Drowned in Sound

Search



the best blood brothers album:

39 votes
?
by richjj

crimes!

richjj | 27 Mar '08, 16:47 | Send note | Report this | Reply

probably

Burn Piano Burn lacks variety, and Young Machetes is a bit scatterbrained. Both excellent nonetheless.


*Island


well

it's true that Burn... lacks immense variety, but looking at it as an album, it works magnificently. I've yet to hear anything like it.


Young machetes

has become my favourite but i fucking LOVE crimes


i love YM

but i find Crimes more well rounded and coherrent.


agreed

but the fact that set fire to the face on fire is on YM means that it wins, because that is the best blood brothers song EVARZ


n00b


It's not as good as

Trash Flavoured Trash.


that song

blows my mind.


probably just about

though i love love love young maschetes


CRIMES CRIMES CRIMES!

young machetes is very good though.have they definately split now???


yeah i split them up

because i am a massive gay.
nah
johnny and + cody rock: http://www.myspace.com/jaguarloveband
Mark rocks:
http://www.myspace.com/djgajamagic
+ http://www.myspace.com/champagnechampagne
Jordan and Cody rule:
http://www.myspace.com/headwoundcity

fkyeah.


ive heard head wound city

is that the band with him from yeah yeah yeahs in as well?i liked what i heard if it was them.il check the others out :)


Yep

And the legend that is Justin Pearson too. Pretty much a super group.


any band with justin pearson in

is a super group.


any band with justin pearson in

sounds the same.

apart from the pre-locust ones.


and?


its incredible!

gabe serbian as well!


Young Machetes


No love out there for

'this adultery is ripe'?


i love march on....

primarily for new york slave. bpib has a massive place in my heart tho so i'd go for that as my favourite


I like 'This Adultery is Ripe'

but compared to what they evolved into, it's not really up there with the likes of the major 3 albums they recorded after 'March on Electric Children.'


Crimes

It's still kind of nasty, but they seemed more comfortable with what they were doing. YM is still amazing, but it's missing something. That said, Vital Beach and Giant Swan off of YM are fucking amazing songs.


I'm still in for Burn, Piano Island, Burn.

Guitarmy is one of the best songs EVARRRR.


Crimes for me


yep Crimes

been listening to it lots & lots recently


Burn, Piano Island, Burn.

My a million miles. It might be in my top 10 favourite albums of all time. The Ross Robinson production really brought out the best in them, just as it did for At the Drive In.


i totally agree

plus it has the best songs. and one of the best endings to an album ever.

crimes is a close second.


if you were only gonna leave me with one album it'd be 'Piano Island' because it was the first i hea

But they finished on a high, 'Young Machetes' is their best.


. . .

Crimes.


Haha, Diver sneaks it in...

didn't cha givvit a bad review somewhere? I'm not complaining, your writing about them got me into BB.


Burn, Piano Island Burn

EASILY

One of my favourite albums ever, every song is amazing, and it does what I think every good album should do - makes you desperately want to be in that band.


troof

crimes
burn piano island
march on
young machetes
this adultery is ripe

however they are all fucking brilliant. RIP. :(:(:(:(


This is a good thread

for me, as I neglected to explore them until Young Machetes, was going to get a ticket to ULU before it passed, and then they split up...

I ADORE Young Machetes and've got Ambulance vs. Ambulance on 7", but where else should I go? Burn, Piano Island, Burn, sounds/looks good, right?


Crimes

but I adore YM and BPIB.

They took everything I love about rock and threw it into their stuff; great live act, awesome lyrics, nuts instrumentation, RIFFS and just plenty of WTF moments to keep you guessing. They were very close to my heart and people who haven't should give them the time of day.

Crimes is also my fave album cover ever.


Ditto

I love Ambulance Vs Ambulance


burn piano island burn

is their only consistently good album, in my opinion.


Burn Piano Island Burn

But I'd say the first three tracks on their last three albums have been fucking phenomenal.

If anyone hasn't searched for it, try and get Pink Tarantulas, that's about equal to 50% of the BPI,B material


Burn Piano Island Burn

has the right mix of shared vocals (as opposed to later albums of pure Johnny tracks) and the storytelling is amazing, the chaos of sound has never been beaten and tracklisting wise is their best. Ah, it's so much better than Crimes and YM.

Oh and Johnny's new band isn't get much love...

http://www.myspace.com/pastlivesmusic


I like these guys better than Jaguar Love

I would really rather have a full length Head Wound City LP though.


*Jordan's

not Johnny's.

UGH.


music should be up by the end of the month

can't wait its going to be unbelievably amazing. better than jaguar love. and agreed about storytelling aspect to burn piano island. lyrically theres no better band.


..

and musically and everythingly.


yes

crimes


Right. As someone who's only heard 'This Adultery is Ripe'.

I feel like someone writing on a Radiohead thread who's only heard Pablo Honey.

I really liked that record. They've done even better ones. Cool.

So I should really get 'Crimes'? Yeah?


i'm all about young machetes

huge gold ak-47 and laser life are the 2 best songs they've ever done, and he rest of the album isn't too shabby either.


Island

was a face melting tech assault tank whereas Crimes was its milder mannered brother who had a soft side and liked D&D.


Burn, Piano Island, Burn

is the jaw-dropper. Then:

Crimes
Young Machetes
March On Electric Children
This Adultery Is Ripe


If you ask me

they never wrote a 100% fully consistent, obvious "best album". Each of them have their patchy patches, however brief. Contained within their last three albums, however, is some of my favourite music ever written.

Which is why I can never reply to "top X albums ever" topics.


new to me

bizzarely...i only listened to blood brothers for the first time about 10 days ago! mate lent me their cd. first 2 tracks off young machetes are great!!! atonal lovelyness. hardcore yet poppy.


in a friendly way

where is the fault in Crimes?
I just can't see it, for me it is a 10/10 album.
:)


i just never took to Crimes.

In order i'd put:

1. Burn, Piano Island, Burn
2. Young Machetes
3. March On Electric Children
4. Crimes

(not heard the debut)


get the debut

its amazing. but good order otherwise.


Well,

as much as I like ¨Feed Me To The Forest¨, Blood Brothers have proved that they know how to start an album better. Also, ¨The Shame¨ and ¨Giant Swan¨ are probably better closers, even though ¨everybody needs a little devastation¨ gets stuck in my head all the time.

And sometimes my attention starts to waver around Wolf Party and Celebrator. Tiny little stuff like that - for me Crimes is a solid 9. And so not perfect.


BURN, PIANO ISLAND, BURN

by about 6.4 metres


would probably go for

burn piano island. although listening to this adultery is ripe most atm. depends what mood you're in, each album will give you something different. which is awesome.