Drowned in Sound

Search



strawberry jam

Animal Collective: Strawberry Jam

8 votes
?
by Nicholas Garcia

It’s been two years since Animal Collective’s last full-length release proper. Feels’was stunning, the kind of album that possessed the ability to seduce anyone willing to surrender just a little time to it. From ‘Did You See The Words’ right through to ‘Turn Into Something’; the chemistry between those reverb-washed guitars and contagious, asymmetric melodies ensured each of the nine cuts hit on a strange, sweet angle. In a list of all-time favourite love records, Feels, in its skewed, intimate glory, sits pretty high up there. Any qualms, just ask one simple question: did Marvin ever pen a line as damn honest as ‘The Purple Bottle’’s “Sometimes I’m naked and thank god sometimes your naked”? No. He did not.

Back in October 2005, Feels could have easily gone down as the seminal work from the Baltimore four-piece’s consistently remarkable output. However, with the release of Strawberry Jam, this debate is once more thrown to the wind. Beside its predecessor, …Jam possesses little desire to sit comfortably with its listener, instead stretching out, sprawling and cavernous. Whilst the visceral joy of Feels remains in part, it is joined in equal measure by a sense of violence and anxiety. In mining much darker emotional territory, Animal Collective have produced the record of their career; …Jam is a masterpiece of mood, composition and delivery. Even in an age of tiring critical hyperbole, it is difficult to deny that this album is the most profound (re)imagining of the pop music aesthetic of recent times.

From the very outset, a transformation has clearly occurred. Whilst structurally …Jam largely adheres to pop conventions - most tracks being based around a simple verse/chorus progression - an immediate discord is struck by the treatment of the vocals. As Avey Tare’s voice permeates the gurgling introduction to ‘Peacebone’, it enters unprocessed, unflanked by harmony and dominant in the mix. Utilised throughout …Jam, this new aesthetic enables the listener to inhabit the album’s lyrical landscapes in all of their glittering light and ominous shadow. With this fresh perspective, the popular misconception of Avey’s lyrics solely promoting the surreal becomes futile. At the heart of ‘Peacebone’’s dreamscape of dinosaur wings and cloud-carved mountains, a lament on the pitfalls of nostalgia clearly resides. Between the frightened babies and coloured water of ‘Fireworks’, an explicit awareness of eternal transience lingers.

The power of the bare voice reaches its apex in the epic ‘For Reverend Green’. Over six and a half grinding minutes, Avey line-by-line constructs a Brueghelian tableaux of American moral anxiety inhabited by burnt children, scores of wasted Brooklyners and a bulimic weight contest queen. Delivery is the key factor here. It’s the juxtaposition between Deakin’s cold, delay-heavy guitars, Panda’s increased-heartbeat floor toms and that voice or more specifically that scream which secures a devastating emotional impact. A howl in the dark against the neglect of insight, the dominance of the material over the spiritual, ‘Reverend’ is both …Jam’s most overtly political moment and its crowning glory.

The slow-burning ‘#1’ provides a welcome contrast to a largely rhythm-driven set. The only track to utilise overt vocal modulation, its ethereal narration serves a very distinct purpose in embodying a departed father figure. Almost mantra-like in mood, ‘#1’’s impressionistic depiction of a fractured family unit reaches no resolve, its tumbling arpeggio simply trailing off into eventual silence. A departure for the band, it feels like an almost mistaken, but very much welcome, step into the unknown.

‘Cuckoo Cuckoo’ is another moment in which Animal Collective reach a new level of compositional mastery and broaden their territory. Based around a simple piano motif, the song’s incessant peaks and troughs evoke claustrophobia in an alarmingly vivid, physical sense. Once again the vocal delivery is fearless, Avey placing the surreal alongside the painfully direct to unprecedented effect.

Panda Bear, conjuror of infectious, spontaneous melody, doesn’t disappoint with album closer ‘Derek’ and the tribal chant that is ‘Chores’. Alongside ‘Peacebone’ and ‘Winter Wonder Land’, ‘Chores’ is perhaps the finest example of the lean physicality which makes …Jam such a joy to experience. Noah’s unique ability as a composer is in channelling the day-to-day through melody to reach the sublime, and ‘Derek’ achieves this effortlessly. In just three minutes, with little more than percussion, guitar and voice, Noah transports the narrative of a childhood pet dog to another place altogether. It is the perfectly displaced closing gesture, strangely tying up all that has come before and all that is to follow.

