Over fifty years of rock and roll; half a decadent century of breathless excess and worry-about-it-in-the-morning repercussions; a lifetime’s worth of ups and downs, but more downs than ups. Feeder know all about the troughs that wait so eagerly about the sides of peaks so fleeting in their attendance – death is quite the end of many a band, yet these relative veterans of all things British and mediocre ploughed on after the passing of their founding sticksman.
One single kept the faithful full of optimism, a song so brilliantly dumb that it acted as a catalyst, propelling Feeder Mark II to where they are today, a Greatest Hits Collection-worthy group as integral to Britain’s contemporary rock scene as tomatoes are to Ragu. That single was, of course, ‘Buck Rogers’, and here Feeder have seen fit to replicate it the best they can.
Stupidly simple structure? Check. Ambiguous lyrics about a whole lot of not very much (but fuck it, cos you can sing ‘em in a stadium)? Check two. Annoyingly nasal vocals that give every aspiring Little Chris in this land and the next hope that they, someday, can emulate their heroes? Check, thrice. So why, then, does ‘Lost And Found’ suck so very terribly? Could it be that we – the music-consuming majority that saw Feeder for exactly what they were all those years ago, during the time of ‘Tangerine’ and ‘High’, a straightforward by-the-book band that got hella lucky – have lost sympathy for them? Have they stood atop this peak for a little longer than nature intended? Yes, and yes, but what’s especially sad about ‘Lost And Found’ is that it still sounds awful when surrounded by today’s similarly compositionally challenged heirs to some throne that’s never actually existed (that was the fucking point): The Kooks, Hard-Fi, et al.
Where’s the fire? Where’s even a spark? There’s nothing to this song, at all: it lacks even the basic blustering energy that made ‘Buck Rogers’ so temporarily appealing.
It’s forever saddening to lose someone dear, someone or something that’s been a part of the way you’ve lived the one life you’re given from a moment cherished until a second of clarity. But even the hardened Feeder fan must realise now, after this debacle of a throwaway single not even worthy of infinite bargain-bin residence, that the band’s time is up. Fifty years plus, not out, and always evolving: it’s rock and roll’s nature to suffer casualties, and ‘Lost And Found’ is the final rusted nail driven slowly into a casket best left buried.
so
not a fan then?
What a shite review.
It's a good song, for a start.. did you even listen to it? You spent more time talking about Buck Rogers really didn't you?
It IS a good slice of guitar pop, which Feeder DO do exceptionally well, but you never noticed because you are too focused on dismantling the band.
no, of course I didn't listen to it
I just imagined what it must be like and then penned what I felt would provoke the most fanboy responses.
It's a BAD song. If it's a slice of anything, it's a slice of shit, and no one wants that.
I've been fond of Feeder since 1996 when they toured with Terrorvision, but they've never been a good band. I realised that after the second album (for some reason I bought the first twice, and Swim twice). This is an example of mediocre rock songwriting at its blandest. There is NOTHING of value about this song, as I so very obviously say above.
The rating, and the 'dismantling', has nothing to do with the band, who come across as nice guys (I met Taka once and a sweeter man you could never hope to meet); it's all about this one song, and putting it into some sort of context. It's bland bland annoying bland stupid pointless dumb bland bland blergh... what the fuck is the point of it?
Face the fact and be done with it: it sucks.
He's got a pretty valid point.
buck rogers
was feeder mk1. it was recorded and released a good 6 months before jon lee killed himself..
aye
But it became this THING post-death, didn't it.
A shriek of positivity, a big fuck-off dumb-as-shit scream-along to banish all bad thoughts totally.
It served its purpose well, even if said purpose was never intentional... or... something...
erm, no, not really Mike
Anything post-Echo Park is seen as the stuff that's all the big post-death stuff. Unsurprisingly really, given that it was post-death.
This doesn't include Buck Rogers - never has, and never will.
As for the review, it just seems like a big bash at Feeder, rather than any sort of rational critique of the song.
IMO, Lost and Found is a perfectly good slice of guitar-pop, which Feeder do exceptionally well.
Feeder
are good I think. It's a shame this review seems to focus on the death of Jon Lee, which everyone seems to be what the band's about now. If they sing sad lyrics, it MUST be about Jon, etc.
best Feeder
song was Just a Day.
every single song
has the phrases
"going down"
"underground"
and other assorted rhymes on this theme. I have no objection to Feeder, nor any positive feelings.
They r just so....meh.
feeder are bad
that review was good.
and i like feeder by the way, i just except that they are a bit rubbish.
i
thought that was a great review
i agree
feeder are no better than the shit on the sole of a tramps shitting shoe, they remind me of shit, and should be filed under shit rock for shitheads
Hmmm
Because Tangerine was a piece of musical genius? Lost and Found is a great return to the rock.
...
oh piss off, its disgustingly boring
And really
this is Drowned in Sound. Not Melody Maker circa 1999. What do you expect?
bang on
this review is.
feeder don't provide anything of interest.
this doesn't mean they can't/won't have more hits, it's just a fact.
that's why people still harp on about the drummer's death after all this time.
The reviewer's right
This song is a load of shite.
Even for Feeder's standards.
..
spot on review. don't rise to all this shit feedback, mr.reviewer.
your almost admitting to a weak review (which it's not at all) if you have to respond and explain
spot on review
the sooner everyone can see Feeder for the transparant RAWK-by-numbers embarassing band that they are, the better.
Thank God ...
... somebody has come out and said it. Feeder aren't very good. Feeder have never been very good. Everybody: MOVE ON!
Feeder...
Cast them to the flames post haste, good review; coffin, nail, right on.
Totally fair review
As a hardened Feeder fan myself, I am so disappointed with 'Lost & Found', most tragically that this single shows Grant balatantly trying to take on a rock 'n' roll stance again and failing. At least the last single 'Shatter' had sobriety and directness to it despite its simplicity. 'Lost and Found' has neither; nobody thought about it. I'm saddened to say that having heard Feeder's potential on 'Yesterday Went Too Soon' and 'Echo Park', I expected Grant to return to fighting form when he was ready to break out of his serene 'Comfort In Sound' -esque cocoon. The butterfly was an anti-climax for me.
Crap review
Utterly pointless review, you've got a chip on your shoulder a mile high mate. I don't even like the song but their energetic stuff is superb live.
I'd like to see what you like so we can tear that to shreds. What do you like, Keane?
Or were you in a band that failed (like many "journalists") and permantly bittter as a result. Idiot.
Jeeeez dad...
...you're ALWAYS ragging on me.
I'm telling mum.
Unfair review
So Lost and Found isn't Feeder's best offering, but that doesn't mean you should trounce their whole career. What Feeder lack in innovation or originality they more than make up for in providing consistently excellent albums providing a quality mix of rock and pop. Personally I am disappointed at this offering, especially as an ambassador for the singles album, but this takes nothing away from the rest of Feeder's work.
A poor review, more about Buck Rogers and Jon Lee than an objective account of this particular single. I's unfair on Feeder to judge everything they do based on the drummer's suicide - look at the music for what it is in itself.