Drowned in Sound

Search



Math Rock: I challge you to prove to me that it's real.

25 votes
?
by ChrisJabe

Shoot.

ChrisJabe | 29 Feb '08, 17:09 | Send note | Report this | Reply

it's just like God

you can't prove it. You gotta have faith.


It can be...you just gotta believe!

I guess it would be nice, though.


i think therefore i am

1+1=2
Math Rock is real QED


Not gonna get any "real" answers am I :(

Well could be quite funny anyway.


You'll get real answers

when you pose a real question. For example, you haven't outlined why exactly you doubt the existence of math rock.


I don't doubt it, I just havn't heard any

I just mean "show me some math rock". Not that hard to work out, is it?


lol.

.


(x+y)

((a - b) x (c/d)) x (5 + e) = math rock!


Easy peasy

Apples in Stereo Rob Schneider's compositions based on the non-pythagorean musical scale...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Pythagorean_scale

Case closed.


Add N to X

?


Six by Seven

.


2+2=5

.


OXES


Simple.

2N+X < # = Q =/= U


oops...

2N+X > # = Q =/= U


Math rock

is synonymous with there's going to be a lot of tap-tap-tapping but instead of being boring you're supposed to think it's philosophically deep. Sometimes this is true, more often than not it really is just boring.


when done badly it's boring

when it's done right, in my opinion, it's amazing. i'm not sure i've ever encountered this 'philosophical' math rock you speak of. would that be like bertrandrussell rock?


ok

math rock is simply another musical genre that people attach to certain bands/styles.all you have to do to see if its real is to see if people use it.there is no 'real' musical genre because people may call the same band different things and so if we take meaning away from one genre we may as well take it away from all of them....and that my friend,is just stupid.


you cannot BE math rock

however you can be
more math rock
or
less math rock
just not actually math rock

thus

I kinda liked it but it's a bit math for me


Oh shitbox

Whoever mentioned Don Can...Thanks...i'd never heard them till now, this may be the missing pieces :)


Haha...

As the genre continues to evolve, some see a departure from math rock's "stern" or "workmanlike"[5] emphasis on difficulty and complexity. According to an LA Weekly music column, groups such as the New York-based Battles, (featuring Ian Williams, another Don Caballero alum), are helping to "make math rock fun and approachable."[5] This is also exemplified by British band Foals, who have added dance-punk elements to the math rock formula.[citation needed]


65daysofstatic are "mathy post-rock.

Dillinger Escape Plan are Mathcore.
Battles are dancy math and very original.
Youthmovies are mathy progressive punk.


My maths teacher used to do

Lighting for Led Zepplin, true story.


ch ch ch check out.

Lava land by Piglet

that is the best i can come up with regarding the synonomous idea that most have about Math Rock being a basically a load of nerds hammering on. beware it is as dry and as hard work listening to it as you'd expect.... very akin to the impersonal and emotionally arrid worst excesses of prog. a la Gentle Giant.

should you wish to try a go at something a little subtler, with a little more listener empathy, then try

Sharks Keep Moving - desert plains EP.

a very enjoyable record, missing out of most of the tat but still sticking with the repetative nature.

personally - i used to see Math Rock as primarilly being about the structure of the song first, and consequently would see bands like Tortoise being quite Mathy, however the most *indie* i can view *math* is Sonic Youths 'Rain on Tin' from Murray Street, nothing about the sound, just about the way the song could be written down in basically an equation(al form).

i do tend to be sympathetic to this style as an artist (many years ago) i used to make prints by exactly the same process.

however as with most genre tags, they are out of date before they are even thought up! ;oD and most refer to Math Rock as to being the sound and its basic start point being an off shoot of Post Rock.


^^^ This

Definitely try some Piglet... some Polvo too maybe.


is polvo math rock though?

i wouldn't say so.

but get polvo anyway because they are brilliant.