Drowned in Sound

Search



the machinist

no votes
?
by Shirt_Potato

pretty fucking good innit?

christian bale is super skinny thought. sickeningly. dark, but a good ending

Shirt_Potato | 23 Feb '06, 16:29 | Send note | Report this | Reply

really?

my flatmate told me it was shit.

however, i don't know why i believed her.


if you like memento

i think youd like it.


I thought it looked really good

I shall watch it.


i love memento

but hate the machinist

the only good thing about it is chrisian bale


i thought the ending

was pretty reactionary. y'know you do the crime, you get completely and utterly fucked over until you do the the time type of thing.

the film itself had the potential to be as truly great as memento but it somehow didn't quite do it for me. still, good film. christian bale looks like he might snap in half any minute.


I dunno

I liked the ending, and don't want to say anymore incase it gives it away for someone planning to watch it.....

*spoiler*

The monster from lost is vanessa feltz


hahaha

give it away!

its a great film, visually stunning, if a little harrowing.


yeah don't tell the ending!!

i really liked memento so...


yeah

no point in watching it now really, you might as well go watch thundercats or some other shite 80s throwback


i never finished watching it

because i remember i was a bit depressed when i rented it, and it just made me feel even worse. and it was painful to look at such a skinny christian bale.

so is it worth me renting it again? i liked memento.


I liked it enough to make this thread

but then again, I like 'A'.


On it's own it is a brilliant film

but comparing it to the rather GOD-like Memento is silly. Memento is leagues ahead of this.


I

Have seen The Machinist but not Memento.

Which makes me a bit silly.


yes memento is

better.

but Its the only film I could think of to compare it with....


i don't think it's silly at all

to compare it to memento seeing as both films deal with memory and play around with the concept of a linear narrative.


I didn't really mean it in that sense

i was probably being slightly silly myself.

I meant it in the context of Memento being so much better that the machinist should be uttered under the same breath.


memento is boring...

Pseudo-intelligent movie.
The Machinist is interesting but i agree with accidental on the neding being quite reactionnary.


memento is ANYTHING

but boring.


sorry

it bored me !


something must have got

lost in translation ;-)


i always see movies

in their originl language !
For me, Memento tried to hard to have a different narrative structure but failed to tell an interesting story.
I haven't look to the DVD but the option to see the movie in chronogical order is totally stupid because the story is weak.


Hmm

you are the first person that i have heard say negative things regarding Memento. I think it has a very strong, but purposly confusing storyline.

I have watched Memento 3 times in total. And each time i have got something NEW from it.

I think it is the work of genius. But that is just my opinion.

The Machinist although a brilliant film, is some what predictable. You could see what was coming halfway through. Memento had you guessing all the time.


i'll wait till i'm in a better mood

i have complete series of 'spaced' at home.. how's that? and 'black books'. guess i won't be leaving the flat this weekend.


black books

YES

spaced

YES

buy booze and takeaway and invite me.


great

i'll definitely save some money this weekend.

have you seen that new space comedy (forgot the name) where their spaceship is called camden lock?


yeah

fucking shite isnt it. lots of people from good shows, spaced, peep show. but a big bag of ripe shite it is.


yep

it's dry.


The film freaked me out

I feel like some gang massaman chicken thai curry (sorry - just threw that one in!)


nice

i cook a mean massaman myself


my 2 cents

yeah it's good


i got this along with kung-fu hustle and downfall

in the hmv offer thing. i cant imagine it being as good as memento, as that is rather spectacular. but still i imagine it is worth it, when bought in a 3 for £20 offer

anybody seen downfall?, if so is it any good


yeah

its very good.

I'm good at this


Downfall

Probably the only war film that isn't either pony or massively overrated. Wicked film.... well what do you expect from the same bloke who did Das Experiment? Another overlooked treasure.

By the way, the most underrated and fantastic sitcom of all time is 15 Storeys High. Sean Lock is the bollocks.


The Thin Red Line.

Awesome war film....


liked it when I watched it

haven't thought about it since. Apart from the weight loss aspect.
It was filler. But good filler.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - M.I.A.: "I'm not gonna stay on my couch in Norwood 'til George Bush works out how to beat Bin Laden"