Drowned in Sound

Search



The Feeling album
2 votes
?
by Dom Gourlay

Consider this: it's July 2005 in a Universal Records boardroom meeting somewhere in London. The Managing Director comes in, leather bound folder in hand.

"This Coldplay and Athlete thing seems to be all the rage at the minute. My kids love it, your kids do too. I think we need to get someone on our label fast or we're going to get left behind."
"But we do have someone in mind, sir. Five of them actually. They've just finished working with that Sophie Ellis-whatshername. At a bit of a loose end now though." says his number one cheeseboy.
"Good! Send them in!" replies the delighted MD.

And there goes the story of The Feeling. Probably. You see, when all's said and done, I couldn't really care less where you come from, how you've got to where you are, who's behind you or what educational background you've achieved. The Beatles, The Stones, The Sex Pistols, The Clash, The Strokes all had a helping hand of varying degrees which gave them the kickstart to change the face of music at their moments in time. No, it's not about that at all. It's about the fact that this record is devoid of any passion, emotion, decadence, stimulation, variation or indeed anything other than a short term cash cow for its parent company. To call this 'project' - because that's basically all these five individuals are - The Feeling is a contradiction in itself, as there is no feeling that can be associated with this album other than one of pure despair, whether that be with its orchestrators or the record buying public themselves who've bought into the whole concept (and my other half happens to be one - eek!).

Reading through the band's biography is enough to make anyone cringe whilst throwing up nothing more than a glass of water in the process. "We make music for the masses, only intelligent, with sunshine hooks and killer choruses that everyone can hum, from plumbers to professors," they proudly boast. Singer Dan Gillespie goes on to say that you can get away with murder in pop music, and to be fair to him, Twelve Stops And Home is living proof.

Quite simply, this record is the devil's spawn incarnate unless you happen to be a Daily Mail reader, and if I have to listen to anything that contains lyrics as tritely inane as "Sugar for your bowl, lemon for your soul" again I will quite gladly go one better than Vincent Van Gogh and slice both my ears off with a rusty hacksaw blade before dipping what is left of my head in a bowl of lukewarm, salty water. It really is that excruciating, and when people like Kubichek, The Strand Arcade, Polar and, yes, !Forward Russia!, can't get signed for love nor money while this can there really should be some heads hung in shame in that record company boardroom this evening.

The End? I sincerely hope so...

  • The Feeling 1 / 10
Words: Dom Gourlay

Hurrah!

Not entirely sure they deserve that 1 to be honest...


YAAAAAAWN.

Your reviews and subsequent scores remind of a certain tacky Song Contest set in Europe - predictable, pointless and quite often laughable.


Lordi

winning said contest predictable? Naaahhh.

On the other hand, I suppose I could have said this album was a life-affirming collection of inspirational music that will influence a generation and the one after. But then I'd be lying, which would be pointless and definitely laughable.

The thing is, I haven't actually read many reviews that have criticised this album to be honest. The Times, Observer and Mail loved it, as did Q. Although maybe that says everything about the demographic audience they appeal to?


The amount of grief I got

for a slightly-harsh live review was insane. I can't understand why EVERYONE is hailing them as some really great thing. I really just don't understand... at all.


Here's my two cents...

Before I even pressed the link to the review of this album, I knew it would be low; thus, the predictablity factor is clear.

The album clearly isn't life-affirming or influential to any generation; however, nor is its intention to be. It is merely a collection of quite Summery (as per the season it's being released in) pop tunes. NOTHING more than that.

Therefore, going into the album expecting a post-apocalyptical prog rock masterpiece redefining rock music was probably, if not certainly, quite naive.

Inoffensive pop music is quite nice on ocassion. I don't consider myself a fan of "Top 40" music (to use the term 'extremely' loosely) but this sort of stuff has a place and purpose (see also: Jack Johnson, The Thrills etc).

On a side note, as much as I like them, Forward Russia are not a substitute for pop music; therefore, comparing them to The Feeling as being "hard done by" is straight away a redundant argument IMO.

My initial comment wasn't an attack on you specifically, Mr. Gourlay. It was just a general reaction to the musical elitist attitude that, whether you accept it or not, IS apparent on DiS. Hell, I get accused of as being a musical snob amongst my friends and I consider myself as 'slightly' more patient with some of my friends', quite frankly, AWFUL taste in music.

I'm fairly drunk, so if any of this made sense, then I achieved at least something.


thing is

i've listened to a fair bit of summery pop that is all also really good music, picking an obvious example i'd point to Gnarls Barkley - summery pop that is also, y'know, good music.

i just don't get the idea that it is alright for pop music to be shite. it's like airport novels, when i go on holiday i read good books because, and i thought this was quite obvious, reading good books is far more pleasurable than reading dross.

being summery pop is no excuse for being rubbish.

