Drowned in Sound

Search



The Pablo Honey(***),The Bends(*****),OK Computer(****),but,everything since(*)Thread

no votes
?
by Alex-in-Ciderland

Insert furious protest below:

Alex-in-Ciderland | 10 Oct '07, 19:09 | Send note | Report this | Reply

Nah

They definitely peaked with Ok Computer, but they've been consistently good since then and weren't much cop leading up to it.


erm

Pablo Honey - 6/10
The Bends - 8/10
OK Computer - 10/10
Kid A - 8/10
Amnesiac - 7/10
Hail To The Thief - 9/10
In Rainbows - 7.5/10 so far


pfft


out of 10

pablo honey - ***
the bends - ******
ok computer - ********
kid A - *********
amnesiac - ********
hail to the theif - ******
in rainbows - *******

still, it is a bit early to judge in rainbows.


that is..

pablo honey 3, the bends 6, ok computer 8, kid a 9, amnesiac 8, hail to the theif 6, in rainbows 7


oh

i respected you


Me?

Surely not!


yeah

'tis a shame


Awww!

What do I have to do to get it back?


justify the conclusion

that Kid A is shit?


EE-URRRRR


Hmm.

Pablo Honey 6
The Bends 8
OK Computer 10
Kid A 9
Amnesiac 8
Hail To The Thief 10
In Rainbows 9

Therefore, you = wrong.


Give it a few months

and In Rainbows will be a 10 too.


hail to the theif

a TEN!? insane.


I LOVE HTTT

I can't explain why, but there isn't one track I'd skip, and a lot of my favourite Radiohead tracks are from that album.


nah

here's how it goes:

drill = shit
pablo honey = shit
pop is dead = FUCKING INCREDIBLE
my iron lung = shit
the bends = shit
ok computer = shit
kid a = shit
amnesiac = shit
i might be wrong = shit
hail to the thief = shit
in rainbows = shit

FOR REAL


Pretty similar to me.

We rule.


.

Pablo Honey 5/10


+++++

the bends 9/10
ok computer 9/10
kid a 10/10
amnesiac 8/10
hail to the thief 9/10
in rainbows 8/9 /10


but anyway:

PH: 4/10
the bends: 7/10
ok computer: 8.5/10
kid a: 10/10
amnesiac: 7/10
httt: 7.5/10 (9/10 with a shortened tracklist)
IR: 8/10


hmm

Pablo Honey-8/10
The Bends-8/10
ok computer-10/10
Kid A-7/10
amnesiac-8/10
Hail To The Thief-7.5/10
In Rainbows-10/10


why not eh...

Pablo Honey 6.7
The Bends 8.8
Ok Computer 9.1
Kid A 7.9
Amnesiac 8.8
Hail to the Thief 9.2

not commenting on In rainbows yet. I've had years with these. it'd be ludicrous to vote on the new one yet.

it's great though.


i'm in!

pablo honey 6.5
the bends 8.5
ok computer 9
kid a 10
amnesiac 8
hail to the thief 7
in rainbows at least an 8

those are facts.


This is very interesting... indeed.

PABLO HONEY= Nay! (like a horse)
The Bends= YAY! (9/10)
OK COMPUTER= DOUBLE YAY! (10/10)
KID A= DOUBLE YAY! (10/10)
AMNESIAC= YAY! (9/10)
HAIL TO THE THIEF= Hmmm... (6/10)
IN RAINBOWS= YAY!


I say:

Pablo Honey - 6
The Bends - 8
OK Computer - 10
Kid A - 10
Amnesiac - 7
Hail to the Thief - 8.5

HTTT would be 9 minus a couple of the tracks.


.

Pablo Honey - 4/10
The Bends - 10/10
OK Computer - 10/10
Kid A - 10/10
Amnesiac - 6/10
Hail To The Thief - 6/10
In Rainbows - 6/10


you're silly


hmm

Pablo Honey - 5/10
The Bends - 7/10
OK Computer - 10/10
Kid A - 9/10
Amnesiac - 7/10
Hail to the Thief - 6/10
In Rainbows - not sure/10


good lord!

