Drowned in Sound

Search



Zwan - Mary Star Of The Sea
no votes
?
by Dale Price
Unless you've been hidden away with Iraq's supposed stash of nuclear weapons for the past few years, you'll know everything there is to know about the history and genesis of Zwan.

'Mary, Star Of The Sea' is the product of 2 years of writing, road testing and getting in touch with what it is about music the five protagonists (the aforementioned Poets of Zwan) love so much, and it shows. Gone is the teenage angst of Billy Zero, in its place is the purest joy yet committed to record.

Consider opening lyric "Here comes my faith to carry me on / a faith not ungreat" your call to action. Denounce your false idols of pain and suffering, L.U.V. is the new I Hate Myself And Want To Die.

So anyway, in constructing the 14 tracks on offer, it seems there were two objectives:
1) If it moves, smother it in melody
2) If it doesn't move, squeeze enough soul into it so it does (repeat 1)

Of course, there are always going to be the comparisons to some band named after a big, orange fruit and they're mostly fair, but don't be fooled -- all the good elements have been implanted into a totally different creature. The country swagger of 'Come With Me' would never have sat comfortably alongside 'Bullet With Butterfly Wings' and the occultist love song swirl of 'Ride A Black Swan' or summery stomp of 'El Sol' don't have any of the self-loathing that marked 'Siamese Dream' as one of the staples of '90s angst.

There are duff moments here, naturally... 'Heart Songs' drags on like an Eastenders omnibus, and questionable lyrics such as the references to toast and tea in the otherwise excellent 'El Sol' are a bit limp. Also, name anyone who's pulled off a song with the words "baby" and "rock" in the title... no one? Thought so.

Pumpkins fandom aside, there's plenty to like about the album. It's a summery, positive, spiritually enhancing record, but it still has plenty of guitar-soaked thrust to get you bouncing about in your bedroom. 'Lyric', 'El Sol', first single 'Honestly', 'Endless Summer' and 'Declarations Of Faith' alone will nudge several of your favourite songs of all time out of your affections.

  • Zwan 9 / 10
Words: Dale Price

Zwan - Mary, Star Of The Sea

Dale... as a matter of curiosity... could Billy Corgan do ANYTHING that you WOULDN'T like? :-)

Re: Zwan - Mary, Star Of The Sea

If he tried to fellate me, I'd probably twat his shining dome. :D

Nah, there's loads of Pumpkins tracks I hate... especially Today, can't see what the fuss is about.

Didn't like his work with Hole, weren't fussed about the Stigmata soundtrack, I know the Marianne Faithfull stuff would disappoint me. I'm not totally biased.

Honestly.

Re: Zwan - Mary, Star Of The Sea

Is that because Dale and Me are one of the same? Or is it because you are in love with me dale?

Love
Billie x

p.s. why'd you have to play those songs so loud?

Oh Billie!

I thought you'd never return.

:?

Re: Oh Billie!

did you manage get those stains out?
did your boner eventually subside?
did i cum to you in your sleep that morning?
did you get sweats?
did you?
you did?
oh gud.

Zwan - Mary, Star Of The Sea

I cannot share most reviewers relative adoration of this self-important, bloated, insolent and ultimately disappointing piece of crap. "Honestly" is passable as a throwback to "the summer of '93"-type single and Chamberlian's drumming is still fantastic...However, Corgan's new level of his omnipresent God-complex is disgusting...oh my!!!

"i declare myself
declare myself of faith"

"i gave you everything
what'd you give to me"

"baby, i'm the greatest thing you've got
in a good way i suppose"

Gimmie a break...he's approaching Lou Reed/Little Richard status in the "adore me for what I've done for you" catagory...and he's got a long way to go for that.

Finally, the guitar work on this record is just over the bleeding top...soooo "big" soooo "loud" and ultimately soooo empty.

Just hope he can take it all down a few notches and make us a rock record instead of some huge tome to his "greatness"



Re: Zwan - Mary, Star Of The Sea

You know, it's a given that everything with Billy Corgan's name on is going to suffer with a bit of his abundant egotism, you expect that by now. Still, it's hard coming back from a concept album about a rock star who thinks he's a conduit for the voice of God.

Saw 'em live last night, and the guy is embarassed when more attention is lavished on him than the rest of the band, in fact, he looked pissed off when the usual "BILLY! BILLY!" chants started.

After many more listens, I stick by my review... it's over the top in all the right places, and the joy and love pouring out of the album piss all over the angst of Siamese Dream.

Re: Zwan - Mary, Star Of The Sea

"joy and love" bleh! Sounds exactly the sort of thing I'd hate. Give me the nihilism and self-hatred of Slipknot anyday!




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Grizzly Bear crave downtime; make Friends in the process