Drowned in Sound

Search



Thee Silver Mt Zion
23 votes
?
by Billy Hamilton

Two distinct factions exist within the music reviewing fraternity: there are those quite prepared to give a record a flawless commendation and those who would never entertain such notions of perfection. I belong to the latter sect, believing that absolutely nothing merits a glittering array of 10 golden stars. Of course, it’s an entirely different proposition when dealing with a five-point scoring system – a full house tends to equate to a 9 on big brother’s more expressive scale – but, to this hack, a 10 is the equivalent of ringing the bar-room bell at the end of the night. Everyone should just give up and go home.

Thus far, nothing has persuaded me to reconsider this stance – that is until now. Because Thee Silver Mt Zion Memorial Orchestra & Tral-La-La Band’s [for the purpose of space saving, this mouthful of a moniker will be condensed to Silver Mt. Zion from here on in] 13 Blues For Thirteen Moons is, quite simply, one of the records of 2008, perhaps even the decade. Make no bones about it: this gargantuan beast of an album is the reason for those woofed-up, bass-bulging speakers sitting on your shelf. Christ, Efrim Menuck’s fifth full offering with Silver Mt. Zion may even be the reason for this and every other music site’s existence on the face of planet t’internet.

Excited yet? You really, really should be.

In keeping with the title’s theme, the record doesn’t actually begin until - surprise, surprise - track 13. Up to that point the airwaves are impeded by 12 untitled cuts consisting entirely of linear drone, ensuring baffled glances are flashed towards the CD player and those cowering neighbourhood mongrels are busy striking the record off their end of year hitlist. But this intro is mere scene setting, a build up to the enthralling, anger-driven pandemonium to come. And when it comes, by fuck does it come.

Opener ‘1,000,000 Died To Make This Sound’ begins with a harrowing vocal recital that sounds like it’s been whipped into an echoic frenzy from the bottom of a disused silo before spewing out a sludge of primal drums, savaging guitar and grating violins. Menuck’s off-kilter wails are extraordinary, shooting straight through this wild symphonic storm with untameable ferocity as he yelps “your band, your band is bland, your band is bland ambition” with pious intent. It's a statement that leaves no doubt; other acts are merely unseasoned, unpalatable aperitifs when compared against the fired up, char-grilled flavours of this Canadian banquet.

Production-wise there’s a feel of Liars’ Drum’s Not Dead to the blueprint of 13 Blues… but, whereas Andrew Angus’ mob of miscreants often descended into vicious swamps of uncoordinated feedback, the pairing of Howard Bilerman (former Arcade Fire sticksman) and Radwan Moumneh (the band’s live soundman) have engineered a more purposeful and coherent direction. By allowing the record to ascend as sharp slitting shots of instrumental chaos before retreating into barren atmospheric chasms, they’ve created a bubbling volcano of sound that leaves little clue as to when the next scorching eruption of molten post-rock will besiege eardrums.

And in this lies the most enthralling aspect of 13 Blues… - the anticipation, the not knowing. Previous LPs like Horses In The Sky or He Has Left Us Alone... were at times bleak, barren deserts in which rumbling storms of sound could be heard building long before erupting in the eardrums. But 13 Blues… is a flash flood, an album that saturates the senses with a surge of acerbic, sledge-hammering riffs and drenching orchestration, leaving minds dumfounded and completely uncoordinated in the belly of this titanic aural siege.

The title track is exactly how the apocalypse should sound: a 16-minute shock of chaotic drumming and screaming vocals that explodes with venomous guitar tussles before subsiding into pleading reverb that’s finally dismissed by a swathe of unrelenting instrumentation. Less rabid pace-wise but equally as terrifying, ‘Black Waters Blowed/Engine Broke’ builds slowly into a peak of sniggering strings and discordant percussion until eventually relenting as an ale-swigging tankard that ends with Menuck howling, “We’re building trainwrecks in the setting sun”. He sounds like a rabid-eyed wolf pining to the moon.

Then, suddenly, all is calm. Album-closing opus ‘Blindblinblind leads you serenely to the afterlife, glowing with twinkling cello-plucks and enchanting, dew-soaked harmonies. Displaying all the hallmarks of a desolate punk masterpiece, the track finds Menuck’s pleading crows tinged with the teary eyed edge of Joe Strummer at his most reflective. Utterly magnificent to the point of astonishment, it’s an enveloping finale to an album that stretches beyond emotional boundaries and embeds itself within walls of the heart.

So here’s the stickler: 13 Blues… scores 10 in almost every sense, but to award such an accolade would imply this is a record never to be bettered. And, with a group of musicians as precociously talented as Efrim Menuck and his divine orchestra, it would take a brave man to make such a bold statement.

  • Thee Silver Mt. Zion Memorial Orchestra & Tra-La-La Band 9 / 10
Words: Billy Hamilton

Why didn't you give it 10/10.

Surely it just means it's in the top 10% not that it's completely perfect in every conceivable way.

I never really got Sparks Flew Upward but this sounds very different, maybe they're worth another chance.


i think il buy this

yeah i will!


Great review!

This album has really grown on me. Menucks vocals can grate but there are other times when he gets it completely spot on and the result it magical. Only real downer to this album are some of the cringeworthy lyrics, 'your band is bland', 'the hangmans got a hardon'.

I agree with the score though, I'm enjoying this immensely.


Even if...

The scoring did correspond to a % of records released, there are 11 marks available so the top % is actually 9 (i've yet to see a rating system where this is the case and it doesn't really make much sense to do. A scoring system based on a normal distribution would be better if you were going to do things in such a way)

On the whole I think a 5 star scoring system is better. It probably leads to a greater range of marks reviewers are willing to give. Q used to have an explanation of what their marks actually meant with 5 being 'truly exceptional' and 3 being 'fine within it's field but not for everyone'. It seemed (theoretically) a bit more objective than other scoring systems.

DIS reviews do tend to be on the high side. A lot of records which are worded as 'okay' get given 8s and some flawed records (flawed even in the eyes of the reviewer) have been given 9s. Maybe they just review records they like though!


Funnily enough,

JAH - My music blog, where I do reviews, gives albums scores out of 9 because of that exact reason. 0 to 9 is 10 options.

In anycase, I gave the album 7/9, but it really should be an 8 or a 9...


I'm convinced

I'll go buy this today.. *ahem* or in two weeks.


score systems....

totally and utterly pointless :)


The problem with the score system

is unless an album is truly terrible (or is perfect) it will get a rating of 6,7,8 or 9.

Effectively each score is covering a large range in quality, someone suggested in Mike's post that a half point mark was introduced and I think this would be useful.

Having said that I really look forward to hearing this album and I dont want to be too negative about the site as on the whole it is great


You should

score like Pitchfork and give it 9.9


Hmmmm

Controversial this may be, but, despite liking most of SMtZions output, I really dont like this album. Efrum's voice is just too annoying. Sorry


playing scala

on 7th and 8th april


i would be excited

but i think Efrim's vocals sound like a cat going through a mangle, and thus i only like the first twO ASMZ releases because they have very little of this


.

Oooh its out on the 24th, I'm sure I saw somewhere that it was out on the 10th?

No wonder i cant find it anywhere then!


release date

picked it up yesterday from the HmmmV and, yes, it's very good


left me cold

i've loved every silver mt. zion record i've laid my hands on, but this one feels really heartless and i can't get into it at all. but it seems i'm the only person in the world to feel this way, so i might just be wrong, who knows?


i AM wrong

...about being the only person, after reading other comments. ha.


pitchfork

oooohhhh, pitchfork gave it 5.2