That said - i've yet to hear The Feeling, i just think the basis of your argument is completely flawed.


OK

I quite agree that "summery pop" and "quality" don't necessarily walk hand-inhand all the time; in fact, quite the opposite is often the reality.

Thing is, I think The Feeling, from the four songs that I've heard, ARE a fairly decent summery pop band. As regards the scorching weather we've been having recently, it's often quite nice/pleasant to listen to outside.

I think the basis of my argument is fine, thanks. You should perhaps have a closer look at yours, bearing in mind you are arguing against me, yet haven't actually heard a Feeling song. Minor point, y'know ;-)


waterwings is

RIGHT on the money
plus displays a general attitude that this site and many of its users would benefit from a great deal were they to share it more..... (as much as i personally may abhor the Kooks/Thrills/Jack Johnson etc)
though i'm more than likely howling at the moon on that one....


"Lordi winning said contest predictable? Naaahhh."

well everyone expected them to.
so aye.


just what

i was 'bout to say..


sophie ellis

bextor is fit


Sophie Ellis Bextor

IS fit, true.


Good review.

That bio extract was painful to read.

The adjective 'Killer' stinks.


they

are the new thrills. this is a FACT


You want

to see the rest of the bio - its a horror epic on a par with any of Stephen King's finest.


aaaarrrghghg

"give me a song and i'll sing it like i mean it"
i.e. i have faux soul, i.e. i have no soul.

sadly the record company will be delighted with themselves.


Haven't heard anything by

this band before. After reading this review and hearing the comments other DiSers have made about them, I never want to.


speaking of forward russia

how come there hasn't been a review of their album yet? It's the best of the year so far, no question.


They're worse...

than The Thrills. Far, far worse.

WHAT IS THIS TRASH

Not you Dom. You are great.

x


aye but

'fill my little world' is grrreat.


???

This album is probably the best of the best of the last 25 yeas


..


This album

is fantastic pop music. It's not going to change the world, but as a backing to summer BBQ it's great.


well if thats what it is

do you really expect it to get a high scoring review on DiS?


it is

everyone's happiness to be content with listening to 'decent pop' that is causing the popular music industry to become stale.

anyone who complains that this album is unfairly getting a bad score is missing the point of both music and critical analysis.

i enjoy good summery pop, but every band in my record collection does not need to be one. why bother with this when you can already get summery pop that is better, more tuneful and more deserving of praise?


Basically this is 70s soft rock

which, granted, is pretty much officially Evil and has been for a long time (30yrs and counting). That said, you know damn well your girlfriend is listening to these guys while you're at work and probably fantasizing about being with them because they're famous rock persons and made more money last weekend then you're going to make in the next twenty years! Aieee!

Yeah, a one seems appropriate. Generous even. Glad someone had the stones to say so.

RstJ


Possibly

the worst album artwork I've ever seen.


Ergh

Yeah I know man, reminds me of puke.
Whoever did it should be shot.


in that case though

you could say precisely the same about oooh...98% of all indie/new wave (of new wave of new wave.......) music that been exhaulted as important and incredible and world-changing these past 5/6 years, sure we all know the ones....but most here likely won't (unless their understanding of critical analysis is as fine as yrs).....


The Strokes...

Didn't change the face of music.


pretty good album

Expected the review, especially since Gourlay wrote it.
Arguably the worst reviewer ever? :)


they

took the template of their garage rock forebearers, diluted it slightly so it was more accessible and let it fly.

every band after them has since followed suite. so they changed the direction of music, perhaps not the face itself.


The singer blokey

Think's he's Jarvis Cocker.
Imo they're tripe, and I heard the album one miserable day when I was stuck in HMV. Never shopping in HMV again, without earplugs and prozac at the ready.


seb

is hot like a cat. yummy


uh don't you mean

"took new wave's watered-down-punk template" etc etc.......? (there's a quote from one of Pere Ubu that srpings to mind here but i cannae recall it offhand)

But then again the shite passed off as 'garage rock' these past 5 years as some sorta justification of its existance and 'worth' when it's patently never even heard a proper great classic 60s garage/r'n'b record bar maybe an mc5 best ofs...

