Drowned in Sound

Search


Home > Reviews > Live


Date: 05/04/2004
no votes
?
by Gen Williams
Fuck, isn't anyone sick of this? Girls in bands that yelp yelp yelp, string out a discordant chord here and there and proclaim themselves to be serious punk-rock artists - rubbish. Punk is fucking things up painfully and visibly, shocking and pissing off as many people as humanly possible for a reason - because YOU'RE pissed off for a valid reason - screw teen angst. And this makes a joke of it. KaitO. Yelp yelp yelp. Yelp. This band made sense two years ago. Their spiky sound pulsated with fervour and purpose - even at its most incomprehensible, it throbbed with a self-justifying, compelling fury. What happened? Right now, this means nothing at all. Nothing they do conveys anything other than the desire to make a racket; it's a mess, and not even a mess for any conceivable reason. Recent recorded efforts show they can still do better than this; but tonight all they have is a great drummer that they don't fucking deserve. That's it.

Erase Errata. Galloping drum cycles, blah-shaped chords and lower-pitched yelping. What happened to fucking great female vocalists? We're not talking professionally trained, clean-as-a-whistle, sieved-to-fine-grained-perfection bullshit, but something individual and alive and corrosive and for God's sake, memorable - something that could leave acid-splattered footprints eroding the ceiling of your skull and deep vibrations reverberating through the inner sanctum of your ears for days. Janis. Joni. Tori. Courtney. Any fresh recruits on the way? No? Yelp-yelp it is then. Fuck OFF, this will never affect anything. This will not jolt Ver System or push things forward, it's not brave or new - it doesn't even have "attractive" in its favour. Everett True is WRONG. Why the fuck are there two drumkits? You can only hear one of them. Fucking pointless.

But. Wait. Something... yes. Now we're talking. Both drumkits getting a royal pounding - and sweet mother of Keith, you can actually hear the kicking that's being inflicted on them both. It sounds like a Xinlisupreme intro - wired and properly brutal. It's starting to sound hungry. More dischords, and no, it's not turning out to be the song that saved the world, but maybe this band have some guts and grit in there somewhere. This chick's barking disordered lyrics and lyrical orders and musing about poetry and robots and feelings and Yoko Ono. Cue predictable crowd response - "Yoko Ono's a cunt!" Original. Undeterred, they cover a Yoko song. It's twee as hell and about as vital as the Frog Chorus, but there's something defiant in their belief in it. They got guts, at least.

What's that? There ARE some real vocalists left out there? Shit, yeah. From the moment Le Tigre's Kathleen Hanna opens her trap, the quality level leaps about 4 notches in the right direction. This is what we needed in the first place. The bizarre, helium-abused fruit of Hanna's throat could shatter glass at 1000 paces - this is why the Astoria serve their overpriced drinks in plastic cups. No guitar wankery - where the guitars get a look in, they're serrated, rusty, and tetanus-loaded, ripping through everything in their paths, held at bay merely by sparse, squelchy, move-ya-big-ass-round beats that command all the movement in this sizeable void. One big fat uncompromising rhythm lays down the law from the get-go, and doesn't stop to ponder its place in the world or the artistic merit of what it's doing. What we're talking about here is conviction, and Le Tigre have it in spades. Forget shame at the unfashionable stigma of feminism - "Fifty years of ridicule!", Hanna and her cohorts scream in 'F.Y.R', meeting a room full of pumped fists and roared responses. And for an hour it really seems that simple, that clear-cut. It's not about sounding angular for the fucking sake of it and putting on a po-faced show of arty seriousness while rehashing hooks that Sonic Youth threw to the wolves years ago; it's about one big digital suckerpunch - it's about reaching an audience, about eliciting an instant reaction, about mixing anger and frustration with the kind of pop suss that leaves absolutely no excuse for not paying attention and taking something from it. Le Tigre are at once pop heroes and missionaries for their cause.

