Drowned in Sound

Search



simon breed
3 votes
?
by Alex Denney

Lured by an admittedly unsubstantiated claim that he comes ‘feted’ by the Bad Seeds, I had high hopes for Simon Breed.

Sadly ‘Finish My Book’ isn’t all that and a brooding bag of biblical potato chips. It’s about escaping the rat race via the joys of a good book, and the anxiety experienced when our protagonist realises said novel will at some point have to end.

All of which makes the song’s melodramatic delivery seem faintly ridiculous, as Breed wails portentously "what they don’t tell you is time passes!". Er no, Simon, that’s sort of a given.

Breed makes his vocal entry low and expansive before suddenly shifting up an octave to place us firmly in Echo & The Bunnymen territory, or to be more precise, ‘Killing Moon’ territory. Unfortunately there’s also an unsavoury whiff of Legs Akimbo-style amateur dramatics to the proceedings, compounded by a truly De Burghian middle eight which speaks of "sudden stabbings" and, bizarrely, "the stench of children".

To be fair this is a serviceable tune and there’s enough to suggest Breed has better things in him, but for now you’d do well to avoid this overwrought slice of Big Music-style emoting.

  • Simon Breed 5 / 10
Words: Alex Denney

honestly you're worng!

I don't get why its OK to be melodramatic about remote stuff like the Bible and not about the everyday - thats Simon's thing. i think hes great. OK so Book doesnt get you but if you were initially lured in by the Bad Seeds link you won't be disappointed by his other stuff. There's a song he plays live called Snipes which is as beautiful and compelling as anything by Cave or Oldham.


go on

Just to add, you may have finished off the book review but you should keep on listening to Simon's other stuff as there are some really great songs, multi layered and beautifully written. Nout wrong with a bit of emoting, that's what I say!





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Dead Meadow: ruffle Feathers, produce stellar fifth album