Drowned in Sound

Search



Most Overrated Band OF ALL TIME

no votes
?
by PinkHerring99

i mean by general public like, not by indie "snobs"...

nirvana, pink floyd, u2, rhcp

PinkHerring99 | 28 Feb '06, 21:02 | Send note | Report this | Reply

whoa !

pink floyd actaully are that good

anyway, the answers oasis says i


...

RHCP or Arctic Monkeys.


.

Vengaboys


close one

although i dont hate them like most people on here RHCP have 1 and a half good albums, hardly the legends they are made out to be by many. Foo Fighters are also guilty, plus what that man said ^^^ (soapy)


you better be refering to

blood sugar sex magik and mothers milk
cos otherwise you'd be wrong ;-)


Oasis...

...from 1995 onwards. ("Definitely Maybe" was top)

If anyone thinks I'm being cynical, check my profile for a mass of (cough) "uncool" bands. Remember this: "Morning Glory" got rubbish reviews then everyone changed their tune when it sold millions. "Be Here Now" got ecstatic reviews then everyone changed their tune when it didn't do as well. It's amazing how often the press give people what they want (because of the all important circulation) rather than what they really feel...


Coldplay....

Obviously!


Nirvana are up there

Good yes, but not THAT good.


Tom Waits


Slipknot

sorry, but what is good about 9 men jumping around in rompersuits and gimp masks throwing garbage cans at each other? Saying that, Surfacing is still my favourite song of theirs.


What isn't good about that?

(what you said was bad....)


Thats the entertainment of a slipknot show

Shame about the music though.


yeah

i suppose, just never really got them at all.


completely

and utterly incorrect


nirvana

agreed

good though!


BUT

suicide sells. they are not (over)rated on their music so much. it's the corpse evryones looking at.


the Stones...


MY vote

rolling stones
u2
nirvana
rhcp
tom waits
peal jam
rem
robbie williams


Tom Waits

is underrated...like, my class don't know him...or they go "yeah he had THAT song." they are retards tho...


And Jack Johnson is THE new (james) cunt...

i hate him so so much..,i mean "good people" is no "youre beautiful" but how can people buy an album which has a song entitled "banana pancakes"...funny thing is its as bad as it sounds...


ok

the Rolling Stones i dont really get. Oasis are alright, but rip off everyone they've ever heard of. Nirvana are played to death so much that I never want to own a Nirvana album. Coldplay are overrated. Guns N Roses are possibly the most overrated. All this hype to Chinese Democracy, yet they aren't exactly groundbreaking are they? I tend to put them in the same bracket as Aerosmith, Bon Jovi etc.


BLUNT

he is over rated he is shit i hate him


you disgust me

for putting tom waits in that pile of arse. scum.


RADIOHEAD!
NIRVANA!


just had a thought

maybe most overrated by indie snobs would be more interesting. like if someone was to say 'animal collective' for instance.


THE BEATLES

.


Animal Collective is over my head. As is Xiu Xiu.

Both bands I've checked out because of DiS.


It's true though.

He is hideously overrated i say.


u2..

u2 are so overated, its unbeliable


even if only 1 person in the entire world liked u2

the would still be the most overrated band ever.


has to be

slipknot and the darkness