Drowned in Sound

Search



Bon Iver
41 votes
?
by Dom Gourlay
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 12/05/2008
  • Label: 4AD

The story of Justin Vernon and how this record came about is almost too far-fetched to be true, and yet after a few listens to For Emma, Forever Ago it soon becomes apparent that here is someone who clearly isn't faking it by any stretch of the imagination. Every last word, succinct pause, over-exaggerated syllable – it’s no coincidence that the circumstances and surroundings within which this album was recorded were pretty much wholly responsible for the beauty contained within it.

Justin who? Oh yeah, before I go any further it’s probably best to go back to the beginning. Having played in several bands within the Wisconsin folk and art-rock scene, his most recent and more accomplished troupe DeYarmond Edison were undergoing something of a transformation, one that would eventually see them briefly relocate to North Carolina before subtly disintegrating, citing "musical and artistic differences" as their reason for calling time before potential success could come knocking.

Vernon moved back to Wisconsin and promptly set up home in a remote log cabin, living a self-imposed primitive lifestyle whereby tasks such as chopping logs for firewood and hunting wildlife for food became daily chores. Partly as a form of protest over what he saw as a kind of desertion by his former bandmates, and partly to re-evaluate where to go next, Bon Iver was born.

Three months of writing and recording - often in ten- to twelve-hour blocks - ensued, the process only being able to continue at times thanks to Vernon's self-taught hunting skills: some of his prey could be exchanged for recording equipment or guitar repairs.

By early 2007, For Emma, Forever Ago was pretty much complete, in demo form at least, and Vernon, now back in a civilised habitat, set about finalising a record that will almost certainly ensure him recognition for many a year to come.

I do apologise if the background to this record has been emphasised somewhat but without it For Emma, Forever Ago would never have existed, and it’s probably fair to say much of this record wouldn't make sense without it being explained. Nothing less than a full account of the events surrounding the record could be described as being overstated.

Although comprising only nine songs spread over less than forty minutes, For Emma, Forever Ago is one of the most captivating collections these ears have heard for some time. Although comparisons to the likes of Will Oldham and Elliott Smith are obvious and to be expected, there are also similarities both vocally and structurally with TV On The Radio's Tunde Adebimpe and the wizened folk of Iron And Wine, not to mention a slight hint of Micah P Hinson, too.

What sets Bon Iver apart from many of the aforementioned is the sheer substance and obvious depth of personal experience that has formulated each and every one of these songs down to the bone.

'Skinny Love' and its emotive descent into a bittersweet riposte that could be against his former colleagues ("In the morning I'll be with you / But it will be a different kind / I'll be holding all the tickets / And you'll be owning all the fines") paves the way for the closing evaluation of 'Re:Stacks', Vernon exclaiming "This is not the sound of a new man or crispy realisation / It's the sound of the unlocking and the lift away…", almost in relief that his sojourn has been a worthwhile exercise.

Which it has, as For Emma, Forever Ago testifies. I could pull out couplets from the other seven pieces here, but that would only spoil the surprises that await. For you there's only one thing left to do: purchase this record and elevate Vernon to the unlikely status of recording star at a level his talents so obviously deserve. This album is simply wondrous.

  • Bon Iver 9 / 10
Words: Dom Gourlay

This album has 9 written all over it.

Nice review. Going to both his London shows, I hope he's good live?


He was amazing on Saturday at ATP.

I have the album but I've not had a chance to hear it yet. Kind of like Sigur Ros vocals on Alt. Country music, I thought.


Yep,

he was fab at ATP - I didn't know what to expect at all despite loving the album. I really want to see him again at a smaller venue.


my album

of the year so far.

so, there you go Dom.


"Wondrous" is indeed the word -

Brilliant.


...

One of my favourite artists at the minute. Incredible stuff.


The vocals remind me of

TV on the Radio - weirdly.

Good but not as life-changing as the reviews would suggest. I presume this is only just out on CD. I legally downloaded it ages ago.


I fucknig love this record

Possibly my favourite of the year so far


Me too

It's the vocals methinks

Great record


Saw him ATP

and procceded to check this out, I got a feeling one of my fav new artists, Actually brilliant stuff!


the vocals on this album are fucking stunning

so rich and lush.
End of.


Great Review

9/10 is about right. The way he's layered all his voice all over the record is stunning.


Nice review DG

No need to apologize for the background bits...that's what sold me on getting this, eh.


this is simple and beautiful

the skelatal backbone to all he songs are really good and make this album so lonley in parts. But that is counterbalanced by his layers and layers of vocals intertwining. This is going to be one to stick on late into the night I think.


Sweet - looking forward to seeing him in Sheff tomorrow

with Iron & Wine. It'll be like eating red beans and rice at the jukejoint.


Great Escape!

He's playing with Wild Beasts at Great Escape too! Awesome.


It's a good album

but certainly not a 9 to me...


If Foals is a 9

then this most definitely is!


If Foals is a 9

then 99% of the albums released this year will be at least 9 !


spot on

totally agreed, this is a wonderful record.


yep, great record

agreed too


absolutely wonderful album

really looking forward to seeing him next month.


dear lord i love this

i've had the album on repeat for the past three weeks. i can't wait to see them live. everyone i know who has has just cried. in a good way naturally.


I'd never thought

about him sounding like Hinson, but I guess he does.

This album took a while to stun me, but it definitely did. Great mood music, and "Re: Stacks" is one of the best songs I've heard in my many years on Earth. It never gets old.


9/10?


10/10

i reckon.

one of the best albums ive ever heard.


fantastic review

a ten for me though.

i didnt think The Midnight Organ Fight could be beaten, but there you go


To be honest

that back story is a big load of pretentious tit...

But this record is fabulous.


See them live

Have just bought tickets to their SBE gig in September, also have tickets to St Giles Church, and also caught them supporting Jens Lekman at Scala on Tuesday... amazing to see them live, and hear those songs in a live setting... had the record since it was re-issued, and listened to it on repeat for at least a week! One of my favourite albums ever, so simple and beautiful.


Speechless.

My God, there are no words to describe this album. "Skinny Love" is one of the most incredible songs I've heard in a long time. I really suggest you see this man live.