The Cure
Tom Waits
Elliot Smith
I only have Figure 8, XO, Head on the Door and Rain Dogs. I need to know where to go. And i've just noticed that Play.com sale. Guide me oh opinionated ones.
What are your top 3 of each?!!
The Cure
Tom Waits
Elliot Smith
I only have Figure 8, XO, Head on the Door and Rain Dogs. I need to know where to go. And i've just noticed that Play.com sale. Guide me oh opinionated ones.
What are your top 3 of each?!!
With these? Just cover your eyes and grab one but if I gotta pick
The Cure:
The Trilogy albums: Pornography, Disintergration and Bloodflowers- they are are dark and delicious.
Tom Waits:
(I haven't heard his last 3 albums)
But these are considerd gems in my music library: Frank's Wild Years, Swordfishtrombones and Bone Machine.
Elliot Smith: I was living in Portland (where he launched his music career) when he first came on the scene and everybody in town was talking about him (and another local band Dandy Warhols). My first of his records was from his band Heatmiser "Dead Air". The writing on "Dead Air" was half Elliot Smith and half Neil Gust but ther're all good songs and "Dead Air" is almost my favorite Elliot Smith album.
Top 3 are: Roman Candle, Dead Air and From A Basement On The Hill (that one is still too painful to listen too at present)
This is not the real Trilogy.
Bloodflowers is absolutely shit.
The real trilogy is :
Seventeen Seconds
Faith
Pornography
Add Disintegration and you have anything great by the Cure.
Yeah
I don't accept revisionist history either, lyle. Although Bloodflowers ain't as bad/Disintegration ain't as good as you think...but we've had this discussion before. I grew up with the Cure so I'm like those sad old people who go to see Paul McCartney...with better taste, obv. :)
Tom Waits. I dunno.
Anything and everything by ES.
How is high ranking Bloodflowers revisionist?
the man asked for favs and I gave them. Bloodflowers is a great Cure album. I just used the trilogy as a reference and it just happens to be covenient with my reality. Bloodflowers is the first Cure record I could stand to listen to since 1984 when I went to one of their shows and they totally shit on the whole audience (rabid cure fans) by being hours late and then blowing everyone out the door with huge stacks just so they could get the hell out of there and go to there next shit gig.
So anyway, explain the whole revisionist history thing to me
we are talking opinions here, not history. Show me the official document that says Abbey Road was the best Beatle album or Turn On The Bright Lights the best Interpol. Even though it might be so, it isn't, nor could it ever be historical knowledge.
What could be better than Robert having a mid life crisis in a Japanese sex cubicle?
Bloodflowers is still king cure!
elliott smith: everything
i r totally serious. just about everything released is absolutely wonderful. but if i had to pick a top three:
* either/or
* xo
* roman candle
probably in that order.
that is the correct answer
though i'm not sure about number three. i'd be tempted to say:
1. either/or
2. xo
=3. roman candle / s/t / from a basement
6. Figure 8
but that is in no way saying that figure 8 is bad, i just listen to it the least out of them.
new moon is also worth a listen. i get a massive :( whenever i think about the fact he's gone.
For Elliott Smith I'd say
From a Basement on the Hill,
XO,
Either/Or
Apart from 'Elliott Smith' which I don't own (the result of an extreme laziness which leads me to make totally irrational decisions) I think I prefer each album to the last except Figure 8 which, like Roman Candle, is an incredible piece of work, but, for me, a less enjoyable listen.
Excellent thankyou
for your input!
Gonna pick up Disintegration, Pornography, roman candle and swordfishtrombones and bone machine i think.
SAfe