Drowned in Sound

Search



The Dismemberment Plan

12 votes
?
by maximuso

Where to start? I'm listening to a life of possibilities and its a really good song, any other recommendations, best albums etc?

maximuso | 28 Apr '08, 21:59 | Send note | Report this | Reply

Emergency & I

is best place to start in my opinion. Terrific album.

Change is pretty good too.


the plan ruled!

These 2 albums are easily the best. The first two have some good tracks, but aren't anywhere near as good.


Disagreed

Is Terrified is my favourite album, followed by Emergency & I then Change. Is Terrified was the most playful and the sound of a band having fun doing what they were doing. Emergency still had some of that, but they'd started trying to actively hone their songmanship at that point and there's a touch of forcedness about some of the tracks on there.


I only have

Is Terrified, but that's pretty amazing too.


Change

purely for Timebomb (Which is how i got in to them)
I love them so much it makes me wee myself thinking about it.


Start with Emergency & I

Then get Change.

The other albums are great, but the above are far more accessible.


you have to get emergency & i

it's immensely good.

i like change too but it's more weary.
more about the singer and less about how good the band are.


I've only got Emergency and I

what other albums would people recommend- are any a bit rawer/louder?


...Is Terrified

is an almost perfect mix of the rawer stuff and the R&B-influenced later stuff.

It's probably my favourite album of theirs but The City is my favourite song of all time.


Yes!

Is Terrified is the one for you.

The debut album ! has a few of fantastic tracks along that vein, but a quite a few not-so-good ones too unfortunately.


Emergency & I and Change

then Is Terrified. Ace band.


<3 this band

Emergency & I is incredible, Change is almost as good. Travis Morrison's lyrics are absolutely incomparable.


I like Change the best actually

I haven't listened to Emergency in years for some reason. Sounds like I should also get hold of Is Terrified.