Drowned in Sound

Search



The beach

no votes
?
by yes_

I fucking love this film. I don't know why. I wish i lived on that island in that society, and the all saints song that went along with the film is fucking brilliant

fuck!

yes_ | 20 Sep '07, 21:43 | Send note | Report this | Reply

LOL.


Everything.

Seriously, everything.


I love the film

still slowly working my way through the book.

wouldn't want to live there though! although the mass amount of weed is pretty sweet, but there is the threat of being shot by angry Thai's.


Preferred the book..............

but they had to yank it up for the American market and for the sake of securing the requisite funding.


yeah I've only got about halfway through

but already spotted some major differences, and of course the added love story to keep the viewers interested.


The book

is far superior, saying that I do enjoy the film, even if it is a bit wrong in parts.


Read the book recently

Got confused when they said Richard had black hair, then I realised I was thinking of the film.

Excellent anecdote.


I had a similar experience

I saw the film, then a few years later read the book, then watched the film again, then read the book again. I just don't know who Richard is or what he looks like anymore.


My brother is in the beach

I tell everybody this. It's one of my two slightly dubious claims to fame.


I'm glad you asked...

I went out with Alison King's niece. (she was 'Linda Block' in dream team and I believe is now in corrie) And also she said I was 'fit' apparently. So isn't that great.


good work


the book - awesome

the film - a travesty


hate the film

as it managed to destroy the book in every way possible. I like the book.


The book - passable pulp fiction

the movie - atrocious Hollywood guff


its really not though, is it?

LOOK AT THE VISUALS
WOWZER


you know the story

about the beach used in the film, right?


yeah, so?

It still looked cool, was well shot, reasonably well acted etc


I won't argue with you.

Read the book, though.


you wish you lived there?!

Alex Garland must weep daily. THE WHOLE POINT IS TO TELL YOU THAT GOING ON GAP YEARS TO THAILAND IS POINTLESS AND PATRONISING AND DESTRUCTIVE! Gah.


Yeah

he went on a Gap year there so you don't have to.

The Beach is one of the worst books I ever read. Truly awful.


I ACTUALLY AGREE WITH PINBALLFORTRESS

Should I just give up now?


Isn't the book about Alex Garland patronising you with his

"You people just go to Thailand on holiday and look what happens. Me? I LIVE that place. I know it all. I'm not like you, I am someone who *travels*"

The Tesseract is great; the Beach is really nothing special.


i liked it

but then i havent read the book.