Drowned in Sound

Search



youjng knives superabundance
38 votes
?
by Alex Denney

There are few pleasures so fine in this world as handing out slap-downs to the mediocre. Whether they’re assuming fraudulent postures of greatness or simply clogging up the streets with their asinine blather, their presence is difficult to condone. Despite intimations to the contrary, The Young Knives aren’t the humdrum bunch some people have them pegged as.

For all their dummy-spitting bile on sundry topics from Franz Ferdinand to Phil Collins, it’s difficult to escape the feeling that Ashby-de-la-Zouch trio’s principal crime is being in an above-average indie band at a time when such a concept seems more redundant than ever.

But meet them on their own terms and the trio are an amiable prospect, and Superabundance does a creditable job of staving off the second-album malaise that stalks bands of their ilk like paps 'round Wino's gaff after a domestic. The lines between good and evil when it comes to commercially-viable, homegrown indie are getting thinner by the day; frequently it’s only a question of emphasis that distinguishes one from the other. So while ‘Fit 4 U’’s dubby hooks could be Hard-Fi raised on Kafka novels if you squint your ears a bit, the scenester-baiting ‘Up All Night’ sounds a little like sour grapes ‘til you realise The Cribs have been getting away with this shit for ages.

If that line sounds faintly patronising, there are a couple of moments on Superabundance deserving of our unqualified praise: ‘Counters’ blazes out of the traps with a pulse-jacking riff and a surprisingly ribald bass line, yelped vocals giving the proceedings a fraught air as opposed to the knitted-brow obstinacy displayed elsewhere. And tellingly at eight songs into the record, the band sees fit to drop one of the best songs of the set in ‘Dyed In The Wool’, where most would flounder self-importantly in the shallows of their own complacency.

If there’s a quibble to be had with this otherwise commendably solid platter, it’s that there’s a lop-sided feel due to a second half which makes serious inroads into virgin psychedelic territory but feels secreted away somewhat, as if the band couldn’t quite bring themselves to make a clean break from the angular hi-jinks that made them their name. That’s not exclusively a bad thing, mind; 'I Can Hardly See Them' is an unexpectedly bruising foray into the realms of trippydom, but the similarly spacey ‘Rue The Days’ suffers badly from the kind of indie bloat the band have skilfully managed to avoid elsewhere.

Their flaws we all know about and they continue to run up against them here – not weird or intricate enough for the sophisticates, not savvy enough tune-wise to bother the top ten any time in the near future, Superabundance nonetheless forges a quiet victory to remind us why there’ll always be a space on the proverbial pencil case to scribble bands like The Young Knives’ good name.

  • Young Knives 7 / 10
Words: Alex Denney

Well as

no-one here likes em (don't slagg the DiS) let me proudly say yet again.

They're awful, humdrum, uninteresting numptys and I really hope they dissappear into nothing-ness.


"No one here likes them?"

What are you talking about?


Young Knives

are aces.

My thoughtful review.


YK vs Marmite

Such divided opinion! Well, I love 'em. Voices of Animals and Men was one of my faves from last year and the new material they played at the Astoria recently had me licking my lips in anticipation of the new album. Can't see why so many people feel such antipathy towards them - its not like they're offensive or up their own arses or anything.....


"No one here likes them?"

I think quite a few people at the Astoria enjoyed the Young Knives set last week (myself included). "No one here likes them?" - a humdrum, uninteresting numpty comment if I ever read one.


i like them

i'l always remember the first time i heard tremblings of trails, such a good song, and i liked terra firma, havnt heard up all night yet.


I realise

me saying that means a bunch of people are gonna say the contary, but seriously, whats the point.
They were on the end of some serious lashings a few days ago.


Besides

if you ever needed any evidence to discredit my point...
The first CD I ever bought was a Nickelback one, and I liked it 0.o


Again...

what are you talking about?

You say "no one on here likes them" which simply isnt true. You may not like them and thats fine.

