Drowned in Sound

Search



Turkey in the EU.

17 votes
?
by fihiki

Opinions?!?!?!?!??!???

fihiki | 27 Feb '08, 13:28 | Send note | Report this | Reply

Maybe I should say

I'm pretty much against it.

For a pretty selfish reason though.

I just don't really want the countries with the highest amounts of Parliamentary/Conciliary votes (Germany, France, UK, Poland,...) being amongst the most nationalist/right wing countries.

I think we should just give all the votes to Finland, Luxembourg and the Netherlands.

That would be grate.


it's still pretty right wing

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Deutschland uber alles and all that malarkey, eh?


Ahhh....they're not allowed to sing that one anymore.

Besides, their army are all fat bearded sacks of shite these days and their government are so scared of conflict that the German contingent in Afghanistan aren't allowed to go out in the dark! Awwww!


My issue isn't really with the army though.

I mean. I don't care how rubbish their army is. I'm not really worried about an invasion or owt.


Stop scuppering

my really well thought out and well phrased plan, people!!

Nah, you're right. But the UK is pretty Euro-sceptic compared to the vast majority of other member states.


i'd say it is

but the examples of it are subtle and brief. like an urban fox.


But we're talking in a relative way here.

Clearly one can find examples of such things everywhere. I don't think it is any moreso than any other European nation, that's all.


Delight-full


for me it's about what we want the EU to be

primarily and economic free trade zone with other social stuff attached, or more like a United States of Europe. Germany aside, i'm guessing support for Turkey's ascension is found mostly in countries that want the former rather than latter.

I'm with the former too


Nah, nt rly.

Sarkozy's France is pretty much against any kind of Union on a socio-political level, yet he is constantly h8ing on da Turkz.


my final economics coursework piece is on this

40 pages of economic analysis and i don't have any answers. purely on a social level, i'd say yes.


Yes

I think that it is vital that the EU engages with Turkey. Influence from the West will help support them and make it less likely that they will succumb to the more hardcore Islamic elements within the country.

The German opposition to their membership is, sadly, more racist than economic.


This is bad

considering Mehmet Scholl's contribution to German Sporting History.


It'd be brilliant.

The Free Movement thing would be the best. We'd all be able to go over and live in Turkey, where its sunny!


arent the turkeys

islams? highly unorthodox.


is turkey muslim? really??

who knew?


news to me

i thought they were turkish.


...

eh?


The answer is no.

I don't see why we would really, it would be a forced and unecessary union.

We clearly have issues with their human rights record and have opposing views on the idea of freedom.

Oh, and day da muslims, obviously. It's easy to cast this off or make light of it, but it's an important point. A lot of people will have an issue with it. If we can't make integration work on a local level, why would it ever work on a national/supranational level?


all fair points

turkey will get its human rights record in order and the possibility of EU membership can only help that. i'm not sure what you mean by opposing views of freedom though? the fact it's a muslim nation is something to consider, i agree. however i'm not sure how much more significant its religion is than that of orthodox christian countries which are hardly cohesive to europe and european values either. outside of istanbul, ankara and the coast, it's a conservative country - but a conservative country with a very secular state - even under and islamic government - and one that is at the forefront of trying to spark an islamic reformation. i think it should be lauded for that, and ever closer ties to europe - free trade and other benefits - with the prospect of full membership can only benefit turkey and europe as a whole. however, after the massive expansion of the community in recent years, i think we need quite a few years before europe is able to absorb such a large economy / nation.


The islam thing

Isn't a fair point at all. It might be an important consideration, but i fail to see how it's a reason against them joining. Isn't theirs still a strongly secular government? (i think that they're pretty strict on the banning of headscarves)

I have pretty much no support for the UK as a religious nation and, when it comes to religion and politics, really don't think that one should guide the other.


Can't we just

let the Kurds in instead?


I'm gonna say "YES!"

Because the EU is a good thing and should get big and strong
and i've been to turkey and it's BRILL

You'll notice my argument has no political backing - I don't DO politics