Drowned in Sound

Search



no votes
?
by Anthony Smith
  • Type: Single
  • Release date: 12/04/2004
  • Label: Polydor
Coldplay may or may not be the worst thing to happen to popular music in the last five years - that's a debate for another time and place - but one thing's for sure, the success of their benign stadium rock has let loose on the charts an abhorrent assortment of the blandest of bands.

The floodgates have opened and inanely competent nondescript (not even ugly enough to have the fortune of being called ugly) white boys like Keane, Athlete and Snow Patrol have evidently all been given keys to the MD's washroom.

Ah, you say, what has the band's image got to do with the music? Ah, I say, bloody everything. As my old PE teacher (a dead-ringer for 'Magnum P.I.') used to say: "You look good, you feel good; you feel good, you play good." And thus, it follows, if you look like you've been kitted out at Littlewoods and had your hair cut by your gran, your music will be painstakingly, arse-numbingly dull.

And the dictum is well proven here because 'Chocolate' is one helluva crashing bore. Whereas the interminable 'Run' was very 'Yellow', this - with its Celtic flavour - is very Travis. (If you haven't already guessed, these are not very promising touchstones.) And, as with 'Run', they see fit to adhere to a woeful plodding tempo which, one assumes, is a deliberate attempt to crush my ailing soul.

Surely singles should, to quote a scary hairy Danish dance duo, move your feet. That's why God invented the 7". This drivel leaves you rooted to the floor like Wes Brown during a set-piece for the opposition.

Any good music in the history of the universe has relied on at least one of two elements: excitement and intensity, and you don't have to be a particle physicist to conclude that this tepid track has neither.

This is a recording designed to fit into a banal lifestyle, without friction, without fuss. It slots in nicely with that trip to Ikea, that purchase of a deluxe double-disc DVD, that Pizza Hut meal deal...

It's merely music for people who have given up on music.

  • Snow Patrol 1 / 10
Words: Anthony Smith

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

you are joking right? travisty and mouldplay aspire to the greatness that is Snow Patrol. Listen to the album before you compare them to the droning shite. Tiny Little Fractures, Wow, How To Be Dead... CHOONS. Chocolate. Best song on the album. If it sounds like travis, I'm a french-fry loving welsh hobbit.

I'm not welsh


Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Interstingly, the review does not even mention the B-sides. Perhaps our incest-spawned reviewer here would care to enlighten us on his unbiased views on the quality of the b-sides. And also describe them. Maybe he could also do that for all the rest of his single reviews he had submitted to the site. Then it might be a review of the single, rather than just the song.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

>It's merely music for people who have given up on music.

Too right.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Great review, spot on.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Sadly, not every band wants to make the music Anthony likes..
Sadly, not every band can be revolutionary..
Sadly, not every band care that much about how they look..
Sadly, some bands release singles not solely for dancing purposes..
Sadly, too few people have dismissed Snow Patrol as another C*ldplay or Tr*vis.. and the result of this closed-minded attitude is that they've missed out on one of the greatest pop albums of the last 5 years!

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Sorry if Snow Patrol aren't cool enough for you mate. Maybe you'd have liked them if Run had missed the top 40 like most of their previous stuff.

Me? I've got all five albums (Including the reindeer section duo) and love 'em all.

And thanks for doing the review, every column inch helps the band sell more copies.

Snow Patrol - Final Straw, best album of last year. Only noticed this year by the media...

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

What are the names of all there five albums because i've got there latest one and I want to get the others as well

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I have heard starship fighter in the last week and have to say there early demo's are better then any punk or rock band around at the moment gary lightbody true genius (not like chris martin who is over hyped)

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Songs for Polar Bears
When it's all over we still have to clear up
Y'all get scared now y'hear? (as Reindeer Section)
Son of Evil Reindeer (as Reindeer Section)
Final Straw (2 versions)

Earliest stuff contains screatching & electronics up to two quiet RS albums. Newest is a mix of the two styles. WOW is very first albums, Run is very RS.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Using football analogies in a music review?! You really are a clever boy. The deafness must be hard for you, but i think after that review you deserve everything you get...

No backing up of your points...
No decent comparisons with any relevant bands...
Let's all just jump on the bandwagon eh?! "Oh...the band are British you say?! Well then...let's compare them to Coldplay and Travis...don't know why...saw it in the NME once...Look mummy! I'm a music journalist!!"

Three top tips for you Anthony, if that IS your real name...

