Drowned in Sound

Search



What Games Console Should I Own (Really)?

34 votes
?
by Stealthy

It's between the Xbox and PS3. I want the PS3, but this is really suffering from the fact that it has only one game worth owning, and I don't want to own that game.

The Xbox on the other hand, has a few games I wouldn't mind owning, but as soon as I buy one I get the feeling that Devil May Cry 4, Metal Gear 4, Final Fantasy 23, and a special 2D Back In The Day superversion of Sonic The Hedgehog all come out on the same day for the PS3 and I get screwed.

I need to know what to do!

Stealthy | 10 Jan '08, 18:22 | Send note | Report this | Reply

if it helps

Devil May Cry is coming out on 360 too, and they've not ruled out porting Metal Gear over at some point...


Xbox 360...

i had the same dilemma and am happy with my choice, xbox live is so well populated. All the games i want are on both consoles or exclusive to xbox, plus wireless controller rule.


^this

Xbox live is amazing and there's always someone on it.


also

The 360 control is the greatest controller ever.

Better than the Playstation one and even better than the N64 one!


the N64 controller sucked!

WTF's going on with that button underneath? And the huge, pointless arm in the middle?

PS controller FTW. There's a reason it's barely been changed in three evolutions.


I loved the N64 one.

Nothing can control a 3D shoot'em up like the N64 controled Goldeneye.


...

What about the games where you had to use the left side too? It was bloody impossible!


PS3

* Free online
* Ratchet & Clank
* Bluray
* MGS, FF, GTA5, GT4 all to come.


£39 for xbox live 12 mths

free isn't a great selling point. MGS is the slowest game ever, GTA was better 2D, GT has always been the most overrated game with the worst handling cars possible.xbox...


...

You are utterly wrong about all those games. And trying to make out cheap is better than free is just silly.

You are fortunate however in that I'm still wanting to be convinced.

DEBATE FOR MY LOVE!


GTA was better 2D?

are you mental?


not mental i just found the game..

a little rubbish really but in 2d it seemed ok cos the graphics were poor anyway so GTA offered something a little different.

i agree free is better, though walking is free but i'd still rather pay 90p and get a bus!

if you are wanting to be convinced i think you probabaly already are convinced.


...

FAULTY ANALOGY.

Apart from that, I am convinced: I will never buy a Wii.

I just want someone to hug me and tell me all my favourite games will definitely come out on Xbox... or for a truckload of amazing games to suddenly arrive for the PS3. Then I'd be set.


GTA 5 is multi platfrom

you dolt!


Great.

But we've still got to get GTA4 out of the way first and that is PS3 exclusive for nine (I think) months before it goes multi platform.


Wait a bit?


Don't do this.

The Wii is not that great.

It's a bit boring I find. You couldn't play it hungover and the games I've played are only fun in multiplayer mode.

360 defo!


the thing is

the wii has some of the best games around. People just tend to play the multiplayer fun games with friends though. For single player you have Super Mario Galaxy, Resident evil 4, metroid prime, zelda, plus mario kart released this year


THIS IS WHAT I'M THINKING!

I don't give a fuck about the gimmicky control system - I just want to play Zelda and Mario Galaxy, then beat the shit out of Mario with Sonic in Super Smash Bros.


i have a wii and a 360

the wii is a good laugh with mates, and it's still fun one player but if you're a lazy gamer and don't wanna move much get a 360 or a PS3.

the wii is a lot of effort, i like having both though


...

NEVER. That stupid waving shit around makes me want to die.


seriously?

That would be SO sick.


Definitely a 360

I should say that I've never owned a PlayStation, but I did play on a PS3 hoping to be blown away but it just seemed a little underwhelming. And the controllers are still shit, which actually completely ruins gameplay. They're not heavy enough and the rumble-effect on a 360 controller is so much better.


unless you import

a Dual Shock 3 pad from Japan, there IS no rumble effect on the PS3 controller (just now)!


