Drowned in Sound

Search



sole - selling live water
no votes
?
by Daniel Hayward
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 20/01/2003
  • Label: anticon
There is a big picture, but the paint is running. ‘Selling Live Water’ is a vivid corner of the canvas; an exhausting 90 BPM ride through the eyes of Tim Holland, head of the Californian hip hop collective anticon - one which deftly juxtaposes the personal and universal, barrelling past old friends, the 'war on terror' and sole himself – there is no persona here. Just Tim and a paper-thin alias. Hell, this isn’t even paper thin - he could be thinking into the microphone.

And he thinks like someone who understands that they'll only ever grasp corners of anything. In the liner notes, sole refers to his attempts to break down the propaganda he is surrounded by, and political commentary serves as a vital facet of the album, to the extent that the bile with which he regards his government rises to drown the individual who even begins to accept a life within the country’s urban veins. Which is where the self-revulsion begins, tied inextricably to the world at large; to the culture gulfs that exist in every city, to the materialism inherent in even putting out a record; sole raps "you make songs on CDs that vanish in a vacuum of money made and things piled on shelves" – he sounds tired of his own voice.

The constant vitriol here doesn’t make for easy listening, and sole isn’t in any way mysterious. He’s honest, and as such his music comes with all the baggage we associate with such backhanded compliments. After about the fourth cracked moan of "my poor ageing face" on 'Slow Cold Drops', it’s spelt out fairly clear that this isn’t a party album. Nevertheless - if you can face up to someone else’s soul bearing without wincing - 'Selling Live Water' is one of the most engaging pieces of music to drop in 2003. Holland’s gruff rap moves between conversational drawl and an arrhythmic bark that torpedoes over the understated mix of samples and live instrumentation that acts as a backdrop more than an accompaniment; a swirling mixture of head-nodding beats (try listening to ‘Pawn in the Game Pt.1’ without at least tapping your foot) lounge-jazz and rock guitars.

The production is progressive, but not difficult; the mixture of sampled melodies and live instrumentation gives the whole record a submarine clarity and (as with many anticon releases) the more listens the listener gives, the more content the album returns - the subtleties of the production, another spat out line that failed to register last time you heard it. You grow to know sole, and yet, of course, you don’t – but the impression that you do is an aim achieved. By creating a connection between artist and listener (however real), ‘Selling Live Water’ genuinely feels like a trip through someone else’s psyche, and if that psyche only constitutes a corner of a great big picture that we’re all a part of, it’s a trip to see how that corner connects to the rest.

  • sole 8 / 10
Words: Daniel Hayward

Sole - Selling Live Water

This must be the most underrated record of the year. Difficult at times but so rewarding - I think a lot of critics just didn't give it the time, which is understandable I suppose.

Try this or cLOUDDEAD to start your Anticon collection :)

Re: Sole - Selling Live Water

I found it hard to get in to at first, especially after seeing him live (which I didn't rate too highly - it's on DiS somewhere), but eventually this record made my 2003 top 5. Give it time and it really does reward you - the last two proper tracks are amazing.

Sole - Selling Live Water

No, just no.

How can you people at DiS claim this as hip-hop album of 2003 when you ignore so much good hip hop. Rjd2? MF Doom? DM And Gemini? And somehow the true best hip-hop album of 2003 (Prefuse 73 - O.W.E) didn't even warrant a review.

Most of Anticon is unbearable and cLOUDDEAD sounds like an alien collective dropping half-assed ryhmes over some fairly good beats. But either way, you don't need an Anticon collection.

The new hip-hop sub on Warp is far better than Anticon.

DiS. Either stop reviewing hip-hop or let me do it.

If you ignore both of these at least stop reviewing Hip-Hop like its indie rock, its embarassing.


Re: Sole - Selling Live Water

"One Word Extinguisher" is indeed excellent. But not, in my humble opinion, as good as this - bit too long and it doesn't pack as much of a punch emotionally. DM+J is a bit too cliched at times. RJD2 didn't even release a full-length in 2003. And MF Doom, whilst being very good, is not as special as the world makes out.

cLOUDDEAD = gorgeous, full stop. And whilst much of Anticon's stuff is deliberately esoteric at times, they still rule. At the moment I think they are still a lot better than Lex although that may change in time.

As to DiS reviewing hip-hop like it's indie rock...what do you mean? I don't understand. And surely you like the fact that decent hip-hop is getting mainstream coverage at long last?

Re: Sole - Selling Live Water

check
http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/8505.html
http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/7832.html
for proof that we do indeed dig DM & Jemini

i'll take partial responsibility for the Prefuse 73 album oversight, but we did interview him here http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/6876.html

as for anticon/cLOUDDEAD, the new cLOUDDEAD single is nutbustingly good, new album's FAR out (like, too far out) but you must have records by Themselves, Alias, Sage Francis, etc?...anticon admittedly can be patchy but there's still some awesome shit in there you gotta agree?...

