With 2005 already a distant memory, it's through tear-dribbled hazy eyes that we ask you to hold our hand and peruse politely through our top 46 albums of the year.
No one else has ever thought of this idea before, so we decided to take the lead and poll our staff to come up with our top fourty-six records of the year.
We've based these all on their UK release dates, so those wishing to make an issue about the Arcade Fire LP or anything else you may claim you had on import are hereby warned. We do of course welcome you to comment, debate and generally moan about our choices, as that's pretty much the point of DiS.
We'd like to extend a rather large thank you to Tom Edwards for painstakingly compiling this list from all of our staff's entries and to Raziq Rauf for sorting it out and listening to Trivium.
-- Colin Roberts, Editor
The List:
1. Arcade Fire Funeral
“One of the most impressive and confident debuts of the year… Encompassing chamber pop melodies, angular art rock, lavish orchestration and post-punk vocals, its sheer sonic size and ambition goes some way to justifying the amount of gushing praise that’s been heaped upon this album.”
2. Bright Eyes I’m Wide Awake It’s Morning
“It’s the closeness and the honesty which makes I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning a thing of awe. The compulsive, calculated attention to detail is in the Braille textured production, but it’s the lyrics where Conor shines through, with every sniff of journo-sensationalism shot down.”
3. Saul Williams Saul Williams
“Whatever I write will fall short; whatever praise I heap will topple before its completion. Saul Williams does this to you, be you critic, consumer, hip-hop head or beat freak.”
4. Bloc Party Silent Alarm
“All the angular pop pickings and fiery live shows in the world couldn’t have prepared us for this record… The singles are by no means the sole highlights from Silent Alarm. From the opener, it’s clear that the bar has been set high.”
5. My Morning Jacket Z
“This album soars effortlessly throughout its entirety, combining the majestic and haunting with the stark and sacherine and never losing its way. In essence this would have been the perfect late-summer record.”
6. Sufjan Stevens Illinois
“It is a record that marches to the drum of an inner devotion, one that represents the earnest and sober side of its creator… Stevens has a beautiful voice and a rare melodic instinct, but it is the passion with which he performs these songs that causes them to communicate so much, so well.”
7. The Decemberists Picaresque
“Picaresque is more than an indie-pop album, it's a collection of eleven lavishly arranged acts rife with the whiff of greasepaint and the roar of an adoring crowd, which you should be a part of.”
8. …And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead Worlds Apart
“The album's practically bursting at the seams with additional instruments which expand on Trail Of Dead's punk assault.”
9. Million Dead Harmony No Harmony
“To say they’ll be missed is an understatement (and a whopping cliché), but fuck: they will, and are already.”
10. Art Brut Bang Bang Rock ‘n’ Roll
“On one side there’s those saluting their scattergun tunes expressing pent-up modern suburbia and adolescent frustration, and on the other there’s those who think that they don’t mean it, that this is all some sort of joke… I’m not so much laughing as dancing like a monkey on fire.”
11. The Rakes Capture/Release
“As a record, it’s near faultless and the best album the London-based quartet could have possibly made. As a state of the nation diatribe, it’s spot on and bleakly wonderful.”
12. Patrick Wolf Wind In The Wires
“While he’s not enchanting maidens, Patrick’s in his lab putting digi-edges to dusty melodies, bringing a new and gentle surreallity from the typical troubadour record.”
13. Wives Erect The Youth Problem
“It's as addictive as the dirtiest of pop records being listened to in an entirely inebriated state. It's as brilliantly complete as a punk-rock record can be without spontaneously combusting within your CD player.”
14. The Chalets Check In
“It'll undoubtedly annoy as much as it does entrance, such is the violently bipolar nature of today's indie community, but to these ears Check In is as strong a pop record as 2005 will muster.”
15. The Cribs The New Fellas
“Short, sharp and definitely leaving you wanting more, The New Fellas could easily be the best "scene" album of the year. That is, unless the band start hating themselves for it.”