I have a PS3 and a Wii

And used to own an xbox360 before someone broke in to our house and nicked it.

I'd get the PS3 if there's a couple of games you want for it. More games will be coming out for it as time goes on, after all. Only reason the Xbox has the upper hand there is because it's been around longer.

If there's nothing you want for PS3, Xbox isn't THAT different, being honest. Just crashes more (or mine did).


Or

get a PS3 when there's actually something on it you want to play *and* it will be cheaper. Getting one now without wanting to play anything available for it would be up there with the most retarded things ever.


so many dis'ers with a 360

Team slayer on Halo3 anyone?


i'd say PC, but otherwise

don't get a PS3. just don't. don't do it.


a wii

you fucking gimp. i had a nightmare i had a ps3 last night. It wasnt good.


Get a 360!

It has Gears of War (you would love this game, seriously. Chainsaw bayonet on your big fuck off machine gun? Hell yeah!)

Also:

The Orange Box - Half Life 2, Ep 1 and 2, plus Portal, which is possibly the best game ever and of course, Team Fortress 2.

Other good stuff: Halo 3, Dead Rising, Stranglehold, Assassin's Creed, Flatout, Bioshock and xbox live is pretty sweet.


:) Halo 3 online seems to be ok now.

Managed to actually play a few days ago without people being randomly kicked off and the game ending!


it's working RIGHT now...

just played team slayer on narrows


ace! I'd join in a game,

but I'm off to the pub!


gamer

tag?


same here!

stupid pub. I OWN at Narrows, unless it's stupid fucking Shotty Snipers. Worst game mode ever.


rockets is worst!

dis halo game next week sometime anyone??


rockets is definately worst.

at least with shotty snipers you can find somewhere good to hide/find someone too engrossed in their sniper and shotgun them in the back.


yeah I'd be up for that.

gametag: Lizard Hips


^ he is right.

All the best games are either out for both, or are xbox exclusives. Bioshock, Halo 3 and Dead Rising should be enough to sway your decision, and both exclusives. Plus xbox live is ACE.


wii

i know it's obviously not the best graphically and has no where near as much power as a PS3 or 360 but it's the most fun console by far. i love my wii, it has a web browser and has some really great games coming out, but if you're even considering buying a PS3 you might as well get a 360 and a wii, it'd still be cheaper.


SNES

no contest


you can

download snes games on the wii


you can download loads of games

on 360 i have sonic2 and street fighter turbo.


it may be

'the most fun' console, shame the games for it are so shit though. Unless you're 8?


or enjoy fun


i agree

i have a 360 and after playing on a friends wii (who also owns his 360 for Real RPG games etc.) just for a laugh as they are great fun!


so shit?

hmmm.
Zelda, Metroid Prime 3 and Mario Galaxy are easily three of the best games I've ever played on anything.


360

by about a million miles. For x-box live and the few good ps3 games that are coming out are coming out on 360 too.


xbox 360!

my boyfriend has one and when i go round i spend all my time playing on it. much to his annoyance.


also

i heard one of the greatest games ever is coming out on the xbox arcade thing.
wait for it...

GOLDENEYE!


re: satsuma

you are a good girlfriend.


Wait for the PS3 to become cheaper

That's what I'm going to do.

I'm not basing this on anything rational.

Actually my two favoutite games ever are coming out on it.

Metal Gear Solid and God of War.

So that is quite rational.
PS3's just strike me as being better.


PS3

My boy has one and I have to admit, it is great.
You don't have to pay for extras after you buy the standard box like with Xbox, and you have a ready to go blu-ray player as well as some very good games (bearing in mind the only one I play is loco roco, but i have to watch 'tother un play warhawk all evening :S)
Also, it has 8 brains and will upscale dvds to as high a definition as possible for your viewing pleasure.
So that's my second hand opinion!


Red Ring of Death

anyone?