In its very placement, ‘Derek’ confirms that, with or without major record deal, Animal Collective have no time for self-serving grand gestures, but only the pursuit of divine pop music by strictly earthly means.

  • Animal Collective 10 / 10

Crikey!

Pitchfork gave this a 9.3, too. I supsect this will be hailed as THE album of the year.


10/10?

Certainly closer than the Jamie T mark but Strawberry Jam isn't perfect enough to warrant full marks in my opinion... maybe it'll grow, but that much? Doubtful.

I'm not even sure how many albums I own that would warrant a 10... 'OK Computer' maybe? 'Rubber Soul'? The first Velvet Underground record?

10 is pretty sacred, really.


I never really considered 10/10

as the best album evar, you know. I would give 10/10 to an album with a flawless structure, unique sound, and ambition. I gave this one a 5/5 stars.


Now THIS

I can get behind.

SJ gets better with every listen.


I could not agree with this wonderful review any more

it actually is a masterpiece.

i did not realize this fully until putting it into my cd player this morning, having listened to it on download for months.

it is so perfect. the artwork. the sounds. the words. the feeling.

i think it might be my unexpected album of the year.
i can't quite contemplate how they continue to get better and better and progress


sigh

I wish panda bear sung more, I find avery's vocals truly annoying.


wow

never seen a 10/10 on DiS before.


Yep

Now it can be filed alongside the likes of Jamie t...


This

really is a grower, the songs just unravel with each listen.


Strongly agree...

" If I'm on stage and I'm thinking about how I've played this song a lot, or I'm thinking, "I wonder how many people are out there," that's not a good headspace to be in as a performer. So I think it's good to be in a state that you're not totally familiar with." - Noah Lennox.

This just about sums up half of why I love animal collective. The other half of me is won over by how utterly listenable they are on record without sounding stale and familiar.

Thank goodness for AC.


Good Review

It'a 10 for me as well, my only fear is that I'm listening to it far too much and won't want to listen to it again a few months down the line.

I love Sun Tongs and Feels but I found there was a bit too much filler there, sprawling songs with lengthy build ups that never quite get there. There's none of this on Strawberry Jam imo.For Reverend Green is my song of the year so far by a long long way.

Cheers


Not sure if it's a ten

but this record gets better every time you listen to it. It's the most listenable album they've released and 'For Revered Green' is actually incredible.


Nah

More like a 4, or a 5. This is dull dull dull compared to their previous stuff and they seemed to have had all their charm stripped away. Sung Tongs > Feels > Strawberry Jam. I think I see a pattern here.

The Wire's review was spot on IMO


no way is this a ten

this record sounds fucking horrible. The flow and structure are superb, and the level of compositional skill on show is really quite impressive. But the production is near unlistenable at points. Its just one big trebly stonewalled mess with absolutely no subtlety or dynamism in the sound. Jacknife Lee murdering Phil Spector with a fuck off compressor. And a lot of the vocals take this even further, high pitch squeals which add to the muddiness and provide very little in terms of complimentary tone (although the growliness on tracks like Reverend Green does work much better).

As well as this, since the vocals are mixed much higher and clearer means you can really hear the general clumsiness of a lot of the lyrics. Feels was a little bit dodgy in this respect (that "sometimes i'm naked" line is one i might pick out), but Strawberry Jam just goes above and beyond. They often make sense in some sort of grand centralised scheme, and themes do show themselves throughout, but they just don't sound very pleasing or beautiful. "Cringeworthy" might be a more adequate descriptor for certain couplets

You could argue that its AC's prerogative as to their sound and production, and maybe that's what the decaying strawberry on the front represents: something sweet and fruity (the quite commercial and poppy songwriting) which has decomposed to bitterness and distaste. But whatever their intentions i think the auditory aesthetics detract massively from the album as a whole


AUDIOGEEK

you my friend, i feel have lost the joy of music due to your obsession with music making and theory.

shame.


absolute bullshit

its pretty patronising to suggest that i've "lost the joy of music" because i care about things other than the "songs". To me, good production is as important to music as many of its other features.

i could turn your comment on its head and say "you've lost the joy of a really good sounding record what with your myspace streaming and youtube and iTunes". But that would be SOOOOO fucking patronising


I don't think it sounds like that through neglect or anything

I think that's just the way they wanted it.

They've always liked trebly music (danse/spirit) and they said pretty often they wanted it sharp and "brain stab" was used once to describe the new sound. It sounds pretty full to my ears anyhow. It was produced and recorded by the same guy as feels, so...