Re: Sole - Selling Live Water

I didn't claim Selling Live Water was the hip-hop album of 2003. I just write the review, bub. The Why? album was my record of the year. The King Geedorah album was second (and I think a review is forthcoming). Prefuse 73 was in the top twenty. So were the Non-Prophets and Tes. The Gangstarr album was good, but not good enough. C Rayz Walz's was absolutely mediocre, etcetera, etcetera. Making assumptions about and arguing over specific issues of taste is worthless.

More importantly, I take issue with you telling me to "stop reviewing Hip-Hop like its indie rock". Have I missed something here? Is there a secret ninja training school for aspiring hip-hop writers? People reading about hip-hop know what hip-hop is. Once you've informed them that a record falls loosely within the genres' boundaries, I can't see any need to enforce the stigma that guitar music and hip-hop are absolutely opposed. Music is music and should be considered as such; I'm not interested in specific terminology or sampling laws. Nor am I interested in guitar virtuosity or punk aesthetics. This is why I enjoy the cLOUDDEAD album; because I am interested in music as organised sound and words, and it appeals to me as such. That’s the perspective from which I write about music, and if that "embarasses" you, then I can't say I'm particularly sorry.

However, I can accept review was amateurishly written, that on the whole that's a pretty kick-ass list you have there, and that Lex had a fantastic 2003. So amen to that.



Re: Sole - Selling Live Water

Spot on.

And don't put yourself down, it was a good review - one of the best I've read here recently.

Sole - Selling Live Water

Infact, you can have my top 15 hiphop albums of 2003 for free.

1. Prefuse 73 - One Word Extinguisher
2. Madlib - Shades of Blue
3. Soul Supreme - The Saturday Nite Agenda
4. Cunninlynguists - Southernunderground
5. Viktor Vaughn - Vaudeville Villian
6. Lifesavas - Spirit in Stone
7. Jaylib - Champion Sound
8. J-Zone - $ick Of Bein' Rich
9. C Rayz Walz - Ravipops (The Essence)
10. Louis Logic - Sin-a-matic
11. Dangermouse & Jemini - Ghetto Pop Life
12. Immortal Technique - Revolutionary, Volume 2
12. Gangstarr - The Ownerz
13. DJ JS-1 - Ground Original
14. Prince Paul - Politics of the Business
15. The Procussions - ...As Iron Sharpens Iron

Re: Sole - Selling Live Water

oh and respect for the Viktor Vaughn, Prince Paul and J-Zone inclusions, but jesus, are you Jay-Z or something to keep up with the Madlib releases? he put out more records this year than most people own...

Sole - Selling Live Water

I keep up with madlib releases because he is on top of his game and is proving time and time again that he is one of the most prolific AND consistant artists out there.

P.S Jay-Z - The Black album would be in my Top 20.

Sole - Selling Live Water

I keep up with madlib releases because he is on top of his game and is proving time and time again that he is one of the most prolific AND consistant artists out there.

P.S Jay-Z - The Black album would be in my Top 20.

Sole - Selling Live Water

On the front page of DiS it says, and i qoute "THE hiphop album of 2003". This may not be your words or sentiment but its there, thats why i called you out for it. The review is amatuerish but on the whole its an adaquate review for an Anticon album. We clearly don't share the same writing perspective is all.

To answer smileadelic:

"And surely you like the fact that decent hip-hop is getting mainstream coverage at long last?"

Don't make me list publications (online and not) that give decent hiphop good mainstream coverage. Its not exactly a struggling genre.

""One Word Extinguisher" is indeed excellent. But not, in my humble opinion, as good as this - bit too long and it doesn't pack as much of a punch emotionally."

Actually, O.W.E is one of the few hiphop records that has engaged me emotionally on a level that my favourite indie records have. Like these indie records (neutral milk hotel - in the aeroplane over the sea, Talking Heads - remain in light etc) it encourages you to live within the record. When you hear the painstaking detail of O.W.E, when you finally catch that tiny sample hidden between a billion other things going on (It's "I wish we never broke up girl", by the way), you realise that Heron hadn't just made tightly constructed glitch-hop album. He had made a glitch-hop breakup album. All the threads of thought that trail off and wander back to 'her' when you break up with someone, all of the anguish, upset, regret, longing and frustration. Its all here, and i can't name a single other artist who can use the medium of samples so expressively.
So, i'm gonna have to go ahead and disagree with you on that one.

Re: Sole - Selling Live Water

Yeah it's interesting what you say about "OWE", especially as I couldn't agree with you more on the NMH and "Remain In Light" front. I'll definitely give it a few more listens with that in mind.

Sole - Selling Live Water

check
http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/8505.html
http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/7832.html
for proof that we do indeed dig DM & Jemini

Yeah, i saw that. I also noticed that throughout the whole review (which was well written and enjoyable) there was little to no mention of the stellar production of Danger Mouse. The playful party hooks and leftfield leanings of his production is the very reason why "GPL" trancends the mainstream/underground devide. The fact that this wasn''t picked up on in this review is inexcuseable. Yet another DiS hiphop review that is startlingly poor for such a well-respected publication. If your going to give props to the genre by reviewing one of its best releases this year, at least do it right.




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Either/Or #2: Richard Swift