Last five. Thanks for being patient with us. It’s been a slog – we’ve been arguing over this list for what feels like forever – but we’re here. The summit. The zenith. The end. Et cetera. The best five albums of 2007.
According to the DiS editorial team, anyway – the results of your voting will be published next Friday, December 14. Be sure to swing by DiS then to see if your favourite albums of the year – from our original shortlist of 50 – have made the DiS reader top ten. What I will tell you, for the time being, is that the number one record received a staggering number of votes, putting it head, shoulders, knees and toes ahead of the album in second position.
Below the top five is the top 50 in order, as ranked when we initially published the shortlist in an A-Z style. ‘Til next week’s reader vote result: happy listing…
(Missed some? Links: 25-21, 20-16, 15-11, 10-6)
5
Jamie T
Panic Prevention (Virgin)
“Kharas needs brought out and SHOT for this.” In hindsight, now the dust has had time to settle, I reckon it’d be fair to say that the 10/10 review Panic Prevention received on this site wasn’t greeted with widespread approval. A million miles from your typical ‘DiS band’, whatever that’s supposed to be, Jamie T may have walked a familiar line but through his shot retinas that neighbourhood became a more interesting place to loiter. An exploration of suburban living, lacking cliché, is as hard a task as constructing a math-rock masterwork or a looping, spectral paradise. Stealing glimpses of all the hush-hush romance and tragedy a sleeping camp of Barrett three-beds can hold, the trio of ‘Calm Down Dearest’, ‘So Lonely Was the Ballad’ and ‘Back in the Game’ trumped every other album of this ilk in 2007. It’s ‘Ike & Tina’, though, that is the record’s ace; whirring, fumed and dizzy-reeling under hometown lights.
Kev Kharas; review here
4
M.I.A.
Kala (XL)
Leaving a carbon footprint bigger than a fossilised yeti’s, pop trailblazer M.I.A.’s follow-up to the acclaimed Arular was several months, several hundred countries and one troublesome Visa request in the making. It was, naturally, worth the wait - bigger and bolder than its predecessor, taking in the supercharged rhythmic clatter of first single ‘Boyz’ and the bonkers Bollywood disco of ‘Jimmy’, while generally reminding everyone that the Sri Lankan tigress is simply in a class of her own with this stuff, whatever that stuff is exactly. Superb.
Alex Denney; review here
3
Panda Bear
Person Pitch (Paw Tracks)
It’s harsh and impossible to think of a 2007 that’s missing this record from its racks. Pulling memory back to endless after-hours carry on, Person Pitch is, quite simply, a masterwork that words struggle to describe. A synaesthetic epiphany dripping with sample and found sound, it’s Lennox’s disembodied cry manning the record's nerve centre; a playful, vibrant PA. But in a year of clevver music founded on the innate sway of the loop – LCD, Battles, Burial et al. – it’s Lennox who stands out as the poster boy; his is the album that makes that debt most obvious, almost as if he’d constructed a giant tape deck, stuck the world in and hit rewind, reversing the spin of an entire planet on its axis, exploding narrow time and skewing light off the dizzy sphere. A haunting, ultimately incredible record.
Kev Kharas; review here
2
Battles
Mirrored (Warp)
Lord knows how it turned out this way. Swell-headed techlords from assorted mathy spod bands slowed down their unfeasibly dense rhythm section and spawned a seven-minute, glam-slamming monster in ‘Atlas’ and suddenly Battles became the must-hear act of 2007. Put simply, Mirrored was sheer prismatic perfection, a perfectly-titled light chamber of echoing loops and twitching, automated beauty that sounded like nothing we’ve heard before or ever will again, and united speccy blogger-types and skinny-pantsed hipsters for possibly the only time in history. Huzzah!
Alex Denney; review here
Tyondai Braxton, Battles
You know, you make something and you cannot believe another person likes it, period. I kind of consider myself a member of the audience, too, and though I may have a different perspective if I like it, I am crazy enough to think others may like it. So I am very happy that people have responded to Mirrored. It also reminds me that maybe there is more room for this music out there than presumed.
- - -
1
LCD Soundsystem
Sound Of Silver (DFA/EMI)
The more iniquitously-minded of you may suggest that LCD made its way to the top of the list by virtue of being the record that no-one hated; certainly its position here is the result of a very democratic process in the DiS camp, votes going right to the wire to bump it above Battles. But to assess its ranking in such an analytical way would be to ignore the pathos-dripping track-of-the-year 'All My Friends', the sweet drone of 'Someone Great', and the wry lament of fitting album closer 'New York, I Love You'. It would also be a dismissal of a record that is a near-perfect integration of musical modernity and classic songwriting. Sure, it’s topped a few lists elsewhere, but DiS can’t disagree with the reasoning of our peers: Sound Of Silver is the album of 2007.
