...I must say I'm really disappointed with Silent Alarm. It's still very good, but it seems to be loaded with filler which I find a bit hard to take when you consider the b-sides Bloc Party have got.
All The Marshalls Are Dead is probably the best song they've actually got, and yet it was only brought back as a b-side when She's Hearing Voices got onto the LP - and it sounds really out of place compared to pap like So Here We Are.
I'd give the lp 7/10 personally, but if they'd changed the tracklisting it could have been so much better.
Re: After giving it time...
i get the feeling that they deliberately sabotaged the album in some senses to stop it being too, well, catchy.
to try and give it more "substance" with the slightly poor slow numbers...
opening with marshalls and including little thoughts and cutting down to 11 or so tracks would probably have been a better move, imho.
Re: After giving it time...
it's all a bit snow patrol by the end, and it completely undermines the dancey records which everybody likes them for anyway.
does anyone like the slowies?
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
i suppose i was expecting about 11 tracks like banquet, marshalls and tulips and yet all my favourite bloc party songs apart from price of gas, banquet and like eating glass aren't on the lp.
damnit.
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
which isn't good enough really.
Re: After giving it time...
but shit.
completely unnecessary.
Re: After giving it time...
they're not offensive, but they're sub b-side quality going by their track record.
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
i think we're all (what are posting here) still categorically fans, just think that they've made some mistakes in the record.
i meant that blue light was shit in that it does sound the same as a great song taht comes 2 tracks later, so cant help but fail to impress. kele actually wanted that released as a single as well.
my average-ish review for the uni rag:
Bloc Party – Silent Alarm
Bit of a funny title for a record so heavily hyped as this – whether alarming or not, its certainly not going to slip past in silence. With Bloc Party having been tipped in the BBC’s “Sound of 2005” poll (no empty bluster – last year’s equivalent featured then-unknowns Keane, Scissor Sisters and, pertinently, Franz Ferdinand) for big success this year, their hopes rest on this record’s fashionably tailored shoulders.
What with the slew of great singles that preceded the album (the thunderous, Factory Records-esque “She’s Hearing Voices”, “Banquet”’s Apache disco and their first Top 40 hit, “Little Thoughts”), the hype has been more than lived up to.
However, clearly a little worried at having the same criticisem aimed at them as the afore mentioned Franz – that the album was a collection of just-too-darn-similar wannabe singles, the Party have sacrificed their finest pop moment, the beautifully uplifting and danceable-as-all-hell “Little Thoughts”. They’ve tried to make a more cohesive Album, one that will stand up to repeated listens and stay on constant rotation on the most discerning hi-fis the nation over.
In this respect, frankly, they’ve failed. It’s not that there’s a tune of the thirteen that could reasonably be slandered as “bad music”, just that a few too many slip without argument into a dull nether region, too apathetic even to shrug. In an attempt to avoid being labelled one/two trick ponies, the band has over compensated and proved their such accussations right.
Its tempting to dwell on this minor criticism, caught up in longing for what could well have been an era defining album, but that seems churlish when what remain are a number of fine, fine pop songs, for headphones and car stereos, dancefloors and bedrooms.
Bloc Party take the naked, skewed romanticism (and anguished yelp) of the Cure and attach it alternately to awesomely catchy, propulsively rhythmic tidal waves of sound (exemplified in the charging “Helicopters”) and pretty, almost ambient bliss-pop (see “This Modern Love” for details). It’s testament to the skills of Paul Epworth (The Streets, Babyshambles, Mystery Jets) as producer that both of these extremes are captured so vibrantly and innovatively.
“Something glorious is about to happen” hollers frontman and future teen pin up Kele in the tumultuous “Positive Tension”. Should they build well on the promise demonstrated in this LP many peaks, you’d be a fool to bet against him.
Re: After giving it time...
if i hadn't heard stuff like marshalls i wouldn't be so gutted.
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
surely everyone wants to have thir cake and eat it.
is it too much to ask?
i mean, you've gone down to the bakers on your day off, youre a wee peckish, so you buy a cake, and then suddenly some bastards rereleasing an indie tune.
this modern life, eh?
but bloc party's singles used to be an event, thats all.
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...
Re: After giving it time...