Drowned in Sound

Search



the twilight sad

no votes
?
by mr_stranglehands

now I like them and everything but....

s club mogwai?

mr_stranglehands | 25 Sep '07, 15:02 | Send note | Report this | Reply

no idea

but it made me laugh.

seriously though, someone should do s-club mogwai. 3 boys, 4 girls, quiet / loud postrock, dancemoves. makes total sense.


I'm free

every second Tuesday.


you're

on.


riiiiiiiiiiiight...

okay then. I think you may have confused mogwai with tower of power there.


no

i haven't, i just can't see any similarities ... other than they're both scottish bands? they just don't sound similar - mogwai rarely use vocals and the way the twilight sad's guitarist plays is completely different to any one in mogwai; it's hard to work out what he's doing a lot of the time whereas with mogwai you can here lots of little melodies that sort sort of interlock. i know mogwai occasionally 'freak out' too but other than that they're just different.


its just the scottish thing, and te fact that

twilight sad are fuckin ace. thems the similarities. factoid.


heh

yeah, they are immensely scottish... which just makes them all the better.

it's like if you put the proclaimers and swervedriver in a blender.

proclaimdriver.


in the broadest fashion

speaking, they do. As a mogwai taker-or-leaver perhaps I'm just spotting general similarities. tts are great but sometimes their instrumental sections seem a little tacked on from a box of big towering guitar bits. That was possibly stolen from under mogwai's collective bed. And I'm sorry to have brought up tower of power. No-one needs that.


I don't know about

this mogwai similarity but i have to say i have the twilight sad album and saw them last week in Glasgow barfly but i have to say they could be getting a bit over hyped. I think there not to bad, a good album but for me not the saviors of Scottish music as some folk seem to be writing over the pond.


...

This album is one of my favourites of the year. That first track is goosebumptastic.

But Mogwai?
No


They're

My Bloody Valentine fronted by Grounds Keeper Willy.


that's the best

comparison I've heard yet!


Yep

Beats Snow Patrol with more feedback.


^^

thats more accurate tho


...

Ah come on, I can't believe people are saying there's no similarity with Mogwai. There really is. The post-rock bluster is there clear as day. MBV is another influence but I don't think they're copyists at all. Just reasonably transparent influences. It's not a problem. Having said that I wasn't taken with the album. I found it overbearingly earnest and staid.


yes

you are correct, theodore uno.