16. Sleater-Kinney The Woods
“Skull-crushingly heavy, but not without a heart, The Woods is definitely Sleater-Kinney’s finest (and loudest) hour to date.”
17. Lightning Bolt Hypermagic Mountain
“Zero subtlety, zero bullshit: Lightning Bolt have delivered what you knew they would, a record that both ups the ante and liquidises it, spreading its gooey goodness all over their sweaty faces.”
18. Death From Above 1979 You're A Woman, I'm A Machine
“Really, you won’t hear a more exhilarating, dizzying record for a long time to come. It’s so simple – just two dudes making a right ol’ racket – but it’s done with such spirit and delivered with such a purity that any disparaging criticism is simply blown away.”
19. Serena Maneesh Serena Maneesh
“With their self-titled debut album, Serena Maneesh draw from the greatest protagonists of both rock and post-rock to construct something that, while derivative, is also undoubtedly theirs.”
20. Annie Anniemal
“It seems that the majority of British record buyers will miss the boat on Annie’s brilliant, intoxicating debut album. That’s a real shame, because not since the heydays of Blondie has there been an album of pure pop music so sexy, sassy and shamelessly breezy as Anniemal.”
21. Rogue Wave Descended Like Vultures
“There’s plenty of distress, trepidation and steady reflection. It’s full of the minute anxieties of life that keep you awake in the early hours, but set to some of the most life-affirming sounds you’ll have heard for a long time.”
22. Brakes Give Blood
“It’s quite clear from the offset that Brakes are a band who like to shake things up.”
23. Chris T-T 9 Red Songs
“Considering the amount of singer/songwriters we see who are barely audible over nattering crowds, the attention paid by the T-T devotees in even the quietest, more serious moments is testament to the man’s talent.”
24. Bearsuit Team Ping Pong
“By rights, Bearsuit should be the biggest band in the world, not just Norwich.”
25. Stars Set Yourself On Fire
“Their coup is to pair artful understatement with a towering sense of immediacy and timelessness. It's a cohesive record, no one swaggering song treading its companions into insignifance. This could become your favourite record, and Stars should justifiably be many people's favourite band”
26. Stellastarr Harmonies For The Haunted
“New Yorkers, Stellastarr*, always had the potential to be more than that band who had one good song, once”
27. Opeth Ghost Reveries
“Opeth's technical capacity and orchestral dexterity mark them out from both their followers and their peers in one of the great metal albums of the year. This ought to be the epic soundtrack to the bleakest, most mysterious Fantasy Fiction they never made a film of.”
28. Bright Eyes Digital Ash In A Digital Urn
“Oberst should be immensely proud. He has successfully shown that he is capable of lending his talents to a myriad of styles, showcased over this album. He is one of the most naturally talented songwriters of our time”
29. The New Pornographers Twin Cinema
“The fourteen songs on Twin Cinema are packed full of hooks and harmonies, each one refusing to leave your head upon taking residence.”
30. Andrew Bird And The Mysterious Production Of Eggs
“This Chicago singer/songwriter has finally made good on all that promise. A huge jump forward and raising of the bar.”
31. Broken Family Band Welcome Home, Loser
“TBFB's dark new record is a bloody fantastic masterpiece… Welcome Home, Loser is a brooding, more menacing trip than any of their former work.”
32. Mew And The Glass-Handed Kites
“If you are looking for an album that you can put on for a couple minutes to fill time then you'd do better to look elsewhere, but if you want to be transported to an ethereal demi-world stuck between real life and dreams then ensure you purchase this.”
33. Ambulance Ltd Ambulance Ltd
“Brittle guitars hover around the edges, Marcus Congleton sings away in his fragile, whispery, slightly Elliott Smith fashion over carpets of backing vocals and their loose-limbed rhythm section.”
34. Sennen Windows
“Sennen's sound can be bewildering. Luckily it can also be enticing, invigorating and most importantly extremely enjoyable.”
