Drowned in Sound

Search



What's the saddest book you've ever read?

66 votes
?
by RockNRollMassacre

?

RockNRollMassacre | 15 Jul '08, 23:24 | Send note | Report this | Reply

Of mice and men

the ending.


It has

a happy ending, the murderer dies.


very good

very good


of all things;

sleepers &
dogger


The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea

or Temple of the Golden Pavillion both by Yukio Mishima.


havent read those

but i was gonna say spring snow by mishima. SPOILERSSPOILERSSPOILERS......

guy falls in love, doesnt get the girl. does get the girl, catches pneumonia, dies.


I read your spoiler...

(though I haven't read that one). It sounds par for the course for Mishima. I love his stuff.


Buzz Aldrin

which is my favourite book ever <3 and i need to read it again.


i remember Sons and Lovers being pretty grim

Resurrection was a bit miserable too, though i'm not sure why

in defiance of established norms, I didn't find Anna Karenina miserable


The Amber Spyglass

The bit when they're in the land of the dead. Boo hoo.


The Amber Spyglass isn't even as sad as The Subtle Knife

The bit where Lee Scoresby dies... :'(


That bit is horrible, yes

Truly moving.

But come on, what's the worst thing that could happen to Lyra and Pan throughout the whole story? IT HAPPENS AND IT KILLED ME


oo but the bit where will and john AND THAT BLOODY WITCH

(juta kaimanen? off the top of my head)

So so heart-wrenching :(


if they fuck that bit up

Where Hester dies. If they fuck that up in the film (if it ever gets made) I will not be a happy bunny.


I pray the do not make anymore films

I could only watch half of the first one. It was the equivalent of a race to get to the end of the book as quickly as possible :(


It slowly redeems itself

But that maybe me watching it over and over again trying to convince myself. And then watching the director's commentary and the making of dvd, hoping, wishing it wasn't such a crock of shit.


The Amber Spyglass

is still the only book that can jerk tears from these jaded eyes...


Only if you promise never

to leave me because we have to close the portals back to our own universes forever...


Don't

You'll have me going in a minute. Sniff!


the tiger that who came to tea

I actually find genuinely sad. There is something about the colours and style of the illustrations that is crushingly nostalgic and full of lost innocence. It's like a chalk picture melting away on a rainy day or something.

Indeed, the whole book is rain washed and like afternoons before the internet when you just stayed in to be sad.


yep

and the Tiger never came back


I found out a few years ago

that my mum never read me the last page. I lived in hope that he'd come back! :(


ooh yes! indeed!

Story time...

I was reading The Subtle Knife on a bus journey home, last couple of chapters. As I read the final line, thought about it for a little while and looked up, this old lady put a hand on my arm and said "You look like you've never wanted anything more than to get home and read the next one". I agreed and said yep, thats pretty much it, and she said her grandson was reading them too and we both had the same expression when we finished it. Just a look of sheer "wow... right NEED MORE". i love that old lady.


Hahaha

I love those books. I think its because the heartbreak at the end is the sort of heartbreak I can really get on board with: heartbreak that involves parallel universes.


My old head of year

(with a doctorate in eng lit, I think) couldn't recognise the literary merit of that trilogy beyond "teenage" level.

Dead. Soul.

I think I weeped many times whilst reading them. I fancied lyra to bits and was so jealous of their romance, to an actual degree of "ruins you for life" kind of jaded jealousy.


^ this like so much

I joke not when i say i think it's one of the greatest literary works of the 21st century


no it's not

it is written with the same imaginative scope, but rather than being purely escapist it is also an intelligent discussion of many of the key themes of our time like science and religion, is stunning in its philosophical depth, its rich network of allusions, is a compelling coming of age novel, is full of human empathy that goes far beyond being an exciting fantasy novel and is utterly beautifully crafted.


Plus, yes_ is right

it does do that War & Peace thing where you fall totally in love with the main female character.


Oh aye

that too, obviously. But i meant in its hugeness and impact simply as a story that will be loved for loads of generations to come.


this. totally.

absolutely.


I'm a total HDM nerd

I have a bit of a collection going on, and spent a year working with a games company helping design a collectable card game (like pokemon / yugioh / lotr / magic) based on the novels, but it got canned.


Hahah

Yeah, i couldn't wait to start the last one too, which i did right away. I remember i told my brother about this (it was him that told me to read them) and he said "how do you think i felt? I had to wait 3 years for the next one!". I couldn't have waited argh.


Haha that's sweet

And exactly what I felt like, reading the books for the first time.

Does anyone else find Pullman's other books really, really dull?


The Butterfly tattoo

is a stunning Pullman book. Very short and very very sad too.


me:

The Heart Is A Lonely Hunter by Carson McCullers or Tender Is The Night by F. Scott Fitzgerald.

I was also massively emotional when I finished War & Peace


I agree with

'The Heart Is A Lonley Hunter' very little makes me cry but that made me sob.

