Drowned in Sound

Search



David Bowie - Best Album?

24 votes
?
by thequeenisdead91

Simple thread this. What is David Bowie's best album?

thequeenisdead91 | 19 Apr '08, 20:44 | Send note | Report this | Reply

^^^ same

it is amazing


Hunky Dory

Thanks.


I can't separate Low and Station To Station.

Oh, alright then, Low.

But his run of creativity between 1971-1980 is pretty untouchable.


LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW

LOW.

that is all. x


What Mr Bones wrote..

was my first thought on reading the title of this thread. Also get 'Alladin Sane' & 'Stage'


I love Low

.... I haven't herd many more though


all saints

comp instrumentals,always pref bowie when he didnt open his trap.


Low


Aladdin Sane

Lodger
Scary Monsters
Hunky Dory
Station To Station


Low had a huge effect on men's hairstyles throughout the western world

I was struggling with my own hair just when that record came out. I started seeing that haircut everywhere. Low is amazing. Check out the Phillip Glass "Low" reprise/Glassified record- it's pretty good and a must for Low freaks.


I thought about it

And I cant seperate Low and Hunky Dory as my favourites. I guess they both represent the peaks of is 2 most creative phases for me.


it depends on the day dunnit

Man Who Sold The World
Hunky Dory
Ziggy
Aladinsane
Pin Ups
Diamond Dogs
Young Americans
Stationtostation
Low
Lodger
Scary Monsters

are pretty much perfection

71-80

the greatest run of brilliant albums by anyone ever

and I am aware I have omitted Heroes

I have my reasons


Im Curious that you omitted Heroes

Personally I think it is close too Low and I prefer it over Lodger.

Trying to think of reasons to not like it

Is it to experimental? to wide ranging influence? too many non songs?


hmmmm

well, i think if you remove the title track

which is obviously towering genius

you are left with a somewhat scapp set of songs, a lot of them seem unfinished, and, I think the instrumentals are more impressive
and
well
it just seems a bit of a wlrk in progress as an album

low has balance and majesty

heroes seems unfocussed and random
and
really badly produced

compared to Low, it sounds mono

now
you could accuse Lodger of randomness and it might be that Lodger contains songs left off the prev albums and is quite scrappy
but
it's consistent, it's sorta fun and nippy, and all the better for being a pop record.

but mebbe that's just me


It's A fair critisism

I come to Bowie from a different perspective than most as I am a massive Eno fan and I think it's mostly the instrumental tracks that I am drawn too, I reallu like that they expanded the scope of these after Low, add the majestic title track and it's a pretty good listen for me.
Now it's Young Americans that i can't get into beyond the title track.


Top... 8?

Aladdin Sane
Heathen
Low
Heroes
Scary Monsters
Ziggy Stardust
Outside
Diamond dogs

At the moment, my favourite is Heathen. Definitely the best album he's done in the last ten years.

Also, he's re-issuing Santa Monica (again). If you need a Bowie live album from the 70's, get this one.


I cant

believe you havent put hunky dory in that top eight >_<


And in the death

as the last few corpses lay rotting.... Ric did announce that his fave Bowie album was Diamond Dogs!

Then Man Who Sold the World - both of which are quite similar in their dystopian ways...


It's a good record

but it doesn't blow me away like the two that follow it. Saw the Ryko re-issue in a shop the other day, and couldn't be bothered to pick it up. That's how nonplussed I am by it.


I think I dig it

because the book 1984 really inspired me, and it sounds like some kind of macabre Derek Jarmen style movie adaptation of it! But yes indeed... people do seem to prefer the Berlin stuff on the whole.


^ I agree with all of that

but if I had to call it, Ziggy Stardust pips it for me.


i meant i agreed with teepee

the replies annoyingly end up in the wrong place...


Love V2 Schneider and Moss Garden

on Heroes, "Heroes" is one of my favorites.


Heroes

is my all time favourite Bowie song.


1. Outside for me


Hunky Dory

obviously.


Low

for me.


i would have to say

the best of bowie


Diamond Dogs

I love everything about it; music and artwork. Love the bit of poetry(Future Legend) that opens "Diamond Dogs" and all the post apocalyptic imagery woven throughout. Love Bowie's guitar playing, his sax playing on "We Are The Dead" (which is a phrase that passes between Winston and Julia in "1984") still gives me shivers and I still love trying to make all the little vocal parts on "Chant Of The Ever Circling Skeletal Family" Move it up, move it up!


Lets Dance!

XD


That song

"Chant Of The Ever Circling Skeletal Family"

is my mum's favourite Bowie song!

My fave is 'Lady Grinning Soul'.


Low

definitely Low for me. Speed Of life. Sound And Vision. Breaking Glass. Be My wife. Brilliant stuff.


Earthling

Extra points for trying something different. Hello spaceboy, whatta song