Drowned in Sound

Search



nick ellis nick cave proposition OST
no votes
?
by Nick Lancaster.
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 06/03/2006
  • Label: Mute

It's an odd thing, releasing film soundtracks on CD. I mean real soundtracks - there's nothing odd about releasing compilations of shit songs by cool bands with a loose connection to American Pie. But this is background music, composed to accompany specific moving images and dialogue, and since I haven't seen the film, I can't help but feel I'm missing something.

Nevertheless, released it has been. And, to Cave's and Ellis's credit, it works okay as a standalone piece; an abstract and vague narrative, driven by the occasional lyrical compositions and repeated themes. The film's a western set in Australia, Warren Ellis is a violinist, and Nick Cave is Nick Cave - that should give you an inkling of what this sounds like. Short violin- and piano-based mood pieces are the order of the day, with two meandering fragments, 'The Proposition' and 'The Rider' recurring throughout, the latter appearing in full song form at the end to wind things down on an optimistic note. (I'm told this provides a nice counterpoint to the ending of the film, but don't quote me on that.)

The actual songs are a far cry from Cave's usual alt. Leonard Cohen style. Melodies are simple, arrangements are sparse and vocals, where they appear, are falsetto whispers. They're pretty enough in and of themselves, but by being somewhat substantial they necessarily overshadow the instrumental tracks. The overall effect is of listening to half an album, albeit quite a long one with some atmopsheric bits. As such, it's an unfulfilling thing to concentrate on for forty-five minutes of your evening. But it makes fairly decent background music - which, really, is all it was ever meant to be.

  • Nick Cave 6 / 10
  • Warren Ellis 6 / 10
Words: Nick Lancaster.

Fair enough review but

see the film. Best film I've seen for ages and the soundtrack really works brilliantly. Mind you wouldn't recommend it for a first date unless you happen to be trying to impress a goth or similar. Mark Kermode sort of summed it up by describing it as written by 'laughing boy' Nick Cave....dark dark dark...


"Cave's usual alt. Leonard Cohen style"...

...that's about the most facile and absurd over-simplification of Nick Cave's work that I've ever read. You might as well have trotted out the tired "southern hellfire preacher" trope.


"Warren Ellis is a violinist"

...yes, but is it not worth mentioning that he's a violinist in both The Bad Seeds and Dirty Three?


the movie is really good

i wouldn't mind hearing the soundtrack, but i don't think i'll get it

maybe if 'they' stuck in it with the movie when the dvd comes out or something


I'm with soulboy...

The film is indeed GREAT. The Rider#2, that's the good shit. Works well on its own too. Visual and Audio combo see, that Cave, got skills.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - The Weekly DiScussion: indie-rock ethnic cleansing, who's first against the wall?