Drowned in Sound

Search


Drowned in Sound Event sponsored tours and events.

grinderman nick cave

Dig!!!ing through the catalogue: five of the best from Nick Cave

21 votes
?
by Alex Denney

There’s no two ways about it: Nick Cave is so hot right now. Having cast off the shackles of conscious grandeur assumed on Abattoir Blues / Lyre Of Orpheus’ sprawling two-disc set with the baboon-twatting brilliance of the Grinderman project, Cave returns to the fray in his Bad Seeds role next week with Dig!!! Lazarus Dig!!!.

The video to the lead single of the same name should have given you a clue as to where we’re headed, Cave strutting around like he just don’t give a care while sporting a moustache that practically screams ‘rediscovered mojo’. Even the title seems like a casual lording of his literacy over the mewling monosyllabs that have followed in his wake (ahem), so what better time to linger a while on past achievements with a brief guide to some of the highlights from his career?

No better time.

- - -

Your Funeral... My Trial, 1986

It’s easy to forget how fucking strange the early Bad Seeds records were, and Your Funeral, My Trial knows it better than most; a muffled sob from the well of Cave’s deepening heroin addiction. The otherworldly elegance of ‘Sad Waters’ and ‘The Carny’’s hideous, Freaks-referencing slope are choice cuts but there’s so much that’s enjoyable in the performances it’s difficult to know where to begin – the minimalist, lonesome washes of ‘Stranger Than Kindness’, the way Cave’s vocal falls in and out of step on ‘Jack’s Shadow’, or how the cover of Tim Rose’s ‘Long Time Man’ aims at anthemic but winds up drunk and depressed. Difficult, but engaging.

- - -

Tender Prey, 1988

My personal fave, this; the perfect combination of the primal murk of early Bad Seeds and the classic songwriting guise Cave was to pursue throughout the ‘90s. ‘The Mercy Seat’ is maybe the defining Cave screed, a tale of justice divine and secular narrated by a death row inmate with hallucinatory intensity (“a ragged cup, a twisted mop, the face of Jesus in my soup”), the band doing a pretty fine job of evoking what it might sound like to have 10,000 volts zapping through your head. Also boasts an especially fine pair of ballads in ‘Slowly Goes The Night’ and ‘Watching Alice’.

- - -

Let Love In, 1994

Cave followed the epic narratives of Henry’s Dream with Let Love In; one of his most accessible and purely enjoyable records and a great starting point for the uninitiated. ‘Red Right Hand’ is a terrific showcase for the Bad Seeds’ film noir flair, ‘Do You Love Me?’ is a masterpiece of brooding tension with some knockout lines (“She had a heartful of love and devotion / She had a mindful of tyranny and terror”), while ‘Nobody’s Baby Now’ and ‘Let Love In’ represent some of Cave’s most concisely melodic offerings to date.

- - -

The Boatman's Call, 1997

In retrospect the self-parodying overkill of Murder Ballads feels like a clearing of the decks for The Boatman’s Call; Cave’s most intensely personal album to date and the record that introduced a more sombre, contemplative persona that eschewed the teeth-gnashing sarcasm of yore. Cave’s gone on record recently saying he can’t think back on the record without a wince, a protest from his inner Aussie that such navel-gazing should be prompted by a ‘fucking sheila’, or something. Worry ye not, Nick – ‘Into My Arms’ is probably the most perfect love song you’ve ever recorded. ‘Nuff said.

- - -

Grinderman, 2007

For those who found Abattoir Blues / Lyre Of Orpheus’ Lear-like blustering occasionally difficult to get along with, the Grinderman project was simply a breath of hot, bilious air. Cave’s occasionally struggled to find his muse after the sex-and-death narratives of old played themselves out, but this record finds him supremely at ease with himself; not rolling back the years per se but letting it all hang out with a panache that reminds us why, ‘til someone learns to do it even a tenth as good, we need this man in our lives. And yes, we’re still loving the ‘tache.

- - -

Dig!!! Lazarus Dig!!! is out on Monday (March 3) through Mute Records. The Bad Seeds will play a brief tour of the UK in May, in the meantime keep 'em peeled for an interview with Nick Cave on DiS next week.

May
3 Dublin Castle
4 Glasgow Academy
5 Birmingham Academy
7 London Hammersmith Apollo London
8 London Hammersmith Apollo



I love how these sort of features appear after threads on the message boards

If you're going to include Grinderman, you should include The Birthday Party - the live album being possibly the best.


Considered.

But in a top 5?
(Was there a thread on this? I don't often dip into the boards.)


Hmmmm

I'd spent too much time in the music board thread (which was more along the lines of 'good introduction to Nick Cave'). I think Birthday Party should be in a Nick Cave top 5, because it's so good, and really different to a lot of his stuff, but it depends if your criteria is 'objectively best' or a more comprehensive 'top selection'. I dunno. Nocturama's shit though, eh?


I daren't say...

...but I will say I don't play it all that often.


Nocturama is one of the 'weaker' later Bad Seeds albums

but it has 'There is a Town' on it, which is utterly mesmerising.


i am actually the drownedinsound puppetmaster

mike diver is my kermit. sean is spit the dog.


I was 13 when my brother in law

played me From Her To Eternity. It completely opened my eyes to a whole world of music away from the likes of Wham and Culture Club that I had been listening to previously.
Cabin Fever! just blew me away - it was completely insane to my early teenage brain.
The guy is a complete living genius in my humble opinion.


some good choices

nice to see the very underrated "Your Funeral.." get some props, since it contains a few of his best songs

however, in this Cave fan's humble opinion, the Grinderman record really doesn't stand up with the other four. Good album and all, but a bit too throwaway and marginal for a list like this. Some might even say it was a bit of a self parody ..


Henry's Dream

is my favourite but that may just be because it was the first one i heard, when i was young and impressionable


Me too

for the same reasons. Can we start more Nick Cave threads please?


Legend

Yeah, I've been getting back into Nick Cave before Lazarus comes out and just reminding myself of just how fucking amazing his back-catalogue is.
Totally agree about "Your funeral" being great and 'The Carny' might just be the most batshit crazy song ever recorded.
I think that Lazarus sounds pretty good on the first few listens - might be his least unconventional since 'Let Love In', which can only be a good thing.


nice choice of including 'tender prey' and 'your funeral...'!

i do think his remarkable back catalogue deserves more attention, as it's consistently great and never boring.

why not check out e.g. 'from her to eternity' instead of 'grinderman'?


Ah catch'em in my mouth!

I've always struggled with From Her to Eternity besides the title track. Maybe I should give it another go.
That track is amazing, although unbelievably disturbing.
You really wouldn't have wanted to be Nick Cave;s neighbour in those days would you?


Albert Goes West

I'm totally chuffed that the new album has a song called Albert Goes West!

As regards the back catalogue, that's a really interesting look back you've done there. I actually think Abattoir Blues / Lyre Of Orpheus is one of my favourites - the musical arrangements are wonderful.


What about

Abbatoir Blues /Lyre of Orpheus double whammy?

And Henry's Dream is a belter. Better songs and mood than Let Love In


you should have included his book

'and the ass saw the angel' in this list, it's stunning .... and as good as those early bad seeds albums are i think they're trumped by any of the birthday party records!


Alternative top five ...

1. The Birthday Party - Mutiny Sessions/The Bad Seed EP

2. From Her to Eternity

3. The Good Son

4. Video for "Babe, I'm on Fire"

5. Abattoir Blues/The Lyre of Orpheus

But hey! I love everything he's ever done, with the exception of most of Nocturama.

Even the moustache.