But, bizarrely, you dont actually speak for the whole DiS community.


I suppose

its what I get for not carefully considering my every word on boards like this eh.


Speech lasts for seconds,

words last forever.


He's lying.

Look: the clue's in the name.

Nice review: first time I've heard a bassline called 'ribald' but it seems appropriate for House.


Mentalists!

I read the comments with amazement. The Young Knives are a superb band, angular, clever, witty with a great ear for catchy melody yet twist it with unique effect. I havent had opportunity to hear the new album but Voices of Animals and Men must be one of the best debut albums this decade and having seen them way back in 2005 they were an awesome live act with warmth humour and real energy. Any band that comes up with the lyrics "I made a collage of dead peoples faces" and "You were screaming at your mum and I was punching your dad". Whoever said they were "awful, humdrum, uninteresting numptys" has had too much cocoa.....


what

does "angular" actually mean in reference to a band?


I'm going to see them tonight.

My expectations are low. They were fucking awful at Bestival.


meh...

They were so average I'm tempted to write an article about it. They made me question why people make music. I'm not joking.


you were expecting them to be shit.

you came home and decided with yourself that they were shit.
quelle surprise?


I wasn't expecting them to be shit,

and I was prepared to give them a second chance.
The thing that really pissed me off last night was their attitude. They seem to have a real chip on their shoulder. They've achieved a moderate level of success, for a very average band, and now just seem really bitter that they can't progress further


I am DiSappointed

how often DiS gives favor to homegrown bands which don't deserve it. Meh.


Spelling

Correction: favour.


He lives on the other side of the Atlantic,

there was no spelling mistake.


young knives: If this band didn't exist

what band would I have to be interested in, eh?
http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=10642647
I would have to move to australia, or start liking the pigeon detectives.


Wow

People still rate these guys, despite everything.


Tour in Autumn

Did anyone see them on it?


Despite what?

.


I like the Young Knives but...

...that's an atrocious album cover. I was hoping for something nicely hand-drawn like the Terra Firma single artwork.


I'm

looking forward to my copy of the album dropping through the letterbox like a fat kid looks forward to cake.

I'm also surprised that they divide opinion so much - is it because of their music, or their appearance/attitude? I can't see how they would induce apoplectic rage in anyone


I've always thought The Young Knives were terrible.

This was before I even knew what DiS was. They do seem to have their fair share of haters, maybe it's unjust or maybe they're just shit.

There is absolutely nothing to them they're as bad as Snow Patrol in the "sending me to sleep" stakes.


totally...

...wrong. one of the best bands this country has produced for a long time. a lot lot better than your typical 'skinny jeans-indie' by numbers hazardous shite.


got to say

what's with all the negativity? Ok they're not the bleeding edge but this sort of ire is usually reserved for hard-fi types round these rarified parts... it's just catchy, above average IQ indie-pop. Moan about something that deserves it. Or not. I won't be buying the record, but I won't be sending them severed body parts in the post either...


excellent, you made my corrections

can I have a Sub's cheque now please? :D


well i like em

and i dont give a shit if no one else does.


Depressed now

I love this band.

They're fun. As for the chips on their shoulders, do some people not recognise tongues wedged firmly in cheeks when they see them?


First album was excellent...

With every track a winner. I'm not sure about Up All Night, however, so will await the album with eager interest. I think 90% of the negative comments can probably attributed to the band's perceived 'uncool' look, and hey, at least they're generating some fevered debate.


I stumbled across a Young Knives

interview the other week. The singer proudly displayed quite a delightful jacket.


I'm glad they

put "Current of the River" on the album, I always thought it was a cracker of a b-side.


I thought that too

Great tune. LP might be a grower. Im liking it but its not set me on fire yet.


On repeated plays....

it's bloody good!


I also love this band

they should be treasured.


That NME review

the guy didn't like that it was too depressing - thats not a critical review is it?
In his mind does not upbeat mean bad?


Very good album

for me