35. M. Ward Transistor Radio
“Transistor Radio is another timeless record where smoke signals meet chimney stacks. This time around it's a static-touched background soundtrack played through the gramophones of eccentrics or the radios in beat up pick-ups.”
36. Editors The Back Room
“This is a record many people will be able to live inside for a very long time, and in all honesty, which bands don't have influences?”
37. Sigur Ros Takk
“If they didn’t make such glorious and saddening music, the desire to slap them really would be quite great... their music launches from the merely beguiling and bittersweet to a swoop of sheer euphoria.”
38. Adam Gnade Run, Hide, Retreat, Surrender
“This record traces a journey of sorts – physical, psychological and incorporating all matters of the heart and soul – across tracks that rarely veer into wild musical abandonment, but forever retain a sense of tension and suspense.”
39. Four Volts Triple Your Workforce
“This record won’t save your life, but the point is that it doesn’t want to. No; pop-punk, post-punk, post-rock, whatever; this entertaining debut shows how it can still sound essential today.”
40. Deerhoof Runners Four
“If I wasn’t so pathetically sensible under these layers of alleged weird, I’d write this entire piece in capitals. It’s perhaps the only obvious way to translate via words on a page the deliriously insane cookie-crumb sweet experimental pop the ‘Hoof conjure.”
41. LCD Soundsystem LCD Soundsystem
“Most pleasingly of all, it’s a disparate yet cohesive collection of songs with nary a second rate ‘House Of Jealous Lovers’ in sight.”
42. 65daysofstatic One Time For All Time
“The band entered the studio to record an EP and left with a nine-track full-length laced with life affirming noise-driven journies that challenges all to dive inside. If you've ever been even slightly intrigued by things you've read, now is the time to take the plunge and listen.”
43. Smoosh She Like Electric
“Those who demand their 16-year-olds are in bed by eight will gawp at the emotional depth of the lyrics, freak out at the injokes and hopefully toss out their Vanessa Carlton CDs for good.”
44. Maximo Park A Certain Trigger
“Every chorus as life-affirming as the last, every verse a singalong delight… A Certain Trigger puts Maximo Park firmly above their more obvious contemporaries and pushes the oft-limited boundaries of their sub-genre by creating a record that just feels natural to them.”
45. Blood On The Wall Awesomer
“Blood On The Wall play kick-ass, hyperactive indie rock music that updates the old Sonic Youth blueprint with a bucket load of snark and fun.”
46. Spoon Gimme Fiction
“Gimme Fiction is a nocturnal, introspective refinement of previous releases that still capitalises on Britt Daniel's classic pop song writing and sonic inventiveness.”
...
Nice to see Million dead in there...
Arcade Fire, really? Better than Anthony & the Johnstons I guess?
high 5
'harmony no harmony' was my album of the year. in my own magazine, which only i am allowed to read and write.
hurray for sleater-kinney too.
Yes yes!
Glad to see Sleater-Kinney and stellastarr* in there... even though stellastarr* is still technically not available over here. Lets hope it tops everyone's "Top of 2006" lists! Both have been definietely two of the most 'listened to' records of my year.
incidentally
Raz's List.
1. Opeth - Ghost Reveries
2. Bullet For My Valentine - Poison
3. Trivium - Ascendancy
4. Chimaira - Chimaira
5. Marmaduke Duke - The Magnificent Duke
6. Dissociatives - Dissociatives
7. Twin Zero - Monolith
8. Kelly Clarkson - Breakaway
9. Bon Jovi - Have A Nice Day
10. 65daysofstatic - One Time For All Time
Woooo....
....Constantines, Lightning Bolt, Saul, Wives... excellent.
yeah but no dfa979. booo!
although it did come out last yr
Yeah...
there is. And it did come out 2005 in England.
Sore...
Sore to see that Bon Jovi's 'Have A Nice Day' couldn't quite climb into the top 50, DESPITE top ten voting from 2 prominent members of the DiS team.
Oh. well.
