Drowned in Sound

Search



Is my comment on this girl's MySpace overly harsh?

no votes
?
by John_Brainlove
John_Brainlove | 02 Jul '06, 23:40 | Send note | Report this | Reply

good job brainlove

she needed telling.


LOL

no, that was good.


err

the comment I mean, not the music...


oh god

and she likes the kooks, corinne bailey rae and other mor shit bands. fucking hell, people have shit taste.


OH NOES//

SOMEONE LIKES A FEW BANDS YOU DON'T.
MAYDAY!!!!!
MAYDAY!!!!!!!!!!


I just realised

She's 14, and I used the word cunt.
I'm deleting it.
I don't wanna get banned.


for reference:

I just accepted your request so I could express absolute astonishment that anyone sound of mind would not only befriend that pathetic wet blanket whining cunt James Blunt, but then advertise the fact by putting him in their top friends. Before blocking you again.

MY GOD GIRL!
I MEAN, REALLY

x


it was obviously noted...

...no sign of James Blunt anywhere on her page now... A bit harsh for someone who's obviously just finding their feet in music. You have to write a lot of shit songs and listen to a lot of dubious music before you figure out what you actually want to say for yourself. Some people never do (witness the zillions of distinctly average open-micers), but there's no harm in trying... I just quietly deny anyone I really dislike - especially if they're just a kid.

x


hehe.

Be honest with them at an early age!


Brainlove, that is fucking priceless... truly...

(I am glad you have noted that she is 14 - I mean, how could you not have noted that???!!!)

I am cacking myself - even funnier that you are now trying to delete it!


damnit..

deleted?! anyone care to reference the content..


^^^^

See John's post up there.


Under some circumstances I'd think it harsh

but I've just spent the evening at an open mic night listening to shite singer-songwriters who appear to be pursuing their lifelong dream of sounding like every other motherfucking singer-songwriter on the planet which has left me wanting to bludgeon myself unconscious, partly to relieve myself from the pain and partly to ensure I don't wind up harming them instead.

So I'm inclined to applaud you. Even if she is 14.


as it loads

the anticipation grows.


yes, it was.


perhaps

but not your comment on James Blunt...


I think it's too harsh

It seems silly and vaguely cruel to accept a friend add just to do that. Even if she was 21 or something, amusing though the comment was, I don't really see the need for it...


I would have feigned interest

in her and her music taste and made friends with her. Perhaps go to a few gigs then maybe take her out for dinner - naturally one thing would lead to another and we'd eventually get married, have children, buy a house watch our children grow up maybe one day we'd enjoy playing with our grandchildren together. Eventually I'd become very old and sick and just before I died I'd say "oh by the way I just married you so I could express absolute astonishment that anyone sound of mind would not only befriend that pathetic wet blanket whining cunt James Blunt, but then advertise the fact by putting him in their top friends..."


Is the plan

to systematically attempt to mock and shame every one of James Blunt's fans starting with the youngest? That could take a really long time.


Yeah.

Its a really funny plan isn't it?


For a 14-year-old

her songs are OK. Certainly, as her taste and skill grows, she could turn into a very fine songwriter, who knows?

My music taste was pretty awful at 13/14


I like her.

For her age, she's writing and recording her music, and that in itself is admirable.

Good luck to the lass.


I started writing songs at 14...

...and had the deceny not to record them and broadcast them to the world. I feel that, with most 14 year old song-writers, that's the far more admirable route.

I didn't listen to the music but she had a song called "middle class cliche" which is probably the most teenage song title in the history of the world ever.


When you were 14

myspace music wasn't an option. Perhaps she just wants feedback?


Well I wrote some stuff

when I was 14 that I thought was good. If I looked back at it now, I'd be glad Myspace music wasn't around. Give her a break.


Aye. And even now I'm still way too stupid to use recording equipment!

I was being a bit glib there. Maybe she does want feedback and obviously it's good to encourage people to make and record music.

I'm being really horrible 'cos I've not listened to her or anything. I'm just so bored with competent but unimaginative acoustic singer-songwriters (which she of course may not be) and want to vent my frustration.

I promise to shut up and behave myself from now on.


I bet 90% of songwriters you love

wrote stuff as crap as this at 14


awww

shes taken james blunt out of her top friends....


Probably more like 100%

It's the age where you get really pretentious and want to tell the entire world why they're going wrong by writing worthy 'social consciousness' songs without realising how little you yourself know about the world. Which is actually admirably idealistic but the songs never quite work.

In a way this is the brilliance and problem with Myspace. It is great she can get her songs up there and get feedback but people often need time to develop their talent and find their direction.

In a way I think there's a risk in exposing yourself to an audience that soon (especially 'cos you'll find cruel bastards like me taking the piss and that can undermine your confidence!) because maybe it means people start to judge you and tell you which direction to go in when you need to find that out for yourself. Feedback can be problematic in this sense 'cos people have their own agendas and ideas of what they want to see you do.


?

Come on John. You're an intelligent adult and - judging the exchanges we've had - a nice guy too. So what was the point in leaving that comment in the first place?

She likes James Blunt. big fucking deal. Last time i checked, folks were entitled to their personal tastes no matter how insipid.

James Blunt has become some kind of shorthand here on DiS, hasn't he? whenever there's a need for some indie bonding, slagging the Blunt is a safe option because nobody is going to come to his defense, so there's no risk of damamging your reputation.
What i don't understand is why folks here are even aware of him?
Blunt doesn't even exist in my universe. There's way way way too much stuff to listen to in this world without turning on the radio and being bombarded with shite, and telly where you're likely to see the likes of Blunt is very very easy to avoid.

All I really know about the Blunt's music is that he's sold a hell of a lot of records. I have NEVER heard anything by him other than maybe 30 seconds of 'You're Beautiful', but going by that alone I can understand why people would think they like it. Its utterly harmless. Its bland and shallow, just like a majority of the population of the UK. But that doesn't mean folks need to be berated for liking it... otherwise you may as well start slagging people off for liking Corn Flakes, or tea, or Coronation Street.


It was a joke at some songbird's expense

Which was retracted when I realised she was 14.
And I think I clearly have much more of an issue with Blunt than you. Huge issues. A wide range of wideranging far-reaching issues with him, his music, and everything he represents. He's a fucking airhead aristocrat posing as some everyman John Lennon figure.
Yup.
Not going to go into it again as it's all been pretty much said already.
But I disagree that it's harmless.


I'm not even convinced John Lennon was an "everyman John Lennon" figure

There isn't any point in going into the James Blunt argument again but I disagree that people slag him off just 'cos he's a soft target.

I love music and it's hugely important to me - like msot others who post on here. And there are singer-songwriters who write songs with intelligence, passion, humour, originality and entertainment but struggle to finance what they're doing. So when extortionate amounts of money are spent on someone who to me exhibits none of these traits, it genuinely angers me.

And maybe it is harmless and I over-react to it but I feel the best music is a powerful, life-affirming, even life-changing force but radio stations instead feed people pleasant, inoffensive background music that seems to be designed not to upset them or challenge challenge them in anyway.

It's like if your a chef and you see people eating ready meals or fast food all the time. To criticise it risks (possibly fair) accusations of being snobbish and elitist but, at the same time, it still feels really important to do so.


:'-(

Seemed funny until I noticed she was 14.
Now I just bullied a child into not having Blunt in her top friends.
A hollow victory.


yes, hollow perhaps.

but a victory nonetheless.


Sad

It's sad for somebody of your age to bully a 14 yr old on myspace. It's really sad to come and brag about it on a message board.


It was a JOKE

A JOKE A JOKE A JOKE YOU IDIOT.
Now get out of my face.


He's astonishingly right.

What you've done is actually embarrassing.

Ask Crablin to delete the thread Brainlove, and we can forget it ever happened.


tee hee

Shame on you John, Shaaaaaaaaaaame ooooooooon yoooooooooooou!!!!!!!


It's not as bad as the time I pushed a young mother and her child onto the tube tracks because

the child was holding a carrier back with a 'back to bedlam' logo on it. I mean, I think the response on the platform was pretty mixed, some people laughed and some people thought it was band out of order. The arresting officer thought it was pretty funny though, and the jury selection was excellent. Even the judge guffawed when the witnesses were giving their statements. So I got off scott free! Who would have thought it.


Hurrah John !

Now if you could convince my wife that Blunt is shit...


Do you want me to hassle her on MySpace?

Maybe I should charge a fee for this service...


Yeah, you bastard. Get out.

lol*

Joke.


I might be being blind

But i can't find the comment. What did you write? But she is totally shite though.


like...

read the thread.


HA! HA! HA!

you massive bastard!


Innit.


Posting......

any of your songs up on myspace soon John?





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - An Essential Dozen: 2008's best albums, so far