Drowned in Sound

Search



Comets On Fire Blue Cathedral

Comets On Fire: Blue Cathedral

no votes
?
by Mike Diver
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 13/09/2004
  • Label: Sub Pop
When Julian Cope gets excited about a band, it’s only right that we, the record-buying public, take notice. After all, Mr Cope is a certified loon, so ignoring him would only see him bang on about this, that or the other with increased passion and gusto. In this case, the other is Comets On Fire, a five-piece straight out of the Bay Area. And you know what? The man Cope might just be on to something.

‘Blue Cathedral’ is Comets On Fire’s third album, following a self-titled debut in 2001 and ‘Field Recordings From The Sun’ the following year. Their expansion to a quintet following the recruitment of additional guitarist Ben Chasny adds depth to the already rich tapestry of sound showcased on ‘Field Recordings…’, leading to an album that is both abundant in depth and variety, as well as in terrifying walls of noise and gaping chasms of silence. The mastering of such dynamics is a tricky process, one that many attempt but few perfect, but Comets On Fire have nailed it.

‘Blue Cathedral’ begins in spectacular fashion: ‘The Bee And The Cracking Egg’ is the kind of frazzled, psychedelic brain-toaster than you know The Icarus Line would love to have penned. Indeed, if they’d grown up in Somerset on a steady diet of King Crimson and early Genesis as well as My Bloody Valentine and Spacemen 3, then they’d probably be producing records in a similar vein. It’s a monstrous curtain raiser, and one that really doesn’t have you expecting what comes next. ‘Pussy Footin’ The Duke’ is Yes if they’d emerged from obscurity today rather than 35 years ago, the cascading keys worthy of Rick Wakeman himself. It chimes rather than booms in the style of the previous track, and is purely instrumental. First-song service is immediately resumed though, with ‘Whiskey River’ winding its way through seven minutes of sonic ecstasy, Chasny and founding guitarist/vocalist Ethan Miller creating almighty aural structures with just a few pounding and dangerously drawn-out chords.

But still Comets On Fire refuse to be pegged. If the bombastic psychedelica isn’t floating your boat, along comes ‘Brotherhood Of The Harvest’, another instrumental number. Its ambient, duelling guitars recall mid-period Pink Floyd (‘Wish You Were Here’ etc), something that may have occurred to the band too, considering the song title (think about it, kids). Closer ‘Blue Tomb’ is the high watermark of the record though, a ten-minute-plus epic that combines elements of everything you’ve heard thus far, and scatters them, creating a multicoloured, mouth-watering musical landscape. You can just picture Cope, in unadulterated pleasure, skipping about his house in his underpants to it. Bonkers? You betcha. But ‘Blue Cathedral’ is something you must hear, be you a fan of Muse, Cave In, Dead Meadow or any other slightly prog-influenced outfit, or simply of pure, sonic excess and indulgence. This is exactly that, concentrated on a single disc. And it’s fantastic. We, the record-buying public, need music like this. We demand it. It's our addiction. It sets fire to the soul, expands the mind and, most of all, rocks heavier than entire undersea mountain ranges.

Just don’t listen to this on drugs, kids; your mind may detatch itself from your body altogether.

  • Comets On Fire 9 / 10

Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

Nice. Now I am REALLY champing at the bit.
Nice to read some good evocative description, free of self-indulgent gaff 'n' all!;~)

(Ahem...hint-unlike that Pitchfork review!)

Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

pitchfork suck. they need to take their heads out of their arses and actually write about music

go DiS. another quality review.

Re: Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

Pitchfork have never written anything quite as hilariously pretentious as this though: http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/5206.html

Re: Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

haha, i thought that was gonna be the Sonic Nurse review ;)

pitchfork were surprisingly on the money with this one though (even if they neglected to use the words "bad britpop"): http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/record-reviews/r/razorlight/up-all-night.shtml

Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

Tis true...mighty fine review, cannae wait for the album.

For true up-their-own-arse pretention, check out the review of Relationship Of Command on Pitchfork. Although it always makes me crease that they seem to deliberately give poor marks to albums that otherwise receive universal acclaim yet still find it in their hearts to give a Save Ferris album 9.5 out of 10.

Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

Pitchfork is the best music review site on the net, the reviews are ten times for intelligent than anything else out there and they make an effort to review all genres... they have great features and single reviews. Just a great site with great writers who not only have some fun within the constraints of a music review (like most of the DiS writers) but also get down to looking at the music in a little depth... the marking system is also much more accurate than the 5 star system of a simple mark out of ten... yeh great site. mind you so is this one

Re: Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

Aye, pitchfork can be really good. They write about an impressive variety of stuff. Was lmao at the Razorlight review earlier!

I just wasn't keen on their review of the Comets album. Personal taste 'n' all.

Re: Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

they seem to think that english music is either radiohead, trying to be radiohead, or utter shit. to deny showbiz and asleep in the back, two of the best albums released in the last 5 years, decent marks just shows how badly they get it wrong.

oh and if you thought the relationship of command review was pretentious, try reading heathen chemistry. no.

Pitchfork

I guess I agree that they reference Radiohead a lot. But I don't think they have the negative view of British music you suggest. Quite the opposite, in fact.

I think it's more a generational thing, and most of them loved Britpop. Their frame of reference is as much Blur as Radiohead.

And for pretentiousness, I seem to remember the review of the new Sparta album was right up there with their best.

Re: Pitchfork

pitchfork is a zine for students, by students.

FUCK STUDENTS.

jeez.

Re: Pitchfork

And fuck you too sir;~)

Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

Ah yeah...holy shit, I read that fucker! There's a fine line between providing a straight-up (and possibly dull) review and going off on some pretentious rant that says nothing about the actual music...I can practically picture their reviewers jacking off in self-satisfaction as they write these reviews.

Re: Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

Picked this up in the US last week, very nice indeed.

Comets On Fire - Blue Cathedral

This is an amazing album. It is a modern psycadellic masterpiece go now and order it.

I agree

pitchfork spend far too much time trying to dictate what's "cool" that they forget the music.

They should pull their heads out from asses and actually properly listen to an album before reviewing it, regardless of whether they like the artist or not.