tim wheeler - no heart whatsoever - makes it more amusing when it is a band that has all these 'i really, really love you' bull shit lyrics - you got to pity the poor person(s) he's singing to.
how can you say Brandon Flowers has 'no heart' in his voice?!!!! I know you don't like the Killers, but he's got one of the most powerful voices, full of passion and feeling, and is excellent live!
I think he sings meaningless lyrics in a needlessly bombastic way to try and make them sound like they mean something. There is just nothing there. It doesn't matter how much fake passion you inject into your singing if the words don't mean anything. Singing in an impassioned way when what you are singing is basically any old rhyming words (and sloganeering) is hollow, empty and artistically bankrupt. It means fuck all and it sounds soulless, fake and just plain awful. They put more effort into their haircuts that the content of their songs.
Still, it took me a while to figure this out, I used to like this kind of stuff when I was younger too (without wishing to sound like i'm being condascending, I'm really not) so... err. Enjoy your Killers. But I will continue to think they are the most inconsequential band on the planet.
shitty- that guy from the bravery has a horrible voice. and a horrible band no less.
and the fella from linkin park, the amount of shit he uses live to keep his voice in check is dispicable.
ace- loads really isnt it? anyone from any band you like. but for now ill say rob halford. screaming bloody vengeance!!!! best metal vocalist ever, no doubt.
Great voices: Jeff Tweedy (Wilco), Conor Oberst, Elliott Smith, Georgia Hubley (Yo La Tengo), Jeff Magnum (NMH), dude from Arcade Fire, Black Francis, Jonathan Donahue (Mercury Rev), Jamie Stewart (Xiu Xiu), dude from British Sea Power
People with really limited voices that still sound pretty good: Tim Wheeler, Doves guy
Crap voices: HOTS dude, guy from the Others, Kelly Jones, Bravery singer, most nu-metal vocalists, Johnny Borell, and that man from Starsailor who should be put out of his misery.
Worst: Gimp from Maroon 5 (Adam something or other?). I don't care how easy a target he is, he just sounds so damn smug and soulless I just want to punch him.
Best: Kieran from Buffseeds, the fella from Mew, Jeff Buckley
and this is where it becomes subjective - i love the fact that his voice sounds lived in, the semi-crooner of closing time and heart of saturday night to the jazz cat of blue valentines right through to the gutteral roar of Bone machine - it's such a splendid, atmospheric instrument he has - if i could sound even halfway like him..........
gargle?
jesus christ man, waits' voice is a tectonic rumble on the ocean floor, booming thunderclouds spitting down whiskey rain, the creaking timbers of a rickety ship at breaking point at midnight in the eye of a storm...
gargle? GARGLE?
Worst singing voice?
Can't believe no one has mentioned Mr "cat scraping its claws down a door" McNamara from Embrace or Chris "I didn't realise this singing lark was about holding a note" Martin.
Best: errrr. fuck knows. Bjork is great. Daryl Palumbo (especially when he makes camp yelping noises), both vocalists from the Blood Brothers (mmm.. singing voice?). Patton. Conor Oberst, for being so unabashedly out of tune. Most people who can't 'sing' and don't try. Like Dylan and Waits. Or some that can. Like Sam Beam.
Worst- That bloke from the Music or him from Embrace.
Best- Jonsi from Sigur Ros, Simon from Fonda 500 and Jason Lytle from Grandaddy.
As a sidenote, Sam Herlihy from Hope of the States' voice isn't THAT bad! I think the 'rawness' of his voice enhances the sound. Or something. Anyway, I like it so there.
Best: Bowie and Ian McCulloch. I feel redundant writing this and I haven't been around for weeks. *shrugs*
Worst: Any of those speed metal cats that growl in that oh-so scary voice. You know what I'm talking about. They're the WWF wrestlers of the music world. dun-dun-dun, dun-dun-dun 'growl'. "OK, you like cutting the heads off chickens. I'm terrified." *shrugs again*
I really don't like Lemaar's voice. Its so boring! Its the sound of time slowing down whilst being injected with horlics by Steve Davies.
Doug Martsch from Built to spill has the best voice ever. As proven by Fact Weekly online.
Best: Tom Waits, Chan Marshall (Cat Power), Patrick Wolf, Sam Beam (Iron & Wine, I can't believe no-one has said him yet), Jeff Buckley and I love Jason Molina's voice, oh and the Arcade Fire girl
Worst: Dominic Masters-"BA BA BABABABA BOW!!!", Johnny Borrell (souless,souless,souless scorpion man), and Beck (but I still love him)
Worst: Kim Gordon from SY. I skip all the songs on Dirty with her on, I actually can't stand to listen to them becasue her vocals are so horrible. And all of Blink 182.