But seriously, records of the year =
Kind Of Like Spitting - Learn: The Songs Of Phil Ochs
Hockey Night - Keep Guessing
Headphones - S/T
Some Good Stuff
Nice to see Bright Eyes, I'm Wide Awake Its morning, so high up.
Silent Alarm, is right to be in the top10 as well.
I have a few of those
I rate a few of those. BUT The Cribs? Honestly?
...
Yeah, the Cribs is probably the worst album on there.
And my top 10
1. Bright Eyes - I'm wide awake, its morning
2. Patrick Wolf - Wind in the Wires
3. Martha Wainwright - Martha Wainwright
4. Saul Williams
5. My Morning Jacket - Z
6. Sigur Ros - Takk
7. M Ward - Transistor Radio
8. The Cribs
9. The Rakes
10. Broken Social Scene
Millon Dead
Deservedly so.
Saul Williams be awesome toooo
no tom vek
boooo. apart from that little outburst, a good list.
.
Did Bright Eyes really release two albums in one year?
Thats.. ridiculous.
i released
2 guffs today
How about...
Two on the same day o_O
well...
...technically 3 albums in one year, if you count Motion Sickness, the live album.
Right,
I know it's utterly predictable to debate the choices, but for my money Superwolf by Bonnie Prince Billy and Matt Sweeney was fucking great.
Here's my 10
1. Silent Alarm - Bloc Party
2. The New Fellas - The Cribs
3. Discover Mutiny - You Judas
4. Just In Time For Nothing - The Spectacle Experiment
5. Capture Release - The Rakes
6. Chemistry - Girls Aloud
7. Future Perfect - Autolux
8. The Back Room - Editors
9. First Comes First - The Paddingtons
10. Don't Believe The Truth - Oasis
MINE
1) Saul Williams ‘Saul Williams’ (WICHITA)
2) Wives ‘Erect The Youth Problem’ (SWEET NOTHING)
3) Sufjan Stevens ‘Illinois’ (ROUGH TRADE)
4) Adam Gnade ‘Run, Hide, Retreat, Surrender’ (LOUD + CLEAR)
5) 31Knots ‘Talk Like Blood’ (POLYVINYL)
6) Why? ‘Elephant Eyelash’ (ANTICON)
7) Deerhoof ‘The Runners Four (ATP RECORDS)
8) Bullet Union ‘Ruins Domino’ (JEALOUS)
9) Sigur Ròs ‘Takk’ (EMI)
10) Constantines ‘Tournament Of Hearts’ (SUB POP)
Autolux
Glad that Autolux showed up on someone's list.
Oops, pressed wrong button before I'd finished...
But yeah, great choices in the list, fair play to you all. And thank you for not mentioning Antony and his Johnson.
No Elbow?
Everyone always forgets about Elbow :/
Top 2005 for me...
were:
1)Bonnie Prince Billy/Matt Sweeney - Superwolf
2) Wolf Parade - Apologies to the Queen Mary
3) Blood on the Wall - Awesomer
4) Constantines - Tournament of Hearts
5) Josephine Foster - Hazel Eyes, I Will Lead You
my Top ten
1 Architecture in Helsinki - In case we die
2 Malcolm Middleton - Into the woods
3 Saul williams - Saul Williams
4 Caribou - the milk of human kindness
5 Patrick Wolf - Wind in the wires
6 Sigur Ros - Takk
7 Jaga Jazzist - Waht we must
8 Stellastarr - Harmonies for the haunted
9 Dungen - Ta det lungt
10 Common - Be
I forgot to do a list for DiS
But you can see it <a href="http://www.johnrogers.co.uk/BRAINLOVE/2005.html">here</a> if you want.
Oh yeah, no HTML allowed...
Here - http://www.johnrogers.co.uk/BRAINLOVE/2005.html
!
lots of great albums there
Well...