Gareth Dobson; review here
James Murphy, LCD Soundsystem
Oh wow, awesome. That’s wonderful. That’s fantastic. I never know how to react to such things other than, “it’s great”. I feel so funny about it.
- - -
And our top 50 of 2007, from one to 50…
1: LCD Soundsystem – Sound Of Silver
2: Battles – Mirrored
3: Panda Bear – Person Pitch
4: M.I.A. – Kala
5: Jamie T – Panic Prevention
6: Modest Mouse – We Were Dead Before The Ship Even Sank
7: Liars – Liars
8: No Age – Weirdo Rippers
9: Radiohead – In Rainbows
10: HEALTH – Health
11: Deerhunter – Cryptograms
12: The National – Boxer
13: Les Savy Fav – Let’s Stay Friends
14: Aesop Rock – None Shall Pass
15: Clap Your Hands Say Yeah – Some Loud Thunder
16: The Maccabees – Colour It In
17: Animal Collective – Strawberry Jam
18: Klaxons – Myths Of The Near Future
19: Arcade Fire – Neon Bible
20: The Shins – Wincing The Night Away
21: Grinderman – Grinderman
22: Blonde Redhead – 23
23: PJ Harvey – White Chalk
24: Efterklang – Parades
25: Justice – Cross
26: Black Lips – Good Bad Not Evil
27: Deerhoof – Friend Opportunity
28: Clipse – Hell Hath No Fury
29: Field Music – Tones Of Town
30: Bloc Party – A Weekend In The City
31: The Cribs – Men’s Needs, Women’s Needs, Whatever
32: !!! – Myth Takes
33: Andrew Bird – Armchair Apocrypha
34: Arctic Monkeys – Favourite Worst Nightmare
35: Electrelane – No Shouts, No Calls
36: Thurston Moore – Trees Outside The Academy
37: Beirut – The Flying Club Cup
38: Future of the Left – Curses
39: dälek – Abandoned Language
40: The Sea & Cake – Everybody
41: Mathew Sawyer and the Ghosts – Blue Birds Blood
42: Eugene McGuinness – The Early Learnings Of…
43: Von Südenfed – Tromatic Reflexxions
44: Prefuse 73 – Preparations
45: Pinback – Autumn Of The Seraphs
46: of Montreal – Hissing Fauna, Are You The Destroyer
47: Yeasayer – All Hour Cymbals
48: The Twilight Sad – Fourteen Autumns and Fifteen Winters
49: Jen Lekman – Night Falls Over Kortedala
50: Feist – The Reminder

very good choices on 1st and 2nd
two of my top 5 also this year.
i'ev enjoyed this chart and shall definately invest in a few i hadn't heard.
Battles
is shit. Panda bear should be #1
you rate
Battles 8/10 though?!
Radiohead only at #9
haha, okay.
future of the left
down at #38? Fuck me!
I was hoping this
would get Number 1. Not suprised though really.
Meh
FOTL LP is amazing
but I think its fairly predictable that basically everything Andy Falkous does never gets the media recognition it deserves
mm
just what i was thinking.
LCD at first?!
Its a great album and loads better than his first. Is it really the best album of the year tho? I'm not convinced.
Önly twö
Bänds with umlauts in their nämes.
More umlauts for 'Ö8!
Wörd!
Wot?!>?
No DEP??
WTF!>?
Re: LCD at first?!
Yes it is. Listen again. Preferably whilst walking somewhere.
^^^
Exactly!!! This album should come with a warning: "May make you dance uncontrollably whilst walking"
LCD on the go
i agree with kykiske, listening to Sound of Silver whilst walking is the best way to appreciate it.
Good call with the walking thing
I love LCD and had a great time at the Brixton show last month but I'm really struggling to get what is so special about this album. Top 20 yes, number one? No way.
Play it while walking through town however and it is virtually impossible not to adopt some kind of travolta-esque strut.
I'm still trying to work out
Why Low didn't make the list. I think on another topic it's mentioned that it's because they'd released better albums before but that's true of about half the list!
Concur
If that's the reasoning, Bloc Party should be at -30whatever they got.
Er....
NO BESNARD LAKES?!?!?!?!
EH???
Clearly the finest album released this year.
and that LCD
album is really overrated IMO. The last 2 or 3 songs are painful.
The LCD Album
gets painful after the 1st song. Repetetive, sub !!! bollocks and severely lacking in any variety/change of pace. Thus album of the year, Good call!
i just listened to it
it sounds like if flight of the conchords decided to take themselves seriously.
rubbish and boring.