Best: Cedric Bixler, and I quite like the guy from Interpol's voice
worst - anyone in a rock/rap combo, ur man from embrace, dude from the others
best - johnny cash, the fella from turin brakes (seriously), dude from I am Kloot (for the regional flavour), tom waits, elliott smith (although this may be down to the way his voice is produced on record, i.e. very doubletracked)
loads more but ive realised i cant be arsed to type......
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best : Tom Waits (natch)
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Thom Yorke
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Craig Nicholls
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Mike Patton/Thom Yorke
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
best: simon neill. mon the biffy!
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Good : Bjork, Jeff Buckley, lead singer out of 80s Matchbox, Josh Homme, all of The Futureheads.
Bad : Dom Masters, sorry cant think of any others (scuse the pun)
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst: someone with no... heart. Someone totally dull. there are loads to choose from. Kaiser guy, Killers guy, Doves guy, whoever.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
and their not really special but i really like Dylan and Robert Johnston
don't forget american nasal whining for worst voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Still, it took me a while to figure this out, I used to like this kind of stuff when I was younger too (without wishing to sound like i'm being condascending, I'm really not) so... err. Enjoy your Killers. But I will continue to think they are the most inconsequential band on the planet.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
That's a bit harsh innit, John? Surely there are more inconsequential bands.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
and the fella from linkin park, the amount of shit he uses live to keep his voice in check is dispicable.
ace- loads really isnt it? anyone from any band you like. but for now ill say rob halford. screaming bloody vengeance!!!! best metal vocalist ever, no doubt.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
People with really limited voices that still sound pretty good: Tim Wheeler, Doves guy
Crap voices: HOTS dude, guy from the Others, Kelly Jones, Bravery singer, most nu-metal vocalists, Johnny Borell, and that man from Starsailor who should be put out of his misery.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Kieran from Buffseeds, the fella from Mew, Jeff Buckley
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
whereas fred durst is minnie mouse on lambrini, and dom masters is ........................a cunt
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
You are right it is all subjective.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
jesus christ man, waits' voice is a tectonic rumble on the ocean floor, booming thunderclouds spitting down whiskey rain, the creaking timbers of a rickety ship at breaking point at midnight in the eye of a storm...
gargle? GARGLE?
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Can't believe no one has mentioned Mr "cat scraping its claws down a door" McNamara from Embrace or Chris "I didn't realise this singing lark was about holding a note" Martin.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
James mercer
Arcade fire girl
The editors guy
Notwist guy
Judah Nagler
Ted Leo
vs.
Anything overly screamy, americanised, souless or completely untuneful (melt banana excepted)
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst: fuck knows. mine? Dom Masters is a bit nasty.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst. Too many to count: Kelly Fucking Jones. Geoff Rickley from Thursday. Bruce cunting Dickinson. FREDDIE MERCURY (*ducks*). Tim Wheeler. That guy out of the Flaming Lips. Chr*s M*rt*n. Most people with "Good Singing Voices"©. Roger Miret from Agnostic Front may be the most ridiculous vocalist ever. Alex Kapranos gets more annoying by the day.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best- Jonsi from Sigur Ros, Simon from Fonda 500 and Jason Lytle from Grandaddy.
As a sidenote, Sam Herlihy from Hope of the States' voice isn't THAT bad! I think the 'rawness' of his voice enhances the sound. Or something. Anyway, I like it so there.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst: Any of those speed metal cats that growl in that oh-so scary voice. You know what I'm talking about. They're the WWF wrestlers of the music world. dun-dun-dun, dun-dun-dun 'growl'. "OK, you like cutting the heads off chickens. I'm terrified." *shrugs again*
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst: Liam Gallagher (Oarsis)
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst: Tim Wheeler, Ian Brown, Miki Berenyi
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Doug Martsch from Built to spill has the best voice ever. As proven by Fact Weekly online.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Jeff Buckley. I really like Jarvis Cockers vocal style as well.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Thom Yorke
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst: Dominic Masters-"BA BA BABABABA BOW!!!", Johnny Borrell (souless,souless,souless scorpion man), and Beck (but I still love him)
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
the worst is the bloke from the Kings of Leon ...
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
worst - morrisey, that guy from the strokes
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Cedric Bixler, and I quite like the guy from Interpol's voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Mike Patton!!! Uses his voice like an instrument.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Its on Pleasure Is All Mine and Where Is the Line.
Pleasure Is All Mine is a brilliant song. I add Bjork to my best singers.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Best: Richard Sinclair
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst Him out of The Cure
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
His mockney accent on 'boys don't cry' era stuff r0x0rs my s0x0rs.
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
best - johnny cash, the fella from turin brakes (seriously), dude from I am Kloot (for the regional flavour), tom waits, elliott smith (although this may be down to the way his voice is produced on record, i.e. very doubletracked)
loads more but ive realised i cant be arsed to type......
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Worst- Jordan Pundik- Newfoundglory... its so whiny!
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice
it should be good but somehow its awesome
Re: Worst singing voice Vs Best singing voice