We begin with perhaps the defining Belle And Sebastian song. "The State I Am In" sets the tone for the rest of the album. Nick Drake vocals combine beautiful acoustic melodies, and fantastic Morrissey-esq lyrics. When he writes words, Stuart Murdoch gives a kind of indescribable British feeling, filling his songs with classical and contemporary references, you feel like you're in some unique club as you understand every one of them.
After all, who else would understand about the "feel from Joe the Store man" in the utterly sublime "Expectations"?? A wondrous tale of working-class teenage life, it paints an astonishingly vivid picture of rejection, of the incessant pain of normality, and of the grey, cold walks to school on February mornings.
And where the lyrics let you down, the melodies compensate. Swirling, hypnotic, but mostly just darn catchy, Murdoch is a wonderful song writing team rolled into one. He seems to be able to tap into the rivers of our everyday minds. We've all had the "coffee that tastes like washing up, we've all had days that make suicide a positive option, just like the one described in "She's Losing It".
Did I forget to mention the killer melody of "My Wandering Days Are Over"?? The self-examining realness of "I Don't Love Anyone"?? The classic program out track "Electric Renaissance"?? I'm getting exciting just writing about it.
You may think that Belle And Sebastian have made better records than this. You may think Belle And Sebastian are a fey, annoying bunch of intellectual Indie wasters. You may have stopped reading this after the first paragraph.
But, in 30 years time, when Belle And Sebastian are nothing more than an entry in a Colin Larkin book, "Tigermilk" may be rediscovered by the automated youth of the future. Let them, like us, enjoy it.

Belle And Sebastian - Tigermilk
Re: Belle And Sebastian - Tigermilk
Belle And Sebastian - Tigermilk
Re: Belle And Sebastian - Tigermilk
Moving on...
The first two are definitely my favourite Belle and Sebastian records. I think I know what you mean saying there's more feeling on Tigermilk: I think it's a cuter album, if that fits. It's something about the characters and the strummed guitars. It's like an enclosed world, whereas Sinister's is bigger and more expansive and sunnier. To me at any rate.
and yeah, ballboy are brilliant :)
I'm really looking forward to the next album. But although i like the songs, I don't think The Sash My Father Wore & others really worked as an album. I can't quite work out why, and it's not just that it's Gordon minus band plus strings, it's something about the recordings. All seems a bit stale (with a couple of exceptions, the version of I Gave up My Eyes... is good, as is Past Lovers). I've got no complaints about the other albums though.
Oh, and the version of I Lost You but I Found Country Music, with Laura Cantrell, on the last single, is amazing too. I've been listening to that even more than the Kaiser Chiefs single (which I've been listening to a lot!)