Drowned in Sound

Search



no votes
?
by Adie Nunn
With Finlay plodding about on the London scene for yonks, this is their debut Long Player and, well, hmm.

Pavement.

Oh so very, very Pavement.

ALMOST as Pavement as fellow London-based indie blokes Garlic. But not quite. Garlic’s album was horribly underrated, I reckon, but live they kinda suck a bit. Finlay’s album sucks a bit but they’re very good live. Go figure.

This ain’t a competition, however, so let’s move on.

You’ve got bands like this lot who so clearly want to write a proper pop song but at the same time fuck it up so it’s not quite as easily-accessible as it could be. Fair dos. Urusei Yatsura used to do this. And Johnny Greenwood from that Oxford band did it on ‘Creep’ with his crunchy guitar parts. Fat lot of use that did. But ignore me, I’m probably talking shite.

Finlay can be a great live band. Their guitarist seemingly has spasms onstage. They have some good songs but overall, ‘I Dreams And Visions’ is just too damn dull. If you like your Pavement-meets-Built to Spill-meets-Grandaddy type music then this could be for you, but why bother when there’s a new Grandaddy album out anyway?

It tries, but ultimately it’s a wholly unmemorable affair. There are plenty of people out there who like their pop loose, lo-fi, and off-kilter. If you are one of those people, then you could maybe find room for this in your collection. I guess I would’ve bought this in 1996…

  • Finlay 4 / 10
Words: Adie Nunn

Finlay - I Dreams and Visions

haven't heard the album but these guys were awesome at truck....

Re: Finlay - I Dreams and Visions

Adie's review ain't too bad - as she admits herself if you like bands like Pavement, Grandaddy and Built to Spill then this album is right up your alley (I actually think this album is better that Grandaddy's new one). If you're into say Muse or Carter (ahem) the chances are Finlay aren't for you.

But they are definitely better live - that is for sure.

Re: Finlay - I Dreams and Visions

What if you like Pavement, Grandaddy, Built To Spill AND Carter and Muse....?

Re: Finlay - I Dreams and Visions

I'm afraid you are incorrect.

Re: Finlay - I Dreams and Visions

I don't know... are you sure you're who you think you are? There's not someone else in there with you, is there?




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Latitude Festival 2007: the DiS review