"every band since..", "changed the face of music", haha put down that nme and copy of artrocker and stop blindly believing all you're told....


you seem to miss my point

i was not saying what they did was in anyway original, nor should it be lauded as such.

i also did not say that they 'changed the face of music' for the better.

you cannot deny, however, that since The Strokes became popular, the influx of guitar bands who share their ideas of image and sound (which were ideas created as early as the 60s) have risen thousand-fold.

well done for namedropping Pere Ubu though. it raised your crediblity immensely. i'll see if i can fit Freddie and the Dreamers in somewhere next time.


that wasn't the point of mentioning them

and much less so "namedropping". purely mentioned as it was a remark made by(whatever the leadsinger's name was - woah i've forgotten it, dang that's my credibility facade fucking blown, oh dear, betcha feel smug now) back from teh time punk was being diluted into new wave but thoroughly on-point both with regards to then and now. s'all.

its just how your comments appear to consider the strokes' rise to have been in a vaccuum, solely on musical worth, discounting the major (let alone minor) part played by the all-encompassing hype that unarguably led to their rise and subsequent 'legacy', the then-current music press situation (down to 1 unanswerable, increasingly editorially-advertising-led music weekly that the naionals give full kudos to because of its past), their 'iconic' (zzzzzzz) image and threads and b&w press photos from the coolest photographers, where they're bleedin from..... (and yeah i knowevery band's rise is due also to other factors alongside their music, but the strokes' was exceptional..)
what you said read precisely like some trite unquestioning soundbite from the nme or friday pages of the grauniad though (and these "garage rock forebearers" you keep talking about...?), which is wqhat most likely put my hackles up immediately. especially as i'd been grumpily counting down the minutes til i finished work all PM. ho hum.


let's be

friends!


ah awright ;)


perhaps

this unification and putting down of weapons was in fact inspired by The Feeling?

this album could probably end wars! (although it'll probably start them first...)


...

The Strokes didn't change the face or direction of music. They started a trend in music, which is nothing more than a fashion thing.

They're the musical equivalent of leg warmers.


Thanks for this review

the vast majority of critics in the mainstream media these days seems to be led by the buying public and the opinions of NME.

That is why, since the NME has become Smash Hits, the mainstream media has been giving good reviews and endless publicity to soft rock and manufactured guitar puke that has no resemblance to decent music.

Thus making those with awful taste thinking that by liking the Kooks, this shower of appalling twunts and Orson, Keane, Fallout boy, boy kill boy, boys r us etc etc they are somehow listening to credible music.

Don't always agree with Dis but at least they see this tripe for what it is.


It just shows you

Re: Thus making those with awful taste thinking that the likes of the Kooks, this shower of appalling twunts and Orson, Keane, Fallout Boy, Boy Kill Boy, Boys r us etc etc they are somehow listening to credible music..."

The Kooks graudated from the Brighton School of Music and Orson have been touring relentlessly for decades (yes decades). These bands aren't maunfactured; nobody plucked them out of thin air like the Spice Girls.


If you think

going to the Brighton School of Music makes you unmanufactured, I pity you. It's the most derivitive, soul destroying organisation - a music SCHOOL, it's so ridiculous - that has produced some truly terrible artists.


snobs!

It's just nice music; good harmonies, good melodies, good hooks. Why can't people just appreciate this album for what it is and stop giving the band such a hard time just because they're not cool enough.


i heard

the Housemartins the other day. they have "good harmonies, good melodies, good hooks" and they're hardly cool.

wait a minute... what's my point?

oh yeah: been there, done that.


the feeling

I love this album. Why is not possible to appreciate more than one genre of music? Sure there are some indisputably pure 'pop' songs on this album, but they are certainly not devoid feeling or interest as the review attempts to claim. It's a shame that the review to this album was written before even listening to it.


Another thing

Try writing a review that helps people. Why not tell them WHY it's bad rather than prcoeeding off on a tangent about the band's biography.

You didn't breathe a virtual word about a single song.


i simply dont understand

how people can really love a band that are as souless as the feeling. they are bland, trite and devoid of any passion or feeling ironically enough.

why should we not demand more from pop music?


The discussion

prompted by this review is excellent. well done to all involved.


Dom D1ckhead

Try listening to the Album before reviewing it, it might help next time. Nothing wrong with this at all, well constructed good melodies & hooks.

Also try talking about the music, rather than what's on their website

I just went to the toilet and sh4t a better review out of my ar5e.


"Wings were only the band that The Beatles COULD have been..."

I love listening to The Feeling whilst pretending to be Alan Partridge...


bnm,

My favorite megaupload files search engine is http://megauploadfiles.com
it’s the most powerful and easy to use.

<a href="http://megauploadfiles.com "> megaupload files</a>
provides relevant search results.