What purpose do these records actually serve? Big name acts on big name labels with big-selling hits off big-selling albums that anyone with a fleeting interest will probably have anyway. And in several different formats and 22 different mixes. Are they put out to promote the artist? The song? What about the genre, or even the label?
Truth is, the motivation behind major label compilations is very different to that of the Indies. In the world of underground; Independent fanzines, labels & promoters, where a passion and love for new emerging talent is still intact and the romantic vision of slaving away for 26 hours a day, promoting your acts and spending every last penny of your wages on a bunch of kids knocking out a few good tunes is still an enticing proposition there is one thing that, for some, can become a healthy obsession. Compilations.
Whether on wax, CD or tape, on glossy sleeves or photocopied cut’n’paste efforts compilations are an ideal way to expose the bands they manage, promote or represent in some way or other. And while I don't necessarily want to burn all big-selling comps (ok, just 99% of them) I personally, view the above as the real reasons for putting out compilations and are therefore essential in discovering new music and in a band’s success. The whole point of this article is to give a pedestal to these independent compilations that small labels work so hard to put together and we at Drowned In Sound get so many of. This is the first installment of a special feature dedicated to them, with ten compilations featured each time. I may decide to include free samplers now and again that you should really hunt out but most are available for dirt cheap in the shops. They're cheap. Here’s a guide. You have no excuse.
NO IDEA ~ Redifiling Music
[No Idea]
No Idea is a label that sprouted from No Idea fanzine way back in 1985 and to celebrate the 15+ years or so they’ve been operating they released this compilation with 16 of their acts covering music by, well, pretty much anyone from Morrissey (Radon) to Lemonheads (Clairmel) to Gorilla Biscuits (Palatka). These kind of compilations are always a bit hit & miss in my eyes, especially with unknown bands who don’t really give you much of an idea what they sound like normally.
More well-known acts like Small Brown Bike, Hot Water Music and 12 Hour Turn all try their hand at Thin Lizzy, Bruce Springsteen and Asshole Parade classics, but it’s ultimately Asshole Parade’s spazzed out cover of Circle Jerk’s ‘Red Tape’ that really get my juices flowing. Not so much a bad comp, just a pretty poor one.
[2/5] No Idea Records, PO Box 14636, Gainsville, FL 32604-4636 / www.noidearecords.com
BOSS SAMPLERAGE! Vol. 2
[Boss Tuneage]
As you can probably tell, this is the second Boss Tuneage comp and showcases a whopping 29 bands from their roster. Presented in a simple black and white cardboard sleeve it’s safe to say they really do scour the world for their bands, licensing acts from Japan’s Snuffy Smile and Canada’s Mag Wheel, amongst others. It’s a patchy comp but there is some good catchy punk rock gubbins to be found. The only problem is the impression I consistently get from Boss which is unless you happen to stumble across one of their bands early on at a gig or a punk all-dayer their record is the only place you’ll hear them.
Which is a shame because class bands like High Lo Fi, The Unknown and Woolworthy sound like they’d be an absolute blast in a live setting! Apart from them, though, there’s nothing here to really set your heart on fire.
[2/5]
Boss Tuneage, PO Box 19550, London SW11 1FG.
SAMPLER No.1
[Running Riot]
Reminding me of the first fanzine I wrote for (Sullen Riot), this is not only the first compilation from Running Riot but the first release too. However, as with many first release compilations, it seems like as many demos have been collected as possible and the most half-decent tracks stuck on here. It also seems like the guys behind RR are promoters in Dartford so I guess that explains a lot.
But, all that aside this is possibly a better, more varied comp than Boss Samplerage, flitting past ska-punk (My Dad Is Big), grizzled pop-punk (Stuntface) and really bad OMS impersonators (Potvin), even venturing into uncharted territory with Nushere, who really should experiment with Cubase a bit more.
Although there is potential (note the emphasis on 'potential'!)lurking in here somewhere, there really is no point in the inclusion of whiny bedroom rock in bands like The Spanked Monkeys.