Post a new comment on this review

Le Tigre

"Janis. Joni. Tori. Courtney. Any fresh recruits on the way?" There's Carina Round for one, Ellie Langley for another - I give it a year before they're both megastars. at least in a PJ Harvey kind of way.

Le Tigre, meanwhile, rock.

Re: Le Tigre

Le Tigre were truly brilliant. Loved every minute of it.

Didn't see Kaito but thought Erase Errata were pointless and went nowhere.

Female vocalists that matter? Two words - Sleater and Kinney.

Re: Le Tigre

i've not heard ellie langley. saw carina round a while ago at ulu.. she got better and better as her set progressed but i confess, didn't blow me away. need to hear her on record though.

x
gen

Le Tigre

le tigre were awesome. My first time seeing them live and i was blown away. Kathleen Hanna is such a complete natural, a genius! The personalities that come thru when she is on the microphone are just fanatastic. Yeah Erase Errata seemed to have graduated from Hogwarts waaay too soon- obviously there's a place/audience for their music, but they bored me. ("I'm part robot"? Whaaaat?!?!)

And yes, Sleater Kinney rule. it's funny cuz i saw patti smith recently and she's still light years ahead of bands like erase errata.

Le Tigre

It's par for the course that a band such as Erase Errata will divide the audience - their album is an absolute headache at times, yet has moments of utter genius.

One thing is clear though - let's get away from this tiresome 'female vocalists who matter' debate, please. There is probably the same ratio of tiresome male vocalists as tiresome female ones. Maybe we should adore our artists for how they move you, and not because of essentialist notions of gender.

Le Tigre

OK, so split the gig up by band as per the review. Le Tigre were great. Fact. Erase Errata are frustrating live, nowhere near as good as they are on record and the singer is a bit on the out-there side.

As for Kaito, Gen, all I can say is that you're wrong. Kaito are fantastic and seeing them play to an audience who scarcely knew any of their material, winning them over in the process was fantastic. So they "Yelp", so what? They rock. And they rock with style and sass and attitude.

Re: Le Tigre

and I heard a rumour they might be back soon... and damn good if they are!! Le Tigre that is....

Re: Le Tigre

i looked forward to kaito so much - i caught them with seafood and billy mahonie and easyworld at ulu a couple of years [or thereabouts?] ago, and they were stunning. at the astoria the other night they just seemed to have absolutely abandoned the spark and direction they had. i don't know if it was typical of their live shows these days, or merely an exceptionally bad peformance from them. but they dismayed and annoyed me.

x
gen

Re: Le Tigre

Its been a little while since i've seen Kait0 Gen, last time was in Nottingham with the Liars i think (whom they completely outplayed). The new album isn't perhaps as 'poppy' as You must have seen us..., but perhaps more satisfying. Its just music that makes me want to dance like a fool. Dave's guitar stuff is interesting/different/fun, and while Nykie's vocals may be coming more stylised (and, in some way, more american :S ), for me, it just works.
I managed to miss the gig in Bristol, and will miss Kait0 playing in Norwich again next week, but they've never ever failed to enthrall me live.
Give them another chance Gen.....

Le Tigre

I agree with JonnyRockstar here. Kaito's vocalist has as much right to 'yelp' as Tori Amos has to 'sing'.

I mean, Kathleen Hanna did a fair bit of hectoring in Bikini Kill. A good vocalist does what the song and the band demands - and Kaito is a pedal to the metal alt-rock band

Re: Le Tigre

sure, she's got every right to do it if she wants. but it doesn't mean it'll sound good; i'm merely offering one critical opinion, which you may or may not agree with. there are certain vocal styles that work if everything else is in place; if it's not, they sound godawful. if she'd yelped over something that sounded fantastic, it wouldn't have bothered me. as it was, the good songs that they do have sounded tangled, shoddy and lost, and the yelping really didn't help.

x
gen

Le Tigre

"There are some REAL vocalists out there?"