1. Research.
2. Don't ever write another review again.
3. Get Laid.


Snow Patrol - Chocolate

thats funny, i don't like snow patrol but that review was rubbish. they do sound a bit like travis and coldplay, in that its guitar indie.. if he doesn't like the genre, maybe he shouldn't be reviewing it..

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

"It's merely music for people who have given up on music."

That is so, so true.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

this is a shocking review.uninformed.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I love completists who justify a song being good by harping on about how they heard 'em first and own everything they have ever released.

I suggest now would be a perfect time to stop collecting this cr*p.


Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Thing is as well, Isn't it Coldplay and Travis that copy Snow Patrol being as they've been around longer but dumb journo's didn'yt notice them, and the only existed as of Run?

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Okay, here's something.

Now that Snow Patrol have become popular, loads of people are insulting them.

I have no problem with this, you can like what you like.

BUT IF YOU'RE FUCKING GOING TO INSULT A BAND WHEN THEY'RE BIG, WHY DIDN'T YOU DO IT WHEN THEY WERE SMALL? HUH?

fucking elitist dicks

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I luv Snow Patrol, fuck what people think.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Well, in my case, I insult them now they're big because it coincides with a fairly ropey album. I loved 'Songs For Polar Bears' but this new one is bereft of decent lyrics, and they try (and fail) to make up for the lack of decent melodies with horrible, cheap-sounding electronics.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

"IF YOU'RE FUCKING GOING TO INSULT A BAND WHEN THEY'RE BIG, WHY DIDN'T YOU DO IT WHEN THEY WERE SMALL? HUH?"

MAAAAAAAAAYBE one of the reasons is that when they were small is more people hadn't heard them, so couldn't slate them cos... they didn't know who they were.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Hey it sound more like a Folk Implosion track to me....
Who are Coldplay?

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

It's hard to insult someone when you have never heard them.

You cannot always be there at the start and you don't need to know the whole history of a band to review them.

When a single is poo a single is poo.
When a single is good a single is good.
End of story.

And byu the way you don't need to behave like monkeys to listen to them.


Snow Patrol - Chocolate

As interesting a debate as this has become, I'm surprised to see no one has mentioned the fact that the song doesn't actually make any reference to chocolate.

Coincidence or conspiracy?

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I just hate the fact that the label decided to re-release the album following the success of Run. Someone made the very valid point that Snow Patrol have in fact been around far longer than Coldplay and for a similar timeframe as Travis. Personally I don't even agree with the travis comparisons. And another thingm don't be as shallow as to say whether how the band looks will affect the music, I think you maybe just have some personal vendetta against the mighty snow patrol and need a good kick up the arse!!!!

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

"I just hate the fact that the label decided to re-release the album following the success of Run."

Yeah, it absolutely terrible that they should sell more albums on the back of its success...

Jeez, get a grip.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I don't think that many songs on that album seem to have anything much to do with their titles, 'Run', 'Same', 'Somewhere A Clock Is Ticking' and anything else I've forgotten aside

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Each unto his own. Praise Be.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Well adie, what are the people that went and bought the album on the day of its official release supposed to do? Buy the album again for 1 or 2 extra tracks??? You get a grip....

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

if it was the exact same album rereleased then Adie wins
if it was rereleased with extra tracks then you win

FIGHT

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

http://www.playlouder.com/feature/+swells-8/

= This review, only actually funny


If you're going to say something as unoriginal as
indie = middle class = EVIL!! EVIL!!!!! you could at least do it with a bit more style and humour

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I can't claim to have heard this track. I tried hard with "Run", I really, really did, but I'm sorry to have to say I actually think it's an insult to Coldplay to compare this band to them. And that's saying something.

I actually thought that was a top-class review. If some people had actually read it properly they might have noticed that the song wasn't compared in a specific, stylistic sense to Travis or Coldplay but in a broad, purposive way to convey the general impact / effect of the song. And come on, that last couple of paragraphs were pretty funny whether you like the song or not.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

how the bands looks does affect their music especially when playing live, but not or record (as how can looks affect a sound)
i have an example, if you see a band play with little energy (they all look depressed) no matter how great the music their apathy towards playing passes on to the crowd. last week i saw luma lane, they get great reviews, but live they all stare at their instruments they maybe gave eye contact to the crowd once or twice each. they were dire live. sort of bic runga with an attempted cross with four non blondes. the lead singer had a pleasant enough voice, just the musicianship wasnt very challenging.
i always find a bands image and stage presence has everything to do with how good the gig is as a whole.
i find even if i dont like the music i can put up with watching a band have a fucking great time. (i don't particuarly like the hives on record but seen them live and i liked there music live, same with the darkness - i dont mind them on record but live they are great)
anyway my point is that image has everything to do with how well the music is received by the general population.
and final straw isnt rubbish but its not snow patrols best album.
anyway just out've curiousity did any read the piece in the sun today about the album chart? was a very good piece. (not that i am a devout sun reader mind)