[2/5]
Write to: Running Riot, 15 Denver Road, Dartford, DA1 3LA / www.runningriotrecords.co.uk / thisisthecollective@yahoo.co.uk.
PUNK-O-RAMA 7
[Epitaph]
Ah yes, it’s that time of year again. Well, it very quickly was. Another summer, another Punk-O-Rama comp from Epitaph showcasing it’s latest high hopes. I know Sean has already reviewed this but, well, this is my take, OK? The punk rock climate has changed remarkably since the first POR instalment (featuring pre-fame Offspring, Rancid & NOFX) and POR 7 illustrates this punk attenuation well through the punk n roll of The (International) Noise Conspiracy (still waiting to find a really impressive song from these Swedes), the rabid Randy and the soon-to-be-huge Division of Laura Lee.
Together with an unreleased punk-metal offering from Warped Tour buzz band Death by Stereo and the Irish-punk sing-a-long offerings from Dropkick Murphys and Flogging Molly (there really isn’t a more irritating band around right now) punk rock has never been more varied. Stand out tracks here come from Death By Stereo, 1208, D.O.L.L. and, unsurprisingly, Pennywise. For a few quid you could do a lot worse.
[3/5]
PLEA FOR PEACE - Take Action
[Sub City]
Ok, so this is a little old now but it's the first decent comp of the pile and one I cannot recommend more strongly!! For a start, it’s released on Sub City which was created 2 years ago by Hopeless Records to raise funding and awareness for non-profit organisations, this release benefiting the American National Hopeline Network (1-800-SUICIDE).
If that wasn’t a big enough reason to buy this then maybe the 26 unreleased, rare or live tracks might swing you round. And there really is something for everyone from Cave-In’s remix of ‘Jupiter’ to the spazz-hardcore attack of Shai Hallud & Dillinger Escape Plan (live version of ‘Mullet Burden’ here) to the riot grrl of Bratmobile & SelbyTigers and even some chilled out Telepopmusik-inspired beats from Zero Zero before the emotion-draining screams of Thursday. Compilations like this don’t come around often and anyone involved in the alternative punk/hardcore scene should really try and hunt this out!
Other bands included: At The Drive In, AFI, Atom & His Package (rare track here – and it’s a gudden!), Boy Sets Fire, Grade, The Ataris, T(I)NC, Strike Anywhere and more.
[5/5]
www.subcity.net
HOW WE ROCK
[Burning Heart]
The artwork & packaging on this should be enough to persuade you to part
with your cash for this alone- very classy! As for the music, well,
check back on that title, because herein contains tracks from 18 of the
most rockin’ and rollin’ bands since Twisted Sister (yep, this is that good!). Despite the newly-reformed Turbonegro opening with a very Oasis-sounding intro, they soon get into the swing of things ready for the rip-roaring, tearaway blitz of Zeke storming through ‘Live Wire’. Other such acts are present such as New Bomb Turks, Supersuckers, Puffball, The Hellacopters, Gluecifer and Electric Frankenstein goddamit! In fact, for any newcomers to this balls-out, gasoline-soaked, fag-hangin-from-lip-style of rock (*looks over at young Hives & T(I)NC fans*) then this comp will be right up your street, giving you a valuable education on the scene’s current talent, although why The Donnas are on here is anyone’s guess.
[4.5/5]
DANCE LIKE YOUR DAD
Dislocate Promotions
Bit of a short one this with only three bands strutting their stuff. Originally released to coincide with Dislocate’s Death Skateboards-sponsored tour, this CD features 2 tracks each from three of the bands on the tour, namely My Dad Joe, Fireapple Red & Captain Everything!
Representing the cream of the London pop-punk scene this CD is a corker. My Dad Joe have a real urgent Travis Cut-cum-Fat Wreck vibe to them with some top-class melodies to boot. Fireapple Red have a much more aggressive approach, although still possessing some nice and shiny hooks to tempt you on the dance floor when played live.
Captain Everything! also have a real edge to them and proved live how unpredictable they are. Their two tracks here are, although short, smart examples of a band that are a shining light in the UK punk scene.
[5/5] www.dislocatepromotions.co.uk.
