haley and His Comets or something
        prole-art-threat | 8 Mar '05, 15:47 | Reply

  • Re: Vote Now...

    Vinyl if it's limited or coloured, CDs are more handy for in-car entertainment, ipods if they're pink and mini.

    I just can't choose, but CD's are good for acting as emergency mirrors without loking like a nasty pashmina girl.
    Slicky | 8 Mar '05, 15:53 | Reply

    • Re: Vote Now...

      What's the current score? I can't be arsed to add it up. Anyway. A backhand winner from vinyl makes it 40-15. Or something.
      bamos | 8 Mar '05, 16:12 | Reply

      • Re: Vote Now...

        Cd hits back with three treble 20's

        180!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

        195-40
        tom_from_sparks | 8 Mar '05, 16:14 | Reply

        • Re: Vote Now...

          Shellac.
          dave_rio | 8 Mar '05, 17:00 | Reply

          • Re: Vote Now...

            It's at 8 all about. A point for both if you said both, a point for the one you enthused about most, 0 points to either for those who said MP3 or randomly wrote the lyrics to a Bow Wow Wow song.

            I can't choose, vinyl is aspirational, cd functional and cheap. I say both then.

            9 ALL!
            Patricide | 8 Mar '05, 18:19 | Reply

            • Re: Vote Now...

              CD 10-9......vinyl looks good but sometimes sounds fucking abysmal.
              jimmy_nouveau | 8 Mar '05, 18:21 | Reply

              • Re: Vote Now...

                the highlight of the match comes when cd scores for albums, but vinyl comes back within seconds on the strength of singles.
                alcxxk | 8 Mar '05, 18:55 | Reply

  • Re: Vote Now...

    Vinyl for sound.

    CDs for pretty much everything else.

    So, in an ideal world I'd go for vinyl, but nearly everything I've ever bought is on CD.
    Smileadelic | 8 Mar '05, 18:54 | Reply