Drowned in Sound

Search



Prince Planet Earth

Prince: Planet Earth

no votes
?
by Alex Denney
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 15/07/2007

Okay, hands up – who bought it? For reasons unclear, Prince has chosen to release Planet Earth through The Mail On Sunday. For a one-time gender bender whose explicit lyrics flicked Vs at the petit-bourgeois conservatism of an era, this is a sequence of events which aforementioned rag would no doubt describe as ‘vile’. It still feels wrong even typing it. And for those of you that did choose to grease the palms of those loveable fear mongers for your funky fix, here’s the worst part: it wasn’t really worth it.

Yup, as Faustian pacts go, Planet Earth’ll leave you feeling decidedly short-changed. The title track is a blustery epic that retains something of the creepy insularity that permeated Around The World In A Day, and suffers the twin misfortune of resembling both Michael Jackson and, via a creamy jazz interlude somewhere in the middle, Barry Manilow. And 'Guitar' is a slick FM groove sorely lacking in edge – it used to be that Prince could sing about incest or fellatio and make either seem like an agreeable way to spend an evening, but the newly-religious Prince has to content himself with penning neutered-sounding six-string serenades.

After this, er, hi-octane opening, things take a turn for the schmoove. One or two obvious exceptions notwithstanding, ballads have never exactly been Prince’s forte, sharing as he does modern-day R ‘n’ B’s predilection for schmaltzy production values and trilling vocal histrionics, and unfortunately Planet Earth is brimming with them. 'Somewhere Here On Earth' is a personality-free ballad that could have been written by computers, and 'Mr Goodnight' boasts an attractive chorus which sounds very TLC, but sadly revisits its author’s ill-advised dalliances with rap. Prince’s hackneyed loverman flow frequently comes up short in the syllable stakes, and ends up revealing how a night spent on the receiving end of His Purpleness’ attentions is improbably dull: “We can watch Chocolat on the big screen / before we convene in the pool”. Let’s just see what’s on telly, eh Prince?

When he does eventually tire of serving up this pasty slop, he drops in a couple of reminders of former glories, 'All The Midnights In The World' and 'Chelsea Rodgers' demonstrating the melodic yin to the rhythmic yang of Prince’s undisputed genius. The former has a surprisingly thoughtful lyric and pretty, almost folksy melody, and faintly resembles 'Starfish & Coffee' from his ‘80s masterpiece Sign O’ The Times, while the latter is a tightly-marshalled funk jam that wouldn’t disgrace the aforementioned record.

Sadly, this isn’t enough to distract from the muzaky, phoned-in feel elsewhere on the album, and ultimately you’re left to dwell unhappily on the image of Mail readers nationwide slipping the disc into their Mondeo car stereos and thinking to themselves: “Y’ know, maybe this guy isn’t such a pervert after all. I’ll check out his other stuff.”

They’re in for a shock.

  • Prince 5 / 10

one of

his weakest ever albums

very disappointing, probably about 4 more points than I'd have given it.


That's just cos you had to buy the Mail

Bring back hanging!


My mum gets the Mail on Sunday

and I happened to be there this weekend. I thought long and hard (about 15 seconds) whether to take the CD home with me, but finally I consigned it to being binned by my mum.

Ban this sick filth!


Did anyone

actually believe that this album would be any good?

I thought the entire reason that he had released it for free is because no-one would have bought it anyway...


it's not 'bad' exactly

just totally irrelevant in the context of his formidable body of work. you don't know how the guy who wrote Sign 'O' The Times can work up the interest to write stuff like this... surely he's boring himself? but no, he does sound like he 'means it', which is a little worrying.

track 8 is pretty pumping though and it's one of those good ipod albums, when the odd track pops up on shuffle you can appreciate the basic songcraft more.


worst lyric:

"in this digital aaaage....you can just paaaage me."

oh, princey princey princey


prince doesnt really make bad albums

i have nearly all Prince's albums, and the best of them (which includes more of his 90/00s output than he is given credit for) blow all competition away. this one is alright, pretty much on a par with 3121, still not a patch on The Rainbow Children and Musicology


he hasn't

made a great album since 1987

most albums since have been "ok" at best...although they have contained some excellent stand alone tracks

I agree with one of the comments on here...he sounds bored, like he's just going through the motions

he'll still totally kick arse live tho!


The Rainbow Children...

...is bloody terrible.

Around The World In A Day is his best IMHO.


I heard a really interesting financial brekadown

that actually pointed out that by releasing it via the mail, prince will get more money than if he released it on CD (whether stonking good or no) assuming he gets about £2 per Cd (which I believe s the averag.)

interesting, no?


Let's see, what other free CD offers we have...

Michael Jackson's new CD will be included in boxes of Franzia

Lady Sov's next CD: free with purchase of Big Mac Meal (super-sized only)

Paris Hilton's sophomore disk (working title "I've been set Free!") in copies of People magazine


Planet Earth

(the title track) is pretty decent. The rest of the album fails to come up to par with it though. I can't say I was expecting a masterpiece or in fact, anything particularly good at all - the last Prince song to float my boat was Gold with the NPG and that's, what, 10 years old and a brilliant abberation in a period of complete crap. There will probably never be a Prince album as good as Purple Rain ever again, but I can hope for a few special moments once in a while.


Once Upon A Time

Prince was the Pluse and he rocked the world.

Hey but Time and Tide take their toll.

I saw prince many years ago and he had so many Hitz he had to do a 20 minute medley just to get them out of the way.

In France a skinny man died of a big disease with a little name.