Home / Reviews / Albums /
Shack: Here's Tom With The Weather
Having defied the bad drugs and the bad record company people and whatever other bad things cause bands to vanish for inordinate lengths of time after a hugely critically-acclaimed album, Shack are back (do you see?).
While this is a welcome return worthy of much rejoicing, ‘Here’s Tom With the Weather’ is not the, well, event I would’ve hoped for. I’m very suspicious of its intentions, its (falsely) innocent approach, its slowness in seeping into my head. Hmmmmmm. Not sure of this critter at all. Perhaps they are seasonal. Forming these pixels in the middle of a heatwave doesn’t make sense.
Shack piss me off. I think I love them, but then I think I don’t. I can’t love something that’s deeply personal to somebody else. Oh, but it’s so warm-sounding, such a feeling of timelessness, not a million miles from current Calexico output. After only a few listens, there are fleeting moments of glory, encompassed in a whole ‘body’ of ‘work’. Your singles chart can fuck right off.
There’s something starkly beautiful about ‘Here’s Tom…’. There’s the feeling that it’ll eventually be seen as one of those overlooked classics like Dexy’s ‘Don’t Stand Me Down’. On the other hand, there’s the air of muggy melancholia and acoustic angst, and during ‘Camden Road’, I’m thinking that I’d rather go and listen to ‘Happy Hour’ by The Housemartins. But if I listen to ‘Camden Road’ tomorrow, it might make me want to curl up in the corner with a Camberwell Carrot.
Hmmmmmm, yes. I shall have to have a think about this one.
-
Heres Tom with the weather
Eh! knobhead, if you dont know how to review it DONT FUCKIN REVIEW IT. Why waste a review on going on about Hmmm, not sure about this critter and other bollocks like that.
Adie fuckin Nunn???
Adie fuckin NONE (as in Taste in music)
Bellend!
That first sentence is possibly the worst start to a music review Ive ever read.
Adie lad, (or girl) I think its time for you to jib it.-
Re: Heres Tom with the weather
Not the most intelligent of people, are you?-
Re: Heres Tom with the weather
That was worth the effort of replying wasn't it ?
Is that all you'd like to say on the subject ? Any opinions of your own.
For the record, Shack are on a different plane from 99% of current music so if you don't like them, go and listen to something more suitable.
-
-
-
Shack - Here's Tom With The Weather
I really like this album, and am well pleased I bought it (on the basis of other reviews).
But kids, remember that a review is just a point of view. Having a go at someone's review is as redundant as being in a covers band of the band in the review. Sorry.

Comments
Post a new comment on this review