1. Spoon - Gimme Fiction
2. Bright Eyes - Digital Ash
3. The Constantines - Tournament of hearts
Still don't see how Art Brut can fit in the top ten (it made the Pitchfork one too). Top live band with a couple of great tunes, but there's a lot of filler on there.
oops
I forgot arcade fire and the crimea damn damn damn
Why the bloody hell does "wide awake..." constantly get higher than "Digtial Ash..", as the latter is clearly the best thing Conor has ever done.
A plauge on the DiS house.
Pretty good list
(...if admittedly a little indie for my tastes - LCD Soundsystem at 41???? Are you afraid of electronic things?)
And I'm guessing you all have clearly never heard Alligator by The National
Or else that would've won...
Ps.
great list john, enjoyed that a lot. My fanzine did one too, over at this address:
http://www.tohellwith.co.uk/html/display_selection.php?section=1&contentID=1177
much better
Gorillaz, Clor, M.I.A, Mars Volta...
all must haves. But why will no-one else admit they LOVE Kanye West?
the mars volta?ephel duath?
minus the bear? eh? eh?
and gorillaz new album is definatley worthy of inclusion...
Sennen
did anyone else vote for them?
weird one vote would get em that high.
think only one of mine didnt get into the top 46; www.tgcogc.com
Jordan*
.
Yeah I was just thinking that...
Where's Francis the Mute?
And Crimson.
*rolls eyes*
hmmm
The only thing on there I really "don't like" is Bloc Party.
They are fucking shite, fellows.
Good to see blood on the wall in there
But worlds apart?
hmmmm
HMMMMMMMMMMM
Well, it did kinda suck...
It's one of those albums that takes time.
I hated it on first listen, but got more into it on more listens. So there we go.
I don't own any of these?
how much would it cost to buy them all on play?
JAMESH
Just buy Arcade Fire's and the top Bright Eyes one.
Life = complete.
i've downloaded Arcade Fire
i'm a cheap little bastard. much love to you though.
I do like cds though, so i will do as you say.
Million Dead...
It's weird that MD make the list, not because it's a bad album, because it's not, it's a fucking great album, but because you guys have never reviewed it and bypassed it when it was released. Funny you'll give it a top ten spot but with no review or mention on your site till now.
Arcade Fire
Damn right that should be number 1.
here's my top 10...
1. Antony & The Johnsons - I Am A Bird Now
2. Doves - Some Cities
3. Art Of Fighting - Second Storey
4. The National - Alligator
5. Gorillaz - Demon Days
6. Elbow - Leaders Of The Free World
7. Editors - Back Room
8. LCD Soundsystem - LCD Soundsystem
9. Jamie Liddell - Multiply
10. Bloc Party - Silent Alarm
My Top 11
1. Okkervil River – Black Sheep Boy
2. Annie – Anniemal
3. Andrew Bird – The Mysterious Production Of Eggs
4. Elbow – Leaders Of the Free World
5. LCD Soundsystem – LCD Soundsystem
6. Black Mountain – Black Mountain
7. Bright Eyes – I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning
8. Spoon – Gimme Fiction
9. Bloc Party – Silent Alarm
10. Vitalic – OK Cowboy
11. Clor – Clor
I’m American so Arcade Fire was number one last year.
my top 10
is on my DiS blog !
no James Blunt?
I can only assume your writer had a some form of anuerism when he wrote the word "Chalets". I'm pretty sure he meant to write "Elbow" instead. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. This time.
Hey, here's my top 10
I don't care.
Have a nice day.
Animal collective
clearly i must have mis-read the liast as it appears i cannot see 'feels'up there. Oh, ..its not there..wack.
glad to see
arcade fire is in there though id pop mews album a little higher up! and yes...it would certainly be nice to see a bit of minus the bear and mars volta in there!!! tut tut.
The Mars Volta
are total shitsticks. When will you people learn?
Mine are...
