Drowned in Sound

Search



Sigur Ros or Johnny Foreigner?

17 votes
?
by meandthatarmy

Both Sigur Ros' and JoFo's new albums come out on iTunes tomorrow and I can only afford one, but I can't decide which.

So which one do you think I should get?

(I like them both equally, by the way)

meandthatarmy | 01 Jun '08, 21:09 | Send note | Report this | Reply

tricky one this

after () I would've said definitely Sigur Ros but I (thought I hate to say it) think they might be slightly on the wane these days. Wheras 'JoFo' may not yet have the pedigree but are more likely to be exciting and fresh.


JoFo

cos they are little nd need more cash they seem hungry in their tour diarys


I have Takk

It's very good, but has significant dips and soars in quality.


I already know the JoFo album is amazing

but know nothing of the Sigur Rós album, so I'd suggest the former


Johnny Foreigner

you'll probably hear the entirety of the Sigur Ros record on a BBC nature program anyway.


ooh you bitch

can't have any of these bands getting above their station now can we?


haha

it's not a bad thing that Sigur Ros are getting played on TV - but the BBC were over excessive with 'hoppipolla' soundtracking every single scene of 'natural beauty' in their programming. I've heard it in countless programs, it's a little too predictable.


Yes,

I can see why hearing songs on the telly could put people off buying it.


jofo are ok, No patch on sigur ros

Plus the single is fantastic

so get the sigur ros album

and its out tomorow on itunes!!!!

EXCITEMENT


you can't really compare them, can you?

they're both groups of people who make some sort of music, that's where similarities end really. It'd be like comparing Trifon Ivanov to George Best.


whats a George Best fiver?

Well I guess it has his face on it or somat but why what why why?


ooo nice

I bet my Dad would have liked one of them he is a big Man U fan has been since he was a kid.


Im not comparing them

but I personally like listening to sigur ros more than Jofo.

So if I was in his position I would get the sigur ros album.

Plus, is it really out tomorow??? I cant see this fact anywhere


Johnny Foreigner defo.

Sigur DROSS more like...


JoFo

I don't really have a reason, I just think you should


out of interest

re: sigur ros. why would you want to buy music that's largely all about texture and dymanics and the sound itself in a crap format like m4a?


because...erm...I like the music?

Is that not a good enough reason these days?


hahahaah

it's nothing to do with being a pedant. would you buy it on cassette if it was released earlier?


m4a

is more practical than a cassette. is there really that much difference in quality between a cd and an m4a?


i suppose not if you're listening

on crappy laptop speakers. it just strikes me as strange to pay the same price for an album in a worse format, especially when it's the sort of music where sound quality is surely a premium issue.


Daddy or chips?

Sigur Ros ...marginally ...I think : S


johnny foreigner

never listned to sigur ros


are jofo reaaallly that good?

Iv not heard the album yet


the mini album

is superb. absolutely.


Eh?

Says here Sigur Ros is out on the 23rd and is available for direct pre-ordering from tomorrow. Also says here it's streaming from the 9th from their official site.


yeah

its not out

you might want to go for jofo then :p


if sigur ros

was out i'd say that. buy a Johnny Foreigner CD at a show, and tell them how much you love them, it will warm their hearts.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Von Südenfed: what's really authentic?