Jamie T.
LOL! To be honest, I've only heard 18 of those 50 albums. I think LCD's second, good as it is, is over-rated. As for Battles... they're technically very impressive, but half of "Mirrored" is little more than that. Radiohead for #1 for me (especially if you take into account the second disc). Keep in mind, though, that I <3 them. I would've liked to have seen This Et Al, Asobi Seksu and A Place to Bury Strangers in there somewhere, too; as far as I'm aware, they all received "proper" releases in the UK this year.
... Yep.
Well done DiS, you win!
Can't argue with four of that top five, LCD deserved winners.
Jamie T
Oh dear...
Not a bad list....
...if a little predictable.
Notable omissions include SHAPE OF BROAD MINDS (LEX) , probably the most progressive hip-hop album of the last couple years & BURIAL 'Untrue' (Hyperdub) which is a brooding, moody masterpiece.
both considered
Felt SOBM lacked punch m'self; fun though it was it's not in the same league as El-P or Aesop, dalek or Clipse.
The Burial album... some of us here LOVE it; others are cold towards it. I'm in the latter camp - try though I have to let it sink into my skin, I find it too... clean? I don't find it brooding at all.
Thanks all.
...AGREED...
Stand by the fact that SoBM prattles on too much about innovation. Peaks at Let's Go.
Even though LCD may be a fairly obvious choice
it is the right one. Good to see you didn't just go for something obscure for the sake of it. Good to see MIA up in your top 5 as well.
twilight sad album 48?
the world has gone crazy! top ten fo sho :(
jamie t
is a great little album - good work for recognising it team
twilight sad
should really have been in top 25... no? Oh well. The next album, maybe.
^ this ^
I'm quite confident of their next album being this big, Mercury panel-impressing beast.
Who'd have thought it...
Jamie T in the Top 5. Nobody saw that one coming. I'm pleased to see that though cos he's in y Top 5 too. Good lad, Jamie!
Best list
I've seen so far - well done DIS!
LCD is very much looking
to be the Funeral of 2007, it's so far come top in Uncut, Stylus and DiS. I can see it also being NME's number one (you know how they like to copy others), while I also think 'All My Friends' will end up giving Jimmy-Boy the overall Single of the Year (Mojo, Stylus again, probably that wanker Conor)...
It's also number one on
The Guardian's list.
yes
correct. DiS, you are right about lcd. :)
agreed on first.
very different rest of list for me though...
no aereogramme!
my heart has a wish is beatiful - not just my favourite album of this year but probably the last 3 or 4!
I do like these lists
I don't hear much new music these days so I tend to go with whats on here. How lazy am I?! Anyway worked for me last year.
mental
Of Montreal at 46?
Insane
sorry
but that Of Montreal album's the worst they've done in years. what were they thinking with that 12 minute long track in the middle?
they were thinking
'Hey this will be fucking brilliant'
and they were right!
^ Will someone please put this retard out of his misery?
'Hissing Fauna...' is a work of singular pop genius, and 'The Past Is A Grotesque Animal' is intense, affecting and wonderful. Should have been top 5, definitely.
They opened
their set last night with 'Grotesque Animal'. Which was nice.
no
it's sub emo lyrics over a yawnfest of a, fuck i don't know what it's like. in fact, in years to come, people will use it as a yardstick of shiteness, it'll be like "that's so bad, that's the past is a grotesque animal".
don't get me wrong, i like of montreal, and there's some good tracks on the newie, but in terms of pop songs that don't make you cringe, i'll stick to sunlandic twins and, i guess, satanic panic in the attic. thankyou.
JAMIE T????
oh well, each to their own i guess, but yeah, jamie t is shite and you really need to see it, ok? let's see how you've come along 12 months from now
^^^
pop music for the mo an all
but
jamie 2 is still shit now
and will be both shit and embarrassing by next summer
wot no SFA, El-P, Robert Wyatt?
mostly fair enuff though, kids
andrew bird
at 33 makes me sad though. oh well.
i tried to fight for it to get higher
but i was on my own, sadly. it's in my personal top 10 tho, for what that's worth.
