It’s so easy to poke fingers and fun toward the young – full of spunk and spirit but content to use their talents to further the cause of spiky emo-pop, rather than invest time studying the much-maligned genre’s roots and the bands that have inadvertently led to this MTV saturation. Nobody can turn on any music television channel today without encountering a floppy-haired and studded belt-wearing kid rocking fashionably noir threads emblazoned with the name of either their best mates’ band or a slightly more obscure outfit. Scene points attained, sales growing, frustration among those that have followed these acts’ forefathers to their ultimate demise at the hands of so many pretenders peaking and boiling the fuck over.
Panic! At The Disco’s back story reads like the stuff of rock and roll fantasy – they struck lucky when a member of another absurdly popular (but considerably more bland) emo-pop band heard them online and immediately reached for his chequebook, bolstered by newly acquired major label dollars. Thus, we have A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out, a debut album so polished that it’s almost impossible to believe that it isn’t the new product of some shady industry svengali, previously responsible for a slew of kiddie-pop boybands. After all, that’s precisely what most of these emo-pop bands are: boybands for the guitar-loving Noughties.
What Panic! At The Disco have done, and cleverly, is steer clear of the carbon-copy format of their peers’ records – each of these tracks sounds remarkably creative within the narrow channels of the stream they’ve chosen to sail down. There are beats lifted straight from The Faint’s glitch-riddled hyperactive synth-punk and hooks the size of the boot of Italy delivered in perfect alignment; scenester-baiting lyrics and critic-bashing put-downs are combined with oddly Eighties echoes and chimes (listen to the ridiculously titled ‘Lying Is The Most Fun A Girl Can Have Without Taking Her Clothes Off’ and try not to think of Depeche Mode). Of course, it’s as perfectly contrived as you could imagine, as wonderfully clichéd as the exclamation mark of their name, but damn, these are good songs. Good emo-pop songs. Great pop songs, period.
Without delving too deeply into vocalist Brendon Urie’s wholly muddled lyrics – 365 days of diary scribblings too wildly haphazard in subject matters to warrant deep study, with occasionally fetching choruses delivered in almost falsetto fashion – Panic! At The Disco’s strengths lie in their frantic compositions, unrelenting in their relative invention, however successful the results. The album’s ‘Intermission’ sounds like the techno outburst from Refused’s The Shape Of Punk To Come for crying out loud: it’s just not what’s expected considering the nature of this regularly annoying, major label-suckling mutant of a genre. If you can overlook the sales pitch, the heavily styled looks and this band’s smiling assistance in the deterioration of a scene (if you like) that was once so worthy of entering without fear of your little Sugababe sister following you, then there’s much enjoyment to be had across these thirteen tracks.
Of course, if you’ve already made your mind up and are utterly ignorant of progress, however painful it may feel, then that’s your prerogative. You’re welcome to it – for once these ears are siding, slightly, with what’s been the enemy for these past five-or-so years.
NO
i disagree
my reasoning is
that you are too reasonable here. you've reasoned with this record so much that you've persuaded yourself to like it.
this review is why people will believe that you said “Oh, and I really like Fall Out Boy! What do you think?� in http://www.drownedinsound.com/content/view/631706
its shit no?
sounds like he's singing the yellow pages.
I think...
the review is fair; the album is ok, the songs are a little over-catchy, but generally not a bad album. The only thing I would say is that it sounds pretty much like fall out boy, but with added bepps and bleeps, so why is this review so much better than the "Sugar..." review?
panic!
wooo!!!! i love these dudes.
zzz
this stuff should be making you angry. you have grown complacent. if you don't have a mortgage, big family car, a dog and 2 children, its time to acquire them.
I like it
but it gets boring quickly, probably because of the complete lack of substance. I thought it was a fair review, but surprising in comparison to your Fall Out Boy review (who you completely slated).
Gah.
These bands are ruining music.
A review of 6?
They don't deserve to be reviewed.
wow.
didnt expect that from mr diver. I still hate them.
this band remind me of really bad drugs
You feel like you're doing something wrong if you like them.
You don't know any better if you like them.
The buzz is kinda fun but incredibly short-lived and the headache afterwards means you'll never touch them again...
I'm
addicted to them. Can't get their songs out of my head.
They're the catchiest band I've heard for two years, so I'll have to give them that.
Sorry Mr. Diver...
...this band are still one of the worst I've ever heard, as much power as your reviews do have top sway my opinion from time to time.
Panic! Avoid the Disco...
They may well be going down a storm with My Space addicted teens, but i'm already sick of this Las Vegas foursome.
They're going to be massive for all of about five minutes...
A Fever You Can't Sweat Out is a 40-minute blast of catchy shrink wrapped emo poppy punkiness. Avoid!
1/5
a very
good review. Naturally you hardly have to read the comments on it, since you can guess what every discerning DiS reader will say about an album of fun pop songs but there we go. Panic! aren't deep or clever but they are fun and if we can't have some fun music once in a while then what'll the world come to?
Hooray.
FUN?
I like fun music... but this album does nothing for me. It's not the worst album i've heard this year, but it's no far off.
"good pop songs"
nah. It's shit.
He DOES sound like he's singing the Yellow Pages...but
I concur with Mike's review. Pretty much spot on for me.
I have had the experience of seeing them live, but because their inexperience of touring shows quite a lot you might as well just pop the CD on instead.
Hmm.
I laughed and laughed when I read in the NME that when their bassist left, and they deleted his name off their MySpace profile, it left fans "distraught with confusion". I can just picture all the scene kids crying as they read their computer screens.
Emo = shit.
...
This album makes me sick. It's an empty, nauseating piece of shit that is trying desperately to be different and the same all at once. It's like emo, but without the emotion.
didnt...
the fat one write all the songs on this album. and thats why they kicked him out? i liked him. what a legend.
umm
he didn't get kicked out, BTW...they're rumors xP And think about it this way: they said themselves...:" I honestly don't think this album is good either, we were waiting to really show our stuff when we got better on our second album." They even wanted to stop their songs fr. going on the radio for a while...they were like, " How can they play our songs if we don't want them to?" So yeah, stop bashing them. And the lyrics ARE deep they're just too clever for u haters.Trust me on that one...
seriously
bands like these are waaaay overrated they are huge when they come out but then the trend moves on to something else....i liked them at first but now they just insult the word 'music' .....they suck.....they are shit....finished.end.over.........
OK album
not very mature song writing but as a young band and a generic pop album, it's OK. I just don't see this album has anything to do with emo. Why do you call it emo. You all appearantly have no idea what emo is.