Pah to Bill Gates and his world domination.

You'll all be crying when bluray wins the format battle and your silly xbox360s and their additional HD dvd players are useless.

Oh my, I appear to be going slightly schizophrenic... :(


bluray

will never take over from dvds or compact disc games.


Has already beaten HD dvd

which has been dropped by several major's including Disney.


PlayStation 3.

I have both listed consoles, and whilst preferring the 360 several months ago, i now class the PS3 as being far superior in terms of functionality and on the exclusivity front.


assassin's creed

your choice should now be clear.


I've been trying to decide to.

And I have chosen to wait until the 80gb PS3 is on sale in a couple months.
This should be backwards compatible to play all my ps2 games and is cheaper than buying a blu-ray player.


I went the 360 route

just because there was simply no way I was going to fork over money to a company that seems to be making little or no effort with its customers. It's like everyone thinks the PS3 is some beast that'll inevitably crush all its rivals under the weight of it's Real Awesome Power. Don't go buying one because 'some good games might come out on it in the future;' and really, the 360 has such a strong userbase now that it doesn't make sense for many developers to stay 'loyal' to the PS3 as a single platform. I'm fairly sure we'll see MGS4 on the 360 after 6 months or so of it being a Sony exclusive.

The red ring o' death stuff is aggravating; but at least Microsoft are being sports about replacements and extending warranties. Based on Sony's track record through this generation so far, would they do the same?

Don't buy now on the basis of future promise; the games industry feeds off hype and hyberbole, and you'll find that most of the things you've frothed over turn out rubbish. Go on the basis of the things out there now that you fancy playing.

Anyway, I just got my hacked PSP Slim through the other day. Portable SNES Shadowrun, Castlevania: SOTN and Street Fighter Alpha 3; all for the win.


PS3 == BluRay DVD player

That seems to be one of its major plus points.


If you're in the market for a high-definition DVD player

then yes, it's definate value. As a deciding factor if you're trying to choose between a 360 and PS3 when you didn't really care about HD DVDs in the first place.. bleh.

Personally, I'll only be interested in having a HD player when films that I want to buy are going for 2 for a tenner in HMV.


For me, it's the only reason I'd buy a PS3

Although it'd be wasted on the tiny lil 14" TV I use at the moment. Increasingly looking like Blu-Ray is more likely to win out in the HD format war.


A SNES and a Dreamcast.

Really. If I could have any system and my choice of games for it right now, the current generation of consoles can go hang.


I agree...

This generation all have a lot to prove, only the DS really has a decent selection of games at the moment..and the ps3 must be the blandest console of all time.


I don't know about you but

personally I would get a PS3 just for Ratchet and Clank alone.
I love Ratchet and Clank.


<3

Stuck fighting Pirate in asteroid belt at the moment.

Well, I say "stuck", I've died twice and not tried again.


i always do that with games, lol

...I don't actually have the game or a PS3, I just love the series.
Got all the PS2 ones though.


Xbox360

graphics are great, lots of fun games of different variety and halo 3 as well. totally worth it. all my buds have 360s so i'm debating getting a PS3 as a bunch of new and sweet games are coming out soon....the Wii is fun but after a while I just want to go back to the console again.


Bill Gates Will Eat Your Soul!

I have both and, I have to admit, the 360 is the far superior console. Better games, a vastly superior on-line service, and in terms of all round functionality it beats the PS3 hands down- for example you can plug your MP3 player into your 360, and listen to your own music while playing games, something which isn't possible on the PS3. Plus, 360 is now getting nearly all of the PS3's formerly 'exclusive' games, and contrary to one of the posts above GTA4 is hitting all consoles at the same time, but only the 360 version will have exclusive downloadable content

Ratchet and Clank is a bonza lil game, though. Not worth buying a PS3 for, but good fun nonetheless. Until MGS4 arrives my PS3 will continue to act as a grossly overpriced DVD player. :(