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

To be honest, i really do like this track, sod the comparisons to other bands, its a stong enough track (in my opinion) to be able to stand alone. I hadn't heard anything of Snow Patrol other than the 2 singles from Final Straw up until i saw them support Athlete at the Guild Hall in Preston, but i thought they were absolutely excellent live, and after buying the album on the back of that i feel i wasn't disappointed. Chocolate is probably the best track on it n'all. But hey, each to their own, you're free to critisise, just try to judge a song on its own individual merits. By the way, who's seen the video for it? Thought it was excellent to be honest.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

OK. I like this record. Probably because it sounds like 'Pounding' by Doves. And I saw them tonight in Bristol, afraid that they were going to be shoegazers after all I had read around here. They weren't and Gary was a very funny man too.

As for the reissue, yes they did put extra tracks on. But they also put them on their website for free download, and they're still there.

>This is a recording designed to fit into a banal lifestyle, without friction, without fuss. It slots in nicely with that trip to Ikea...

I had to laugh at this bit. Especially as I bumped into a friend outside who had just seen Zero 7 at the Colston Hall next door. I used to know an Ikea-freak and she listened to their first album constantly. She annoyed me a lot. And she would have hated Snow Patrol.

But blaaaahh... whatever. Class snobbery is a very bad way to write a review. Perhaps hypocritical of me to say this after the last paragraph, but then I wasn't writing the review!

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Exactly, all the people saying that it's a bad review because Snow Patrol are great or something are missing the point, that's a matter of opinion.
Bringing the same crap, tired, class snobbery and stereotypes as far too many reviewers succumb to is the problem, I'm sure it would be perfectly easy to write a negative review without resorting to such desperate levels.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

But then, hey, what do I know, I'm middle class so I shouldn't even have the right to be here

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I think you have all made your own assumptions on class snobbery here as it certainly isn't mentioned in the review.

I buy DVDs.
I eat pizza hut (although my girth suggests I shouldn't).
and maybe if I had enough Snow Patrol albums I am sure I would go to Ikea and buy a nice rack to keep them in.

I buy these things because I like them. I won't buy this Snow Patrol single becasue I don't. It's nothing to do with class but is everything thing to do with taste.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

i'm sorry that you were dropped on your head as a kid anthony... that's the only possible explaination for the fact that you don't realised a great song when it jumps up and slaps you on the face!

i don't actually mind coldplay or travis but THEY CANNOT COMPARE TO SNOW PATROL, go see them live if you don't believe me ... then come back and do a proper review!!!

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Gary Lightbody is a legend, simple as that, you wouldnt think it from the music but he is an incredibly funny guy and he actually had his own stand up show at the edinboro fringe festival 2years ago.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Anthony Smith doesn't like the single. I do. It's all about opinions, isn't it.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

stop mentioning coldplay when talking about snow patrol tnx

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I'm sorry, but yet again the Patrol get beaten down for one reason - snobbish elitism. It's not so long ago that this site was championing them, and now all of a sudden they hit the top 5 and have apparently turned into Travis. Fuck off. Still great, and Chocolate remains the same great song it was when the album was getting all those great reviews back in August.

I quote - "Nearly, oh-so-close to swaggering into the limelight and to have the world know of Gary Lightbody's lush tones, their silky smooth, carefully-crafted tales of love, and love lost."

"The whispers have been going round for months about this little beauty, but don't hush hush, don't keep it to yourself. Everybody deserves a slice. "

Well, it's happened and look what happens. It's as predictable as it is pathetic.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

You quote reviews written by different people than to this article in question. Different people = different opinions. DiS has no editorial policy on Snow Patrol. (At least, not one I've been informed of.)

adie (who gave 'The Final Straw' 4/5)
xxx

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Anal comment:

It's 'Final Straw'.

Yeah, sorry. It just had to be done..


Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

This very point occurred to me as I was writing that post but I thought I'd give myself a bit of licence... It was a convenient way of venting my spleen, oh well!