AMPED UP…
[In At The Deep End]
Mark UKbase (also the guy behind IATDE) sums up the aim of this and all DIY compilations well in the inside sleeve of this first release comp from In At The Deep End Records by saying that there are so many good bands in the UK right now, playing in local venues just down the street which many people for one reason or another will never ever get to hear. However with this comp featuring 30 varied bands covering the whole of the UK scene it gives fans of punk, emo, hardcore or metal a chance to hear stuff by bands they may have heard of but not heard anything by.
For those of you who’re into those scenes this compiles pretty much most of the bands who’re making a name for themselves around the UK from the emo-screams of Leeds’ And None of Them Knew They Were Robots to the youthful thrashy punk of Fig 4.0 to Scotland’s Shatterhand and East Anglia’s Horace Goes Skiing.
There’re obviously a couple of truly appalling bands hiding away but on the whole this is a good comp and indispensable for anyone wanting to get an earful of what the current underground crop sound like.
[4/5] www.inatthedeependrecords.co.uk
COP OFF
[Copro]
From the label that brought us the likes of Medulla Nocte and Earthtone 9 comes a 2 disc comp with disc 1 featuring tracks from it’s current stable and disc 2 showing off the acts from it’s Casket Music offshoot. Although much of Copro’s acts are largely unlistenable, they do throw up some treats now and again such as the savage death metal of Withering Surface and the passionate emo-rock of Forever Until October, whose contribution is an exclusive unreleased track. Although some of these tracks are fairly old, such as Acid Death’s, Medulla Nocte’s ‘Inside I’m Dying’ and earthone 9’s ‘Tat Twam Asi’ video it does give you an idea of what Copro have been up to over the years.
Change the disc and you get 13 tracks from Casket’s wondrous bands. Now, where the quality of Copro’s acts are patchy Casket’s are just plain terrible. I mean, all those cringeworthy local nu-metal bands that infest the toilet venues around the country – it’s the kind of stuff Casket have wet dreams about. From Landmine Spring & Fony to Cowpuncher, Imprint and Caution the fact they’re allowed to put out records is just wrong. WRONG I tell you!
The only ounce of solace comes in the form of Marshan’s stoner blues and you need their mini-album purely for the hidden prank phone call at the end.
[2/5]
PUNK ROCK IS YOUR FRIEND
[Kung Fu]
Ok, there’s eight bands here, each with two tracks with which to woo your little punk rock ears. First band Audio Karate are definitely a band you should try and search out. Taking on the teen-punk template they’re a band with some mighty fine hooks (karate) kicking about. Ozma are a band for all you with a soft spot for power-pop rock ala Weezer. Showering quirky keyboard effects over an infectious pop-rock bounce Ozma have a songwriting knack most bands can only dream of.
Tsunami Bomb’s female vocalist sounds like Karina from Dance Hall Crashers and subsequently they sound like a punk rock version of them. It’s not a bad thing. In fact these little tasters just aren’t enough. I want MORE!! Ahem. Ok, other bands that appear here are The Vandals with an unreleased track and ‘My First Christmas’ from the ‘Oi To The World’ single, Antifreeze’s generi-punk, No Use For A Name, The Ataris, Useless I.D. & Mi6.
An alright comp but worth getting to hear Audio Karate, Ozma and Tsunami Bomb!
[3/5]
www.kungfurecords.com
Compilations Compiled
me (the piss-easy guess is yours!)
Re: Compilations Compiled
look at the flipside, dickhead
Re: Compilations Compiled
2. SHOCK HORROR! there might be something on there you MIGHT like.
3. commercial snob.
Re: Compilations Compiled
some people *do* have budgets. if that makes them commercial snobs fair enough. we don't wanna sell out to The Man and spend more money than we have now do we.
you're still a dickhead.