Nina Nastasia
Nina Nastasia & Jim White's 'you follow me', should be there, its marvellous, as should Kristin Hersh, Besnard Lakes, Low, Marissa Nadler, Okkervil River, Bjork, St Vincent, New Pornographers, Sunset Rubdown, The Good Bad & Queen, Cathy Davey, Band Of Horses, Bat For Lashes and Iron & Wine!
i dunno tho
50 is hard
it is a bumper year for albums
it really is
^ this ^
There have been way more brilliant albums this year than in the past few... there's no doubt Besnard Lakes, Band of Horses, Wyatt, Sunset Rubdown, Bjork, Low, Okkervil River and more have made great LPs (although Bat For Lashes was LAST year, and the St Vincent album...? A bit... much?), but you've gotta draw your lines soemwhere. Also: DEP, Oxbow, El-P, SFA, MMISL, L Pierre, Burial... the list goes on and on and on... Maybe we should do a top 100 next year?
Whatever your grips about this list..
...can we all at least agree that 2007 has seen the release of some top class albums- the strongest set for a while IMO, 07 a vintage year?
LCD are my #1 as well. Good list, I think DiS and its readers know their shit when it comes to rooting out the tunes. well done all
Guardian writer's top 20
http://music.guardian.co.uk/reviews/story/0,,2223431,00.html
LCD again....looking like a landslide across the board for James Murphy and co
JAMIE T?!?!? etc etc
But yeah, good choice on first. That could well be my album of the year too
Where's Radiohead though?
Erm...
Radiohead are 9th...
Well the good thing is
that 15 of my top 20 records of the year are in your top 50, so that goes to show "great minds" and all that... And indeed 3 of your top 5 are in mine too.
But you guys, there has been some AMAZING pop music this year. You need to open your eyes and see that Pop is the future, and Jamie T is thankfully not.
I know DiS isn't about pop music, but to these ears there's only a thin line between some of those tunes and the last Rihanna album...
Call it "constructive criticism" if you will
x
blimey..
I nearly own the top 10.
Shock.
No Robyn?Henrik Scwarz?
Robyn's UK debut was a strong contender
strugglign to justify the M.I.A though
^^ re Robyn. And Henrick Schwarz?
I'm surprised to hear you mention him (didn't think it would be a DiS thingy thing...)
Okkervil River
Very surprised by the lack of Okkervil River in the Top 50, especially as DiS is sponsoring their tour. I'm not implying that backs are scratched for such awards, just that I thought they probably had the DiS seal of approval, that's all. Plus it's a fucking great record.
No Besnard Lakes, Broken Family Band, Low etc either? Shame on you.
Sound of Silver
Talk to me, makes you want to feel like a teenager.
Easily album of the year for me. Perfect from start to finish.
As for Mirrored, I still haven't made it the full way through the album on one listen. It's unlike anything I've ever heard before, I'll give it that. However, it irritates the fuck out of these ears.
Maybe it will have grown on me, in a few years time...
i don't really care that much about the list
since i knew from the start i was only going to have heard about 5 of the albums on it anyway.
that said, i'm a little disappointed to see armchair apocrypha so low, it hasn't had nearly enough love on here.
also kinda surprised at how low hissing fauna is... not cause i like it, just because it seems to be near the top of everyone else's list. but then, i guess you guys didn't want to be TOO predictable, right? :D
jeez
How are The Twilight Sad not in this list????!!!!
err, they are.
ah
So I see. My folly. woops-a-daisy
I think
yr just copying Stylus! Sound of Silver album of the year, and All My Friends single of the year!
obv it's a good idea to copy others when they get it right.
Paul Smith sez he's gutted
if it makes any difference
we picked and ordered this list about 6 weeks ago.
hopefully you can sleep easy now.
doo-doo-doooh-du-duh-doo-dooooh
awful list for me.
Apart from Deerhunter and maybe Efterklang, none of this album will make my list.
really?
You've heard all 50? - there's some fantastic albums there, although I think Eugene McGuiness and Twilight Sad should have been a lot higher, and Menomena should have been in there.
Where the fuck are Fall Out Boy?
You wankers!
stars of the lid
would get my vote.
but, they weren't even on the list.
shame really.
most of them ( at least a few tracks )
By awful, I'm not giving my opinion on the music ( apart from Bloc Party, Jamie T and the Maccabees... ), but thinking as how 'standard indie' that list is.
Most ( if not all ) of this albums have been highly discussed on every website, webzine or blogs on the net. It definitevely made me think of this thread a few weeks ago about uniformization of taste.
I can understand why people like or even love this albums. I just find a bit awful that many of them will be in EVERY top50...
How the hell did Jamie T get in there?
Stops me from taking this list seriously.
It does seem a bit odd.
Thought I was on nme.com for a second.
It deserves a mention somewhere in this thread, so...
I'll mention The Great Unwanted by Lucky Soul. Not perfect by any means, and perhaps not quite top 50 stuff (they should have put Give Me Love on it), but an album I've enjoyed a lot this year.