Drowned in Sound

Search



the roots rising down
15 votes
?
by Ed Graves
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 28/04/2008
  • Label: Def Jam

It steals away your breath, entirely unexpectedly: after so many records of engrossing beats and socially conscious rhymes, Philly hip-hop collective The Roots are getting angry.

Rising Down was making waves ahead of release, word rumbling upwards that alterations were being made to its tracklisting, collaborations with emo superstars trimmed from the end product as tones upbeat didn’t sit pretty with what preceded them. ‘Birthday Girl’, featuring Fall Out Boy’s Patrick Stump, does ultimately appear, but it’s positioned at the rear, an afterthought in the band’s mind shackled in place by their paymasters. It’s easy, immediately, to hear why: a summery song about girls doesn’t truly fit in with tracks directing sights at the internet’s decaying of the music industry, the declining state of the environment, and the ills that loiter about us without anyone doing the slightest fuck all about them.

The first track proper, the title track, sets our tone: dark, menacing, heavy of low end and vicious of rhyme. Conflict diamonds, tax rises, natural disasters, slavery, downloading – “Does a computer chip have an astrology, and when it fucks up does it give you an apology?” – and more… it’s a dizzying blitz of imagery, set to a bombastic pulse that gets the digits tapping straight away. The aural malevolence manifests again in ‘Get Busy’, where black market firearms rip apart neighbourhoods. And where are these neighbourhoods? “Southside, northside, westside, worldwide.” The Roots are addressing concerns on a global scale, looking beyond their immediate surroundings to tell us – you, me – that these things are happening. And they’re closer than you might think.

Again the internet is up for attack: “Fuck the internet”, three simple words that skip straight to the point. But this isn’t an album made by nostalgia-loving sorts for similarly minded consumers who think iTunes is something you get from a newsagents when you’ve a cold. It’s aware of actions and reactions of a very contemporary nature, observations astute and topical. As America rolls towards a new dawn, a dynasty rightly prevented from laying root, changes will only be made after mistakes are rectified. Rising Down’s title almost seems to mirror this: upward movement must be balanced by retrospective recognition of what went wrong to necessitate change in the first place.

Black Thought’s tirade of ‘75 Bars’ exhilarates, with a ‘nigger’ count that’d make Nas blush. It’s purposely aggressive of both language and delivery; it’s meant to sound violent, without ever advocating any physical altercations. It has the hairs standing to attention from its first four bars. ‘Criminal’ focuses on matters closer to home – small-time theft, gambling, and ultimate comeuppance as our protagonist is led away in handcuffs. Guest emcee Saigon adds colour to Black Thought’s outlines, and the track’s a smooth-of-beat, atmosphere-rich offering that presents the facts as they are: if you fuck up, you will get fucked up. Best not to put yourself in a compromising position in the first place.

I Will Not Apologize’, placed in the middle of its parent LP, seems to lay the law down on perceptions of the album: “Some won’t get it, and for that I won’t apologise”. Here, the record’s pace is deliberately slowed, lyrics dripped rather than sprayed; emcees trickle out their words as the beat ticks with a delay. It’s a break that can’t last, as ‘I Can’t Help It’ drops the listener back into Rising Down’s mixer once again, twisting vocabulary to fit vicious beats seeping dread. The Common-featuring ‘The Show’ buzzes like a wasp in the ear, venomous and about ready to snap through frustration, and by the time that shoehorned-in Stump number makes itself heard, it’s as if a completely different band has hijacked this album. Really, it couldn’t have just been dropped?

It matters little – ‘Birthday Girl’ can’t affect the coherence, the assault, of this album from where it sits. Rising Down is an attention-holding, cacophonous of intent record that realises its blueprints spectacularly well. The few duds in the pack barely register, certainly not in a negative way, ensuring that aforementioned LP highlights continue to bore into the listener after the record’s put to bed. It gets nudged out by the next release but soon springs back, every bit as potent of message, of something must change voice, as it was the first time through.

It might not be their best-ever album – Phrenology can still claim that title – but Rising Down finds The Roots reinvigorated, more passionate than ever. If relative veterans can continue to deliver the goods in such spectacular fashion, then rap music’s clearly in very good health.

  • The Roots 8 / 10
Words: Ed Graves

Wayhey!

I love The Roots. Need to get this


The doubt

the Roots are capable of making a bad album.

This is good, just not as good as Game Theory, which is one of the best hip-hop albums of the 2000s


"It might not be their best-ever album – Phrenology can still claim that title"

Hells no. I point you sir to Game Theory > Things Fall Apart > Illadelph Halflife, THEN Phrenology.

I love The Roots but they're hella frustrating live, they seem to get bored with playing their own tunes very quickly.


Illadelph Halflife

Was the first of theirs I got.
C'est superb.


£3 in Fopp

if anyone wants to buy it


I havent listented to the Roots

since Phrenology. I might have to check this and Game Theory out...


Things Fall Apart

Will always be their best record. Hugely underrated.


Great album

The Roots are always enjoyable to listen to.


Phrenology is not even slightly close to being their best album.

I still need to purchase this though. Glad to see another decent review for it.


Yep, Things Fall Apart was incredible

This album is quite good too.


Why is this so review so massively late?

Just out of interest.

And I think Things Fall Apart is their finest moment. They will probably never better Act Too Love Of My Life.

Things do (ironically and hilariously boom boom) fall apart on Phrenology with Water -- the song which highlights the best (Part 1) and the worst (part 2) of The Roots. Nobody wants to hear the sound of drainage. We can all hear that just after we've had a bath. That moment on the album is pivotal and sums up The Roots dilemma. Sometimes they strive so hard to be serious that they become unlistenable, like their frustratingly Jekyll and Hyde live act.

That said, I've not heard Rising Down yet, and am looking forward to it.


Massively late?

It's only a few weeks - since DiS doesn't have a fully paid-up team of contributors who hit deadlines because they're paid to do so, sometimes reviews run a little late. Point is: this is good, deserves a review, here is a review, a positive review. People's happy.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Yndi Halda: acerbic introspection, home and abroad