Gen, what on earth do you mean by this? I'm confused as to how you can compare Kathleen's, Jenny EE's and Nikki Kaito's vocals, all of which are completely idiosyncratic and vital to their music, and yet find one set great and the other two lacking? How are you judging this?

And all this focusing on women's voices kind of reminds me of the specious, sexist argument that women can't play instruments, and so the only place for them in bands is as the singer. I'm sure this was not your intention, however...I hope.

BTW, Le Tigre were indeed great. Erase Errata were a lot tighter the following night in Birmingham. :)

Le Tigre

of the three bands, only kathleen's vocals complemented her band's music; her vocals took an already vital and punchy sound, and gave it fresh impact. the others did nothing whatsoever for their music.

i'm a girl myself, and while i don't consider myself a feminist, i'm certainly not gonna be suggesting that women can't play instruments or produce great music - rather, it pains me when average 'girl bands' or female musicians perpetuate this myth. i hate the notion that female bands/artists should be judged separately to male ones, and with both support bands it seemed to me that had they been entirely male bands, they might have garnered less attention than they have thus far. i could be wrong, but that was my perspective on it.

my singling out of the vocal styles was because male or female, i particularly appreciate good vocals. there are far too many average vocalists out there.

x
gen

Le Tigre

Thanks for clearing that up. :) I know you're female, which is why I found it odd that your review kept on picking out the gender of (almost all) of the performers like it was a strange thing, in a 'ohmigod, chicks are in bands!' kind of way. Particularly one of the first lines: "Girls in bands that yelp yelp yelp, string out a discordant chord here and there and proclaim themselves to be serious punk-rock artists." Like men aren't occasionally guilty of that too... ;)

But I know what you mean about average female musicians - although they could be held up as proof that women can't play, I want to see the day when female bands can just be average (or poor, or great), with their gender not noteworthy any more.

*climbs off the soapbox*

Le Tigre

Have to agree with you on Kaito. It was just a noise with some yelps... nothing really held the songs together or gave you anything to hook onto. People were comparing them to sleater kinney or clinic but they just didnt have the tunes...

Erase errata had some great moments though when some of the more angular jazzy bits had a chance to shine through over the rather incoherent guitars. But yeah Le tigre ten times better than both of them. awesome fun

I think what i wanted to say was... if youre in a guitar band and dont really give much of a shit about making melodic and harmonic sense with your songs... then go all the way and make a freaky noise-core record. Or concentrate on the rhythms and get something hardcore dancable going. Or something. But whatever you do dont just sit there half assedly between the two producing tuneless incoherent any-old-chords
guitar attack thats not hardcore enough to be engaging on a guttural level and not tuneful enough to be engaging on a melodic level either...
</whine>

Re: Le Tigre

frankly i'd like to see some girls make a really heavy stoner record. i caught part chimp a couple of weeks ago, and they were absolutely obliterating... i'd love to see some girls working along the same kind of tangent, because the more of that kinda stuff, the better really :D it dismays me that so many women in bands follow the same old girlrock cliches.

why are there no female bands being influenced by stuff like mastodon?! [if there are, PLEASE, a show of hands....]

x
gen

Le Tigre

go matt!

Le Tigre

I've never listened to Erase Errata or KaitO, but I have a certain affection for Le Tigre. I think their sound is different and not overly-done at all. Perhaps it's due to the fact that I'm live in the states, but I think they're something new. Something different. It's nice to have a change once in awhile, you know?

Le Tigre

Le Tigre- Sigue Sigue Sputnik.

If you are a girl singer in a band, you get loads of young boys adoring you. It's lovely. Can't blame us- sex and drugs and rock n roll- the girls can do it too.

Le Tigre

The band i used to be in were very much influenced by Mastodon, Isis & Old Man Gloom

Two girls in it too!

Re: Le Tigre

hurrah! :D

but..but... *used* to be in? what became of it??

x
gen

Re: Le Tigre

I destroyed my hand and can't play guitar as good now :o(




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Drugs. Music. Let's talk.