1. The Mars Volta - Frances the Mute
2. Arcade Fire - Funeral
3. Super Furry Animals - Love Kraft
4. Art Brut - Bang Bang Rock 'n' Roll
5. The White Stripes - Get Behind me Satan
6. Bloc Party - Silent Alarm
7. Sigur Ros - Takk
8. Gorillaz - Demon Days
9. Dangerdoom - The Mouse and the Mask
10. Part Chimp - I am Come
What about
Boards of Canada??? A great album absent from so many end of year lists.
rate
i jus remembered i forgot Oceansize and Silver Mt Zion on my top 10. arcade fire shouldnt have got that one vote.
Jordan*
kaister chiefs
ha ha ha you gotta laugh at DiS. they created the monster and now that monster has sold nearly 2 million records they disown it...ha ha ha. Love it or loathe it Employment is easily in the Top 46 records of the year. in fact probably on the fringes of the Top 10, its classy pop and that can't be denied just because they're popular. Arcade Fire overrated. but otherwise agreed on a high placing for the Trail of Dead record that was criminally ignored and also good to see Million Dead and M Ward in there
What are you on about?
It's half baked indie schlock held together by a couple of catchy singles. NOT a good look.
gymmy
works for their management company...
but
bloc party are also in the top 10, the arcade fire. are they not 'popular'?
My Top 10
1. Sleater-Kinney - The woods (Sub pop)
2. Fiery Furnaces Ep (Rough Trade)
3. White Stripes - Get Behind Me satan (XL)
4. The Mars Volta - Frances The Mute (Universal)
5. Bright Eyes - I'm Wide Awake It's Morning (Saddle Creek)
6. Architecture In Helsinki - In Case we Die (Moshi Moshi)
7. Boom Bip - Blue Eyed In The Red Room (Lex)
8. 50 Foot Wave - Golden Ocean (4AD)
9. Super furry Animals - Love Kraft (Rough trade)
10. Eels - Blinking Lights And Other Revelations (Dreamworks)
Stellastarr*
Technically isn't the UK release of Harmonies for the Haunted 2006?
Good list. I'd agree with Arcade fire, nice to see Picaresque and Set yourself on fire in there too.
8/10
It's always good to see that Drowned In Sound puts in albums that the majority of the music press overlooks (Ambulance Ltd., Adam Gnade, Mew), but there are three glaring omissions that should be in the top 10, never mind the 'top46'. I speak of Elbow, Anthony & The Johnsons, and Doves - three beautiful (and might I add) British albums that piss all over the likes of The Cribs and Art Brut - I mean, they're both quite fun live, but albums of the year?! Also where are Martha and Rufus Wainwright, Gorillaz, Idlewild (perhaps controversial but what the hell), Ryan Adams (I'd plump for '29') and Richard Hawley?
No BSP?
What about the mighty Open Season, surely one of my faves of the year. And blinking Lights by Eels should be in there as well as Howl by BRMC. What about Broken Social Scene? Or are you classing that as a 2006 release cos it officially released over here later this month?
bsp
open season is crap mate. seriously. and i'm saying that from the perspective that ..the decline of is in my top 20 of all time. lists are cool.
mars volta would be no1 for me this year and elbow and bright eyes would be up there also.
andy's right
open season is gash.
Omissions
Personally, I'd like to have seen ELBOW in there, very high, Metric in there, Richard Hawley in there, and Of Montreal in there. But alas.
My Top 10 for 2005
is as follows:
10: Gorillaz - "Demon Days"
09: Coldplay - "X&Y"
08: Jack Johnson - "In Between Dreams"
07: Maximo Park - "A Certain Trigger"
06: Editors - "The Back Room
05: The Rakes - "Capture/Release"
04: The Arcade Fire - "Funeral"
03: The Cribs - "The New Fellas"
02: The National - "Alligator"
01: Bloc Party - "Silent Alarm"
Saul Williams, Spoon, Sigur Ros, My Morning Jacket, Mew, Stellastarr*, Broken Social Scene all sound interesting, & have been on my list to buy, but my measley wage doesn't stretch too far.
Another mention given to...
....Elbow. "Leaders of the Free World" was an amazing album. Funny how the world droned on and on about how great "Cast of Thousands&qu