Re: Compilations Compiled
johnny quest thinks your cool!
cus if you charge you've sold out, you've entered the capitalist system and worst of all, you've put a price on art/music/culture/revolution/rebellion/etc.
and to produce it is all free (like all the best things in life). At musics barest core its just people in bedrooms and garages playing with sound waves. And you can't, honestly, put a price on that. You can't honestly tell me selling something cheap, places any kind of value, respect and correlateable-meaning on it? can you?
you can't honestly tell me that putting say, a few bands people know on something, to get them interested, and then into new bands, is more important than releasing something that no-one wants but doesn't sell out to, like, bands with fans, who people, who mostly love music, have invested a lot of money in (which is all a lot of bands are, with their big debts, and songs people wanna listen to)
why does everyone want to be the victim? why blame the friggin system? set fucken fire to the system if you don't like it. burn everything. fight! fight! fight! but for the love of sanity, stop fucken moaning and being all elistist-schmuck on our ass cus you waste your money putting out records that interest 50 people who've sold out enough to have enough income to buy your records, risk free of it being a waste of their money. selling out is the last thing to fear when great music, which WILL change peoples lives, is going unheard and amazing people are starving or worse, working a McJob.
You. Just. Don't. Get. IT! Or, do you?
Music is not free
I know this wasn't quite what you were getting at Sean, but it's just an ongoing irk of mine.
Re: Music is not free
Re: johnny quest thinks your cool!
Re: johnny quest thinks your cool!
Why is money so important in this debate anyway?
Isnt it more important that more people hear more good music? And do that, you need to compromise a little.
it's not about money.... honest
you complain about elitism, and say that music should be free. i can only see this being a highly elitist comment: people LIKE music in their hand, not on their computer-- that's why there's still a music industry. giving it away free relies on the generosity of the people paying for the recording, mastering, production pressing and so on of the music. if it's free, surely only those who can afford to lose stupendous sums of money will be able to produce music. now THAT's elitist.
i run a record label cos i love music, but i have to appreciate the harsh reality that i have to make a profit somewhere. i'm not out to get rich, so i keep my retail prices fair. but out of a cd single, there's 1.10 to play with after the retailer and distro take their share. a cd that actually plays rather than a 22p cdr costs 35p (and you'd never get cdr in the shops anyway...), the covers (and you have to admit we all like nice coloured covers!) cost more, plus all the free copies to press, plus post, plus the cost of recording (and every band in the universe will tell you that a bad job is not cheap, let alone a good one. ooh, that leaves eleven pence to pay the bills, feed myself etc.
this may all sound very very anal, but i know that a lot of people are cross about the naiveté of your argument, sean. generosity is one thing. usury is another. i know you were talking about compilations but the principle is the same. whilst i can understand the point that free use of old tracks is ok, you still have to deal with the other costs involved.
when's your free 20 track cd compo coming out? hope it has a nice cover ;oP
it's about inspiring people
There will be a paid-for-version which'll have a lot of good extra value stuff. And believe it or not we'll have both big bands who've had top20 singles (which they've only sold cus they're good) and small bands who don't even get 10 people at their gigs (cus they're new and lacking in media support). But nah, i'm a sellout, no-one would ever wanna buy it. Compilations with bands no-ones heard or cares about, that's the future, it's got so many morals and good ethical standpoints.
"ooh, that leaves eleven pence to pay the bills, feed myself etc."...don't you have another job that pays? Why do you need to justify getting the money back when you release something you love?
But you've got me all wrong. I would never, EVER, claim that music SHOULD be free, i was just argueing against that dumbfounded diy/punk point. That's what debate is all about. Selling records, in theory, is selling out, it's entering the capitalist system (one which works on the exchange of economics).
Maybe the key to all of this is that we go back to bartering trade and you have to be a really good band/label to acquire really good records and food and shelter. Then it all comes down to the merit and creativity. It'll never work..
sean
Re: it's about inspiring people
elitist, toi? oui oui. what you're effectively doing is reducing the value of the paid for version by giving most of it away free.
"Why do you need to justify getting the money back when you release something you love?"
if i don't get the money back, i starve. i'm not a rich kid with parents to back me up. the record label takes up the vast majority of my time (and threshers the other 20 hours-- pays the rent), since promotion, legal stuff etc. all takes time.