Pablo Honey-5/10
The Bends-9/10
ok computer-8/10
Kid A- 10/10 (it's gone up in the last few days)
amnesiac-6/10
Hail To The Thief-10/10 (same as Kid A)
In Rainbows-10/10 (so far)

and for the hard cores:
itch: 7/10
a disappointments for me, as it's so rare.


is it rare though?

i've seen it 10 or 20 times in different places, thought it's always been £20+


it's not rare at all

Every major record shop stocks it. It's usually pricey as it's an import.

It's about as rare as the My Iron Lung EP.

Drill is the rare one.


For anyone who's interested

Itch is less than £9 on Amazon at the mo...


oh well

showed myself up there then, didn't I!

I always thought it was rare, I've never seen it in any shops, just on the net!


Involved

PH - 5
Bends - 7
OK Comp - 10
Kid A - 10
Amnesiac - 7
HTTT - 7
IR - 9


What the hell

PH - 6/10
The Bends - 10/10
OK Computer - 9/10
Kid A - 8/10
Amnesiac - 6/10
HTTT - 7/10
IR - 9/10


this is the worst thread i'veever read

say what you think about the album, you can't discuss numbers you wankers


^^ 4/10

Must try harder.


Radiohead - 5/10

Rush - 8/10


out of 5 *

Pablo Honey **
The Bends ****
Ok Computer **
Kid A *
Amnesiac *
Hail to the thief *
in rainbows (not heard yet) so *x?


lol


i just called oR a nob

sorry oR


I've been called worse

But I've checked it with the answer key and my scores are spot on.

Truthfully, even though I'm "appreciating" Radiohead these days, I still don't find myself pulling out Radiohead albums much (Kid A last week in anticipation here, but that's it.) ...and so I just sorta guessed .... but as I said, luckily I guessed exactly right!


8,7,10,9.5,8,9.5

is right, you are wrong


Hehe... PH > The Bends

Oooookay, dude! Erm, btw, did you not rate In Rainbows, jp100?


i was drunk

but The Bends is the only radiohead album where i skips tracks, and I had only listened to In Rainbows twice then, I don't think i'll have an opinion for at least a week.


They peaked at OK Computer for me.

I can't be arsed with most of the stuff afterwards.

This will be the last time I say this. Possibly. Until I type it again.


Erm...

Pablo Honey *** (pretty much for Thinking About You, Creep and Anyone Can Play Guitar)

The Bends ****

OK Computer ****

Kid A ** (only listened to it properly once mind but there wasn't really anything there to make me want to ever hear it again. I do like Idioteque, Everything in its Right Place and How to Disappear Completely though)

Amnesiac - (N/A - couldn't be arsed.)

Hail to the Thief - likewise

In Rainbows - likewise


^5

:D


Quite right.

How dare I have my own opinions and not like something that everyone else likes. I should be banned for life.


6.6, 9.3, 10, 10, 8.4, 8.2

i think i am likely to give IR a 9, but not before i've heard it a few more times.


I agree (ish)

But OK Computer only gets *** in my book.


hmm

Pablo - 5
Bends - 9
Ok Computer - 11
Kid A - 9
Amnesiac - 7
HTTT - 8
In Rainbows - 8 (after a few listens)


Hmmm

PH - 6
TB - 10
OKC - 9
KA - 8
A - 8
HTTT - 7
IR - don't know yet. I'm veering towards an 8.


liek duh

pablo honey = fun/10
the bends = travis/10
ok computer = masterpiece/ten
kid a = even better/10
amnesiac = stunning/10
httt = dance you fuckers, dance you fuckers/10
in rainbows = waiting for the vinyl/10


I agree

100%
Thank god someone else thinks this.
I was beginning to think I was the only person on earth that thinks everything after ok computer is completely meh