Drowned in Sound

Search



Sea Change Vs Electro-Shock Blues - Which is the most depressing?

6 votes
?
by st_nick_

I vote Sea Change.

st_nick_ | 26 Feb '08, 19:09 | Send note | Report this | Reply

B-B-B

BUMP


sea change

at least manages to conjure some energy from his angst - beck just seems torpid.


Sea change is uplifting

Not depressing.

A masterpiece no less.


a grand album no doubt..

and as powerful a guide to beauty in the world as any i could care to name...

but it is exhaustingly slow.


E had good reason to be depressed

and yet channeled it into something that was ultimately incredibly uplifting and inspiring, as well as being brilliant musically. Beck just moped a bit for no real reason (although I do think that Seachange is nice enough).


Blues

^ agree. Electro shock blues is a masterpiece. Writing a song about finding your dead sister is pretty fucking gut wrenching.


...and then singing it last night

(and every night of his tour probably) to a room full of strangers.


Haven't heard Sea Change

but I don't find Electro Shock Blues depressing at all. I don't think I'd listen to anything I found depressing.