Drowned in Sound

Search


Home > Reviews > Live


battles astoria square
Date: 14/05/2008
18 votes
?
by Charles Ubaghs

As Tyondai Braxton reminds us tonight, it’s been just over a year since Battles released their debut LP Mirrored, and since then it’s been nothing but a constant ascent for a band who’ve proven surprisingly popular among a certain section of the populace.

So it’s to much fanfare that Battles return to London tonight before heading off to Minehead for the Explosions in the Sky-curated All Tomorrow’s Parties. First up though, are Fuck Buttons and Dirty Projectors, fresh from their slots from the Pitchfork ATP the previous weekend.

DiS accidentally misses Fuck Buttons due to a poorly read schedule, so first up on our bill is David Longstreth’s Dirty Projectors. Live, as on record, Longstreth and company are a difficult proposition to embrace on first impression. Tightly wound and decidedly left of field, the band’s experimental tactics and Youssou N’Dour by way of Bedford Avenue vocals demand a slow immersion into their singular world. But when that eureka moment finally hits, it’s difficult to deny that Dirty Projectors are rightfully deserving of recent praise.

The audience are certainly appreciative of everything they’ve witnessed, but the shouts of adoration are reserved for Battles as bassist David Konopka takes to the stage and starts off a looping rhythm before being joined by his comrades in arms. Like some rhythmically driven father figure, John Stanier proves himself to be the foundation for which everything else comes forth as he wails away on his drums in the middle of the stage. It’s difficult to tear ones eyes away from him, but the rest of the band certainly step up to the plate as they wind their way through extended renditions of their work. Whether it’s math-rock, future-funk or some other hybrid nomenclature that has yet to be argued over on message boards, Battles are a band visibly enraptured by what they create as a unit. Though, it’s not until the now seminal ‘Atlas’ comes in mid-set that the crowd start to heave in an almost uncontrollable fashion. It’s an explosive moment that, even though the song just might prove to be an albatross around the band’s neck in the long term, projects an alternative of what the very terms dance and rock could mean while once again cementing their place amongst the modern vanguard.

Taken as a whole, tonight is a fitting victory lap for the year that was. The only question now is whether or not the men in Battles can do it all again with LP number two. Fingers are now officially crossed in anticipation.

- - - In Photos - - -
Photos: Lucy Johnston

Fuck Buttons





- - -
Dirty Projectors

- - -
Battles





- - -

Post a new comment on this review

Great photos!


The photos are

omgawesome.


*blushes*

thank you! :D

First time i've been to the Astoria and there be no photo pit - was rather strange but great for dancing!


Good review too!

Amazing, amazing live band - am crossing fingers for album #2 also...


yeah,

utterly swell photographing. that one of dr drums is mega mega mega. :)


again..

thank you - really glad you like them! ATP EITS shots coming up - lets hope they're ok! :)


You neglected

the Apollo 440 album mysteriously played between acts. I thought I would be embarassed having bought this at the time, but it still had its moments!


yeah what the fuck?

apollo 440...

Fuck Buttons=no musical merit whatsoever
DPs=genius
Battles=couldn't pay enough attention 'cause still thinking about how genius DPs were


I'd rather be DP'd than listen to DP again

Unfortunately for me, DP are the worst band I've ever seen live.
I can see how they elicit some form of pleasure for fans of progressive-anything, but the idea of DP far outshines the reality.
Decent musicians - check. Ambitious and creative - check. Able to play intricate harmonies in time with each other - fail miserably. Contrived and smug performance - check. Felt sorry for the obviously decent drummer marooned in Longstreth's hapless musical world. Although we came to see how FB's music would go down live, thank God for Battles, who displayed the superb playing precision necessary to pull off this kind of music.


wow I disagree

I actually think DP are the BEST band i've ever seen live!

but fair enough I'm not going to be all "you're wrong you philistine bastard" as is the norm on the internet :)

I personally thought their harmonies and musicianship was not only "decent" it was nothing short of amazing. the harmonies on the last album were PERFECTLY created note for note. I couldn't believe my ears...

The drummer for me was undoubtedly the worst thing about them, in that he was too RAWK and perhaps not as subtle as i'd like. He also hits the drums far louder than is necessary

And also, I thought Battles were great but after so many listens to their recordings I found the drummer to actually be the weakest link in the band, after seeing them live

The "superb playing precision" I found to be lacking

Dunno if anyone out there has seen a band called The Bays, similarly a "supergroup" who play all instrumental music. Their drummer is a total session muso which is NOT cool, but his tightness and precision really is necessary for the music they play.

I, very much to my surprise found the drummer to be slightly not good enough for the band to realise their musical ideas to their fullest potential.

but, of course, they're only humans after all

ooh, controversssssial


What's not cool about being a total session muso?

I don't understand what's wrong with that? Surely if you've spent years practicing an instrument and can make a living playing with a variety of different people that's ace? Am I missing something?


you said...

..." future-funk "

can't stop laughing. a new genre is here.....

what horrid words.

great gig though.


I can't take...

credit for that one. Someone else described them as such in some other publication somewhere.


Battles...

were my new favourite band of last year. Pushing new ideas and I don't think the drummer is the weakest link at all, far from it. As a drummer I could only dream of doing some of the things that guy can but as you said it's all about opinion.

Can't wait to see them at Glastonbury.

Agreed great photos!


Dirty Projectors

Dirty Projectors are definitely progressive if progressive = off tune, off beat, too bad they took so long to get off the stage!

It would have been a better evening without them.


Ahem

More importantly did everyone witness and have photographic evidence of the fact that Ian put my t-shirt on his amp...anyone?