"But you've got me all wrong. I would never, EVER, claim that music SHOULD be free, i was just argueing against that dumbfounded diy/punk point. That's what debate is all about. " you just did, bout 5 messages ago.
"Selling records, in theory, is selling out, it's entering the capitalist system (one which works on the exchange of economics). " couldn't agree more. i have NEVER claimed (unlike someone involved with warner we all know and love...) to not have sold out. i'm PROUD of the fact i've sold out. but just cos i have doesn't mean i have no morals...
anyway, i'm off before this degenerates any further!
R.
excuse me
I think I was banding about the phrase "sell out or sell nothing" about 5 years ago in my fanzine. I've never claimed to be ethically punk - ethical punks live in squats and smell of cheap cider.
Re: excuse me
punks are not ethical people, they're people who believe in little but themselves and chaos and the art of chaos being socially, culturally and morally constructive.
or so i heard.
straight edge punks
teenagers looking for an excuse to start fights in pubs are straight edge. they tip over your pint for the same reason right wing christians tell you you're going to hell - it makes them feel superior.
or so i heard...
Re: straight edge punks
cos they're clumsy? ;oP
....
"£$^%*&)(%£((*%%$((*%
""
Re: ....
i just think too many people running DiY labels don't understand the idea of compromise. They love music, yes, true, it's a given. But they also want people to hear new music. And like you say, people don't care til a band are signed... and therein lies the problem. A diy label can and have many a time done it. You just get your small bands in with the bigger bands, beit tour supports (which don't always cost money) or by getting your music heard and if it's good, people will like it and wanna buy it. It's not unknown for a video that cost buggerall getting on m2 or songs played on peel, etc.
My problem isn't the money at all. It's the mind state. The elitistness of diy people who always wanna justify getting their money back on sales - sell your frigging self out and earn more if that's the problem or don't release records at all.
I know it takes a lot of time to put out a record and time is money. But that shouldnt matter for one second if you love something enough. But the same goes for the band, who are what you're selling and to be a better band, you need to not work 6 days a week.
People CAN and WILL change if enough good bands come from the DiY scene but not a lot have and not a lot of diy labels have the vision to follow it through, they just think its only major labels who can sell records.
Proove me/yourself/everyone wrong!
sean
PS. Not everything i say i mean, this is debate, you have to be rhetorical.
Re: ....
the end
misunderstood.
Re: Compilations Compiled
1. No-one at Drowned in Sound gets paid.
2. If we went out and bought every little diy compilation (cus sending out promo's is so un-DIY!) we'd end up spending a small fortune, then have too much material to wade through to ever find anything good (see also: mp3 download sites)
3. I'm sure you knew all this Mr.Moore.
Re: Compilations Compiled
2. some diy people cant afford to send out promos to people who'd just bin them anyway
3. im not mr moore
Re: Compilations Compiled
Re: Compilations Compiled
I doubt most people deal with bands that are published, which is also an issue.
Anyway, it still selling out if you charge for a compilation. Would make more sense to set-up a download site.
Re: Compilations Compiled
Re: Compilations Compiled
Re: Compilations Compiled
The article wasn't meant to focus entirely on small DIY compilations. They're all from independent labels, from the "PROPER SHOESTRING BUDGET DIY" of Running Riot and Dislocate, which were put together with 'photocopeid paper & marker pens', to those with a little more experience, but still on small budgets, like In At The Deep End, Boss & No Idea to the more successful indies like Sub City, Burning Heart and Kung Fu.
It's a column that intends to cover the range of comps that DiS receives and just because some may have a nice cover, that they have invested a little hard-earned money for their label / first release, that they've actually put a lot of time, effort and money in designing the packaging and putting together some incredible new bands on (and having the clever idea of including a few well-known bands so as more people would actually pick it up and therefore get into some new music) you think it's best we didn't review it? What, REALLY??
You really shouldn't jump to conclusions on the basis of this article, and I don't think I, or the site, have to justify ourselves to someone so far up his militant DIY arse to presume that we don't actually buy compilations or fanzines etc... at shows or we generally don't know what being DIY is about.
It reminds me of the latest issue of Fracture? Christ!