Backlashes like this are one of my pet hates.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

that review was about the album?
so how can you compare a single review to an album review.
that reviewer might well have thought chocolate was a weaker track on the album (but it slotted in nicely) and therefore a rubbish single. (just because its a rubbish single doesn't make it a rubbish song, if you get what im saying) A single has to be really amazing because you would be paying £1.99ish for it, now is 'chocolate' really worth paying £1.99+or- for? i would say no. but that doesn't mean i hate the song, and it doesn't mean the reviewer who reviewed chocolate dislikes the song (he may i don't know, in fact he can answer if he does like the song or not). he is criticising it on the basis that it is a single.
'how to be dead' should've been the next single in my opinion.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

'how to be dead' is my favourite track by farrrrrrr.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I'm in America where Coldplay has gotten mild notice but no one has heard of Snow Patrol, Travis et al. I've been a fan for two years and fell in love at first listen. Whilst I'll readily agree that "Chocolate" isn't the best song they've ever done, the label are the ones who decide what gets released and what doesn't, not the band. Not a band at this point in their career. They truly are a Cinderella story, having been brutally dumped by Jeepster who I hope are now crying in their St Patrick's day pints.

Anyone can criticise, but could the criticism be more balanced and constructive?! Oh, and informed?

Let's just settle down and see what happens in the long "Run." ;-)

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

They were never "dumped" by Jeepster; the label folded. It only exists now to sell back-catalogue and I think the B&S DVD...

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

yeah, that was what i thought as well.

great DVD as well. isobel campbell walking her dog, and chris geddes wanting to visit ikea... classic stuff.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I think it's a lazy comparison, Coldplay/Travis et al. All too easy to say, but how can it possibly be true?
It's not my favourite song on the album, but it's certainly worth of its status as a single. They deserve all the success they get with it.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Give the reviewer a break, he thinks it's shite, most of you think it's great, get over it.

mcgdog

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Amen to that.

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

I reckon big up to Anthony Smith myself. The purpose of journalism is to give an opinion and to evoke emotion whether positive or negative. Whether your view be public opinion or not! By merely stating his OWN opinion on a, less face it no more than mediocre song, he has acheieved what he set out to do. Well done Anthony for making the band wagon riding C's have something to think about!

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

god mate before you review make sure u even know how to your shite chocolate is ace

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

i take that back you need ripping more YOU LIVE WITH YOUR MUM AND HOW THE FUCK CAN YOU JUDGE A BAND BY THEIR HAIRCUTS YOU RETARD YOU ARE A FUCKIN SHITE REVIEWER AND NEED SACKING YOU HAVE YOUR HAIRCUT BY YOUR GRANDMA GET A JOB GET A GIRLFRIEND GET LAID AND NEVER REVIEW AGAIN YOU SUCK

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

You should be ashamed of yourself with this post. At least the review can punctuate a sentance.

Take a long look in the mirror and have a good cry. You're in for a hard life with an attitude like that.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

not trying to be ageist, but this is fucking rich coming from a 16-year- old. Sod off back to college and come back when your balls have dropped

Snow Patrol - Chocolate

once snow patrol achieves global success then the coldplay and travis comparisons will fade. just as coldplay was compared to travis in their less successful times. i am not a huge fan of either, i think coldplay's last album was much better than travis, though beautiful occupation was an ok song, shit lyrics, but nice melody, and nice to see a little tempo from the boys in travis. I would say that any new/lesser known band (i know snow patrol have been around for awhile, having a number of albums under their belts, but until run, i would put them definitely in the lesser known category)the press NEEDS to compare them to someone. When starsailor was just starting to catch, some press i read said the next coldplay or travis. really these three band are not sound alikes really at all, but the comparison thing. So once snow patrol trips around the world, makes a name for themselves internationally, then they will come back, and the press will lick their balls, and say, 'ooohhh, snow patrol, what a joyous noise you make, the likes of which we have not heard before', as opposed to what they say now, 'this, plodding dirge of a song could be good if they could break out of their want to be coldplay or travis mold, and do something truly original.'

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

i think you're over-estimating how successful snow patrol are gonna be. in terms of size i think they'll find their level about the same as idlewild.

and i'm fairly sure starsailor made it into the mainstream before coldplay. so far as starsailor compaerisons go i dont see how they could be, or would be, compared to travis, when the stereophonics are there as a much better one.

also, i think that the people saying what a plodding dirge they make are people who dont like coldplay and travis (as you say), but those same people will never turn round and say that snow patrol are great just because they become big.

if, and its a very big IF, they achieve commercial success in america. all that will happen is the cool kids over their will start hating them as well.

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

"and i'm fairly sure starsailor made it into the mainstream before coldplay."

Coldplay had already released Yellow and Parachutes half a year before Starsailor even released their first single, so I think you might be wrong

Re: Snow Patrol - Chocolate

Wouldn't that suggest that absolutely everyone would rate Coldplay now? Clearly not the case.