The lyrics are a matter of taste, I like them.


I also have no idea what it would sound like

if it wasn't produced in the way it was. I really think they suit the songs.

It's also nice that aswell as changing the kind of songs they play and make they totally change the feel and texture of the music. You can hear the different production types throughout.


i understand what you're saying

but i think it would have been made a lot better with a more dynamic, realistic sound. Its just a relentless, overpowering noise which loses any power it holds by being so relentless, (if you follow). I find it really draining rather than joyous, particularly at any sort of high volume

you're right though, it probably is a leftover of their more abstract earlier work, and they've always loved the treble dial. And i'm sure it's at least partially self imposed. But in my opinion it doesn't work at all

the lyrics suck too ;)


it's pretty much just animal collective

and it's also pretty much just not to your taste apparently.
it's just the way they wanted it, or they'd have done it differently.
if you have any problems with it, that's just the way it goes - they've played, recorded and engineered it to their taste and this is what has been made.
simple.
'shame you don't see eye to eye with their sound (woah...sense-making...no...), but a lot of other people really do.
maybe the sound they love so much will grow on you over the coming weeks...


and the lyrics

i've always loved so so much, because they always just sound like them, and like no-one else out there.
the way they say things is so different to the way anyone else seems to put things.
i love it
and it really, really does grow on you.
i LOVE this album.

fully deserved 10/10 and possible album of the year status.
so far the only contender that comes to mind would be Mirrored, but to be honest i think they're destined for 2nd place after this masterpiece.


crikey

i need to give this album more of a proper listen then.


Sorry, I used to love this band

And Feels deserved the 10 that's given to this new record.

This stuff is terrible, the sound of a band breaking up, saving their good stuff for solo records while half-assing their way through music they hardly seem to care about. Peacebone and Fireworks just wander around and go nowhere.

Is this really the band that produced a landmark track like "Banshee Beat"?

RstJ


It is a shame

you can't just enjoy it for what it is.
The entire point of animal collective is to continually evolve and sound completely different with every album, to continually progress and push the limits of their capabilities to avoid being monotonous.
This album is how they want to sound now, and in my opinion, it is something that is quite a childish and innocent sound, which sort of fits with the album.

Anyway, it does not matter if you don't like, i don't really care about the state of your ears, but it is jsut boring for you to tell everyone they are wrong things.

music is subjective the last time i checked, and A.J.Ayer is a genius.


yes

yes and more yes, thank you smezzer for calling it out like it is. enough hyperbole around this shit show of an album


hmm

pretty much criticising Animal Collective for be Animal Collective.


great review

Not sure if I rate it quite as high as 10 but that will remain to be seen on afew more listens. I find the first half of the album draws me back alot more than the second half. Probably as it contains my FAVOURITE SONG OF THE YEAR - "For Reverend Green". Aveys voice on that particular track is just quite unbelievable.


Huuh?

I can well imagine people who have never enjoyed animal collective disliking this album, but for people who liked previous albums I really can't see how the new album is much of a turning point. As early as 'spirit...' they crafted electronic pop (Chocolate Girl) springs to mind. If SJ is so vastly different to what has come before isn't it great that there is a band who isn't afraid to change directions and risk alienating their fans rather than make Feels mark II? At least you can be relatively safe in the knowledge that the next album is probably going to be different again.


it's just a bit... dull

6 or 7 out of ten, not a patch on sung tongs.


DiScussion

Great!


Brilliant record and review

A nine for me though. Was thoroughly disappointed at first but not love it.

Second favourite behind Feels.

Incredible, incredible band.


10

flip. you never give 10's lightly so it must be good. i remember when dis gave 'ys' a 10. was a good day.


10 ?

you're kidding right ?


i have

bought one cd off the back of DiS giving it ten without hearing any music from it. it was saul williams. so maybe i will take another risk

i've been trying for a while to get into animal collective. is this a good reference point?


yeah

tis the best they have come up with in my opinion


awkward

is this really a 10? nothing else, but a question.


Never really been a big fan

but this is gorgeous, give it time and it'l infect you with its sheer beauty. amaaaazin


strawberry jam..

is too good for it's own good.
it's perfect.
which bothers me.
a lot.


disagree

ive not listened to the record many times, but ive got to say i think their best work was sung tongs. and even that wasnt a 10/10, because of visiting friends. but SJ is ace, yeah, but its not a 10.