Also Her Benny: A Tale of Victorian Liverpool by Silas K. Hocking


I agree with Tender is the Night

Even more poignant considering the parallels with his own life. Really want to read The Crack Up now.


Hmmm - I am re reading The BEautiful and Damned and am yet to read

Tender Is The Night which I know is supposed to be wunderbar... Not sure I'm up for a tear jerker just yet, tho.


It's not so much of a tear jerker

just a hopeless set of circumstances, which you know can't be rectified by the end of the book. Let me know what the Beautiful and Damned is like, it's on my list of things to read.


I know this sounds trite

but American Scream by Cynthia True.


that book is really sad.

There's a bit where Hicks is talking about how he's worked so long and hard to get recognition in America (he's about to get a TV show with Noam Chomsky) and then he gets diagnosed with pancriactic cancer which is rare in a man of his age.

Alot of people on here don't seem to like him to much but he was a genuinley funny man and the world could do with him now.


Harry Potter


The Depford Mice,

When Piccadilly gets totally pwned by jupiter. :'(


Is that with the falling icicles?

"Thomas" is similarly tragic :(


this book about The Hillsborough Disaster

it was told completely through eyewitnesses. very sad.


"Bit of a squeeze in here, la?"

"I blame the fockin' bizzies."

THE END, LA


Gulag Archipelago

Which isn't so much sad as horrifying but, since books rarely if ever leave me truly sad, will have to suffice.


A Prayer For Owen Meany.

I wept like a baby at the end :'(


Thats just what I was going to say Bundoz.

A fucking incredible book, powerful and moving.
I was very upset at the end as well.


I was going to post this

i was crying on the train reading the end. Such an amazing book.


Also

when Dave Eggers' parents die in A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius. :(


The Time-Travellers Wife

I've never cried at a book apart from that, and I totally wept at the end.


the last paragraph

ripped my heart clean out of my chest.

christ, am all goose-bumpy just thinking about it.


I sobbed like a little boy

when I read that.

I bought it for my g/f recently, she'd been put of reading it because she'd heard it was really sad and she said she cried loads at the end as well.


oh yeah

this also made me cry loads


Sleepers

Sleepers is really fucking sad.

And The Amber Spyglass, which made me cry like a big girl.


House Of Dolls

By Ka-tzetnik. Just incredibly fucking grim


The Complete Short Fiction of Oscar Wilde

damn you Happy Prince! Damn you Selfish Giant!


Good question.

I was completely addicted to Crow Road by Ian Bainks.


Don't Go Where I Can't Follow

:''''''''''''''(

Guy compiled a story of how he met his fiance, their plans of marriage and children, shares anecdotes (amusing ones), provides copies of letters and postcards they sent one another, then details how she got diagnosed with cancer and describes the treatment process and her eventual death. I cried like a baby.


The Boy In the Striped Pyjamas

by John someone. Such a terribly sad ending.


This.

I challenge anyone to read it and not cry at the ending.

http://www.amazon.com/Blue-Black-Five-Star-Paperback/dp/1852427604/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1216200720&sr=1-1


Has anyone ever read anything from the "Tragic Lives" bookshelf in Waterstones?

Hundreds of awful looking books about traumatic childhoods, alcoholism, abuse etc...don't really understand why people read them. I'm sure there must be some kind of "but with the power of X, I got through Y" inspirational last chapter, but they seem so predictable and miserable.


Nana Upstairs and Nana Downstairs... when i was about 5 years old

"every Sunday four-year-old Tommy's family goes to visit his grandparents. His grandmother is always busy downstairs, but his great-grandmother is always to be found in bed upstairs, because she is 94 years old. Tommy loves both of his nanas and the time he spends with them. He is desolate when his upstairs nana dies, but his mother comforts him by explaining that "'she will come back in your memory whenever you think about her'."


The Impossible Lightness Of Being

made me feel very sad.


*Unbearable

Why did it make you sad?


Unbearable, yes

I keep saying Impossible for some reason. Just the relationship between Tomas & Tereza, I found it really upsetting. And the ending. I thought it was a great book, and I've really enjoyed the other Kundera books that I've read, but this one upset me for some reason. The rejection and miscommunication.


oh YES, that too !!

it broke my tiny heart


probably

stuart: a life backwards.

'head full of blue' was quite sad, but redemptive by the end.


'The End of the Affair' by Graham Greene

'The Heart is a Lonely Hunter' is pretty bleak, as has been mentioned.


'Timoleon Vieta come home'

By Dan Rhodes.
I had a lump in my throat by the end of it.


The Animals of Farthing Wood

Or maybe the sequel where Fox's son dies


spoiler!!


the time travellers wife

i never wanted it to end tho i think i cried all the way through. i am pathetic i know.


south of the border west of the sun

it makes my spine ache


the time traveller's wife

i cried on the train because of this book!


Flowers For Algernon

So sad, so moving. And it has a super intelligent mouse.


I read this recently, and really enjoyed it.

Did you know they made it into a musical, with Michael Crawford,