Drowned in Sound

Search


Home > Reviews > Live


Antony Johnsons 3
Date: 05/12/2005
no votes
?
by Ross Bennett

If Antony and The Johnsons hadn’t won the Mercury Music Prize earlier this year – sending sales of I Am A Bird Now soaring - there is a high chance that tonight I wouldn’t be so squashed amongst the mass of devotees that have made his UK jaunt a complete sell-out. However, when an artist is this intense, passionate and just so damn powerful, a few thousand adoring fans in West London is the least you’d expect.

From the moment the huge figure of Antony shuffles onto his piano stool, there is complete silence - you can hear a pin drop. All eyes are on the guy with that voice – a voice that divides opinion like no other. Some have said (unbelievably) that his voice is ‘horrible’ which couldn’t be further from the truth. From a beautifully understated ‘Cripple And The Starfish’ through a stirring ‘You Are My Sister’ (Boy George included) to an iridescent ‘Hope There’s Someone’, it is a voice that’s seemingly not of this world - such is the unique, otherness of Antony’s delivery. There is no current equivalent.

What is clearly evident throughout the evening is the British-born giant's ability to turn someone else’s music into his own. He plays no less than three covers tonight – Moondog’s ‘Always A Loneliness’, Leonard Cohen’s ‘The Guests’ and Lou Reed’s ‘Candy Says’ – all of which fall away from their original form, only to be remoulded by these devoted musicians and Antony’s quite incredible command of melody. During the encore, the audience get to experience this gift first hand, when, during the acapella of ‘Trust Your Mother’, he has the crowd sing the harmonies. What’s so exciting about this performance - ‘gig’ sounds far too ordinary – is the feeling of affirmation in the music. Beneath the questions of transgender, the images of violence and pain, and the Warholian iconography, there lies something simply magical and forever enchanting. Which makes tonight very, very special indeed.

Post a new comment on this review

...

I saw the guy in York, and I had similar feelings. I was like a huge cheesy cliche from a soap opera with the phrases I was using to describe my 'emotions'. That's usually something the cynic in me is desperately trying to escape from.

After recently being far too involved in noise guitar/drum & bass and the like, stripping music down in this 'classic' manner really woke me up to my own priorities in music.

Truly incredible.


He's safe for liberals.

So, if he was a hetrosexaul black man would he be as popular among the white liberals? It's edgy dinner party music packaged to appeal to arty types. He can sing, but I doubt he would be on DiS and NME had he looked like Usher...

And he sings like Stoofer (sp?) the cat from Harry Hill's old show.


yes

Black people wouldn't really have a voice like Antony though? It's a really "white" voice.


i actually

envisaged him as a huge black guy before i saw a picture of him.
i was almost disappointed.


Yes,

I'm glad you said that. When I first heard 'Hope There's Someone', I imagined a really old black guy.


What?

Dragging everything down to the level of race and class is like, SO over... you boring moron.

When I first heard the, I knew of his appearance because the friend who excitedly introduced me to him had just seen him in the film The Animal Factory, but we both agreed he sounds like Nina Simone.


...

yeah, but with any artist, their sexual orientation and ethnicity/race blah, will change their listenership. it is an issue with most people for every record they buy, even yourself (as much as you'd love to deny it).

i won't lie - a big appeal for me is in his transgendered ways, and therefore lyrics, and i'm sure that's the same with a lot of people (i won't claim to know anything about the guy bar his lyrics, as i actually know nothing).

to try and claim that 'white liberals' would shun him if he was black is bullshit too. it would surely be the other way round. besides, he really does have a 'white' voice?!

oh, don't you just hate the world?


it's true

i hate blacks
i only like Saul Williams cos he's not too ghetto


Saw him in Canada...

....this summer, some huge ornate church in Vancouver, and it was amazing! Admittedly I had one too many in the Loose Moose around the corner beforehand and the gig is a little bit hazy. These things happen though.


...

lovely review Ross.


Good

review. I went on Tuesday and it sounds like both nights were of similar quality though there was no Boy George.

His voice sounded amazing in the venue as did the strings and piano.

What surprised me was his banter with the crowd. I was expecting a big lumbering shy giant but he actually chatted quite a bit and made a few amusing comments that went down well.

9/10


Actually...

I'm right.


Viktor Yushchenko

Is that an outbreak of acne on his face in that pic? Or has he been poisoned like the man in the subject line in this post was?





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Devastations on